Updates to our Terms of Use

We are updating our Terms of Use. Please carefully review the updated Terms before proceeding to our website.

Sunday, May 19, 2024 | Back issues
Courthouse News Service Courthouse News Service

End of an era in Poland: Ultra-nationalists get the boot, Tusk takes over

Donald Tusk is returning as Poland's prime minister. The mainstream conservative is expected to bring Warsaw back in line with Brussels after eight years of contentious rule by Law and Justice, a conservative-nationalist party.

(CN) — Donald Tusk, a 66-year-old center-right stalwart of Polish and European politics, was set to take over as Poland's prime minister on Tuesday, ending the eight-year reign of a hard-right nationalist government in Warsaw that had become a major thorn in the side of Brussels.

Tusk won a vote of confidence in the Sejm, the Polish Parliament, on Tuesday evening and he was expected to get sworn in Wednesday. He previously served two terms as prime minister between 2007 and 2014 before leading the European Council, where he played a pivotal role in negotiations with the United Kingdom over Brexit.

For many city-dwelling liberal Poles, his return to power in Warsaw was hailed as a massive relief and promised to swing Poland back in a pro-European Union direction after eight years of ultra-conservative rule by Law and Justice, a party backed mostly by rural and small-town voters who felt left behind by Poland's post-communist economic liberalization and modernization.

During its eight years in power, Law and Justice came under furious attack from many in Brussels for being a danger to Polish and even European democracy. Warsaw faced EU sanctions for its actions to overhaul Poland's judicial system, oppose EU laws and rules, curb abortion rights, turn state media into propaganda outlets and reject asylum seekers.

With so many Poles upset at Law and Justice, Tusk returned to Polish politics after his stint in Brussels and led a broad coalition of conservative and liberal parties that set aside ideological differences to bring down Law and Justice at October parliamentary elections.

And Tusk succeeded. In the elections, Law and Justice, which is commonly known by its Polish initials PiS, took in the most votes but fell short of obtaining a majority. It won 35.4% of the ballot.

Since it won the most votes, Law and Justice was given the first chance to form a government, an effort that predictably came to an end Monday when it was forced to seek a vote of confidence in the Sejm. It lost that vote 266-190 and on Monday night the Parliament handed Tusk the opportunity to form a government.

Tusk's center-right Civic Platform will govern with the conservative Third Way and liberal New Left. Civic Platform got 30.7% of the ballot in October while Third Way and New Left picked up 14.4% and 8.6% respectively. All three parties are pro-EU.

The election saw the highest turnout since the end of communism and Law and Justice's defeat was hailed as a much-needed bright spot for those in Europe worried about a rise in far-right forces across the bloc.

However, hopes that the return of Tusk signaled a wider shift away from the far right in Europe were dashed in November when elections in the Netherlands saw one of Europe's prominent far-right leaders, Geert Wilders, take in the most votes. He is attempting to form a government.

In a speech before the Sejm Tuesday morning, Tusk called the October election a “peaceful rebellion for freedom and democracy” and vowed to bring Poland back into the mainstream of EU politics.

“An alienated Poland is a Poland exposed to the greatest risks,” Tusk said.

This was a reference to how Warsaw was scorned by EU leaders under the PiS leadership. Brussels even delayed and blocked billions of dollars in coronavirus recovery funds slated for Poland because of its refusal to undo judicial reforms deemed unlawful by EU courts.

“This madness, this embarrassment of ourselves, could have cost us more than ridicule. But I can guarantee you that we will make Poland return to its rightful place,” Tusk said, as reported by the Guardian newspaper.

Tusk also accused the former government of racist policies and rhetoric against asylum-seekers.

ADVERTISEMENT

“I protest against the xenophobia introduced by the authorities into public debate,” he said. “I protest against the hostile attitude of the authorities towards immigrants.”

But in a sign that he does not intend to throw open his country's borders to migrants, Tusk warned about “the consequences of an uncontrolled movement of people.”

“We can protect the Polish and European border and be human at the same time,” he said. “Poland can be the safest place on Earth if it does not stand alone, if it cooperates with allies and guards its borders.”

His statements reflected a toughening stance across the EU against asylum-seekers. Fear over migrants was a central theme in the Polish elections and Tusk played on those fears too.

In his speech, Tusk vowed to back Ukraine in its war against Russia. His comments came on the eve of an important EU summit this week where the bloc will vote on providing Kyiv with billions of dollars in economic and military aid and decide whether to open talks on Ukraine's bid to become an EU member. Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orbán has threatened to thwart the EU's pro-Ukraine approach.

“We will demand full mobilization of the West to help Ukraine,” Tusk said. “I can no longer listen to politicians who talk about being tired of the situation in Ukraine.”

Poland has been one of Ukraine's staunchest allies, though Law and Justice leaders began expressing doubts about supporting the war after Polish farmers and truckers started protesting the EU's decision to welcome Ukrainian grain imports and trucks. In protest over financial losses, Polish workers from these sectors have blocked the border with Ukraine.

Tusk said he would continue defending the interests of Polish farmers.

The handover of power has been tense and ugly with Law and Justice politicians angrily denouncing Tusk and those opposed to the outgoing ultra-conservatives cheering their fall from power.

In Warsaw, a cinema broadcast the live parliamentary proceedings to a popcorn-munching audience that expressed glee over the change in government and sang the Polish national anthem when Tusk was nominated as prime minister Monday evening.

“I expect the new government to settle scores with PiS, for all the wrongdoing they have committed while in power,” Tomasz, a 35-year-old ardent Tusk supporter, told Balkan Insight, a news outlet. He took off work and traveled to Warsaw from Lodz to watch the parliamentary livestream at the Kinoteka cinema.

“But it’s also important to unite this polarized country,” he said. “I don’t think the new government should forget about the people that voted for PiS, those living in the provinces or having smaller incomes.”

In a memorable scene, Jarosław Kaczyński, the 74-year-old party leader and bitter Tusk rival, took to the rostrum of the Sejm on Monday and called Tusk a “German agent.” He later told reporters that Tusk's return to power signaled an “end to Polish democracy.”

In its nationalist rhetoric, Law and Justice rails against Berlin, accusing Germany of exploiting Polish workers. The party also demanded war reparations from Germany. Tusk's maternal grandmother was German and he has sought closer relations with both Germany and France.

Once installed, Tusk's government faces big hurdles because Polish President Andrzej Duda is an ally of Law and Justice and he has the power to veto legislation.

Also, the Constitutional Tribunal, a Polish high court whose members were appointed by a parliament in the hands of Law and Justice, could block reforms and laws brought by Tusk.

Courthouse News reporter Cain Burdeau is based in the European Union.

Follow @cainburdeau
Categories / Courts, Government, International, Politics

Subscribe to Closing Arguments

Sign up for new weekly newsletter Closing Arguments to get the latest about ongoing trials, major litigation and hot cases and rulings in courthouses around the U.S. and the world.

Loading...