Updates to our Terms of Use

We are updating our Terms of Use. Please carefully review the updated Terms before proceeding to our website.

Tuesday, April 16, 2024 | Back issues
Courthouse News Service Courthouse News Service

Kremlin says Russia at ‘war’ with the West in Ukraine

For the first time, the Kremlin says Russia is at war in Ukraine, citing Western support for Kyiv. In Brussels, European Union chiefs push to make the bloc a 'war economy' capable of standing up to Russia, but they meet resistance from some nations.

(CN) — The conflict in Ukraine veered toward another major escalation on Friday after the Kremlin for the first time said it was at “war” with the West and European Union leaders pushed ahead with proposals to turn the bloc into a military superpower.

The bellicose rhetoric coming from Russia and European capitals has grown more fierce — and candid — in recent weeks as Washington's support for Kyiv falters and Ukrainian forces get pushed back on the front lines in eastern Ukraine, raising the specter that Ukraine's defensive lines may be collapsing.

Ukraine's dire state — and Russia's growing military superiority — was made clear Friday after large areas of the country, including most of Kharkiv, its second-largest city, were plunged into darkness following a massive overnight barrage of Russian missiles and drones. The strikes hit the Dnipro hydroelectric dam, a critical power source, and other power stations, leaving more than 1 million people without power. It was called the biggest attack yet on Ukraine's energy infrastructure.

On Friday, Dmitry Peskov, the Kremlin spokesman, told Argumenty i Fakty, a Russian newspaper, the country was at war with the West. Until now, the Kremlin had characterized the conflict in Ukraine as a “special military operation” and the State Duma, Russia's parliament, even passed a law forbidding Russians from calling it a war, a tool to crack down on anti-war protests.

“We are at war. Indeed, it started as a special military operation but as soon as a clique was formed and the collective West joined in on Ukraine's side, it turned into war for us,” Peskov was quoted as saying. “I am convinced of that. Everyone should understand this to summon up inner strength.”

He added: “This is a special operation de jure, but de facto for us it turned into a war after the collective West increasingly increased the level of its involvement in the conflict.”

Peskov's comments came amid a push by EU leaders — led by French President Emmanuel Macron, who's not ruled out sending French ground troops to Ukraine — to supercharge the bloc's military industrial capacity by combining resources to create a kind of EU army, raise billions of dollars for military spending through borrowing and ramp up military production.

Since the outbreak of full-scale war in Ukraine little more than two years ago, the prospect of a great power war breaking out in Europe once again has come to dominate EU politics, sparking fierce debates about whether the EU is turning away from its conception as a “peace project” after the destruction of World War II.

The grinding conflict in Ukraine has shown that winning such a war might rely on deep troves of industrial capacity and personnel, what experts call a “war of attrition” where victorious armies rely on sheer military mass over long periods of time as opposed to quick and efficient operations, the kind of conflict that NATO specializes in.

Russia, with its Soviet-era military industrial base and defensive-minded and artillery-reliant military doctrine, is surpassing its Western rivals in the production of ammunition, tanks, missiles, drones and other hardware as the war in Ukraine drags on.

EU leaders hold Ukraine summit

Warning Russian President Vladimir Putin may be tempted to attack even NATO countries, some European leaders, especially many in Central Europe and the Baltic nations, say the bloc must quickly build up its military strength in preparation for war with Russia.

How to do just that was the focus of a summit in Brussels on Thursday and Friday, where the bloc's 27 national leaders and EU chiefs, meeting as the European Council, debated the union's military future.

At the meeting, the EU also adopted several measures to counter Russia, including imposing tariffs on Russian grain and moving ahead with plans to give Ukraine windfall profits from more than $200 billion in frozen Russian assets held in European financial institutions.

ADVERTISEMENT

Going into the summit, European Council President Charles Michel wrote a column where he laid out the reasons why the EU “must prepare for war” if it wants peace.

“Russia is a serious military threat to our European continent and global security,” he wrote. “If we do not get the EU’s response right and do not give Ukraine enough support to stop Russia, we are next. We must therefore be defense-ready and shift to a ‘war economy’ mode.”

He said the EU must “take responsibility for our security” and not be “at the mercy of election cycles in the U.S. or elsewhere,” a clear reference to the possibility that Donald Trump may win the November U.S. elections. Trump has rattled EU leaders with his comments questioning NATO's central pledge of mutual defense. Trump, like presidents before him, wants NATO members to pay much more on defense.

The Brussels summit produced few concrete steps toward an EU army, though the 27 member states pledged to increase the bloc's “overall defense readiness and capabilities to match its needs and ambition in the context of rising threats and security challenges.”

In a joint statement, the EU said each state was committed to increasing military spending. Also, they agreed to study the possibility of rounding up funds for military spending by issuing common debt in the form of euro bonds.

The euro-backed bond proposal is supported by France but it is opposed by so-called “frugal” EU nations like the Netherlands and Sweden that do not want to see the bloc incurring debt as a whole.

Also, EU leaders said the European Investment Bank, the bloc's investment bank, should consider lending funds to the defense industry.

In another move to bolster its defense, the EU said it would examine methods to coordinate military spending across the EU.

This dovetails with a proposal by European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen, the EU's chief executive who hopes to win a second term after June European elections, to create an EU defense commissioner to oversee the bloc's military planning. No such position exists now and each of the EU's 27 member states is in charge of their military spending and planning.

Turning the EU into the kind of war economy envisioned by Macron and Michel, though, faces many hurdles.

Some members, including Ireland and Austria, are beholden to military neutrality; across the bloc, many Europeans are opposed to cutting social spending in favor of military spending; some European politicians, most notably Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orbán, are friendly toward Russia; and EU economies are struggling more generally due to high energy costs, large public debt and slow growth.

During the summit, Orbán criticized Western leaders for talking about the possibility of war with Russia and sending troops to Ukraine.

“What seemed absurd and unthinkable just two months ago has now become a reality; this is what they call the spiral of war,” Orbán said, speaking on Hungarian radio. He warned that “if a NATO country enters into military operations against Russia, it will mean the start of World War III.”

Brussels, he said, was being guided by “the logic of war.”

“I feel like I have arrived in another galaxy,” Orban said about the mood he encountered in the Brussels summit.

“Hungary is not at war with Russia,” he said. “One way or another, we must make a turn. Fortunately, our government maintains a sober position and we are talking about a cease-fire and peace talks.”

Courthouse News reporter Cain Burdeau is based in the European Union.

Follow @cainburdeau
Categories / International, Politics

Subscribe to Closing Arguments

Sign up for new weekly newsletter Closing Arguments to get the latest about ongoing trials, major litigation and hot cases and rulings in courthouses around the U.S. and the world.

Loading...