Updates to our Terms of Use

We are updating our Terms of Use. Please carefully review the updated Terms before proceeding to our website.

Wednesday, May 1, 2024 | Back issues
Courthouse News Service Courthouse News Service

Europe’s winter of discontent: Farmers block roads to protest low prices, EU Green Deal

European politics is getting hit by a wave of protests by farmers angry about inflation, environmental rules and cheap imports. In France, farmers are blocking highways, dumping manure outside supermarkets and demanding government help.

(CN) — A wave of farmer protests across Europe hit a new peak on Friday as French farmers descended upon Paris, blocked highways across the country with tractor convoys and expressed their anger by dumping and spraying manure at their favorite targets — among them supermarket chains, administrative buildings and fast food restaurants.

The protests in France mirrored others that have broken out in the Netherlands, Germany, Poland, Romania and Italy, bringing into sharp relief an array of grievances felt by farmers in the European Union.

Europe's farmers have lots of gripes but chief among them are soaring inflation, low prices for their goods, red tape, the costs of the Ukraine war, the EU's ambitious Green Deal rules, cuts to fuel subsidies and a flood of cheap food imports from countries outside the EU with lower standards.

This wave of protest comes at a politically fragile moment ahead of June European elections that could see far-right parties make major gains as discontent deepens in Europe over immigration, inflation and stagnant growth.

Fears are mounting that the farmers' protests could bolster even further far-right forces, adding to a feeling that the mood in Europe is shifting to the right — and that consensus in Brussels around the need to reduce carbon emissions, support Ukraine and embrace free trade deals is weakening.

Last November, months of protests by tractor-driving farmers in the Netherlands preceded a shocking win by Geert Wilders in parliamentary elections. Wilders has long been one of Europe's most visible far-right figures who has spent his political career railing against Muslim immigrants and the EU.

In France, the demonstrations pose a new setback for President Emmanuel Macron and his new prime minister, the 36-year-old Gabriel Attal.

Macron, Europe's foremost liberal leader, appointed Attal in early January with the hope of rebooting his second presidential term.

“Macron is relatively unpopular, so protest is always bad news,” said Laurent Warlouzet, a European history professor at Sorbonne University, in a telephone interview. “And farmer protests have a long history in France and they are especially disruptive, much more than other categories of workers.”

Warlouzet said a surging far right in France will seek to capitalize on the farmers' anger.

“The far right is very strong and tries to benefit from the protests, so that's another worrying element for the French government,” he said.

For the past week, the demonstrations in France, the EU's biggest agricultural producer, gathered momentum and then accelerated after a 36-year-old farmer, Alexandra Sonac, and her 12-year-old daughter were killed when a car crashed into a roadblock they were part of in the south of France. Making the situation even more toxic, the Armenian driver of the vehicle was reportedly living in France illegally.

On Friday, convoys of tractor-driving farmers brought to a standstill long stretches of highways in various parts of France and blocked one of the main motorways linking Paris with the northern city of Lille and Belgium. Farmers warned that the capital could see even more serious disruption unless their demands were met.

“We will go right into Paris to highlight our rage, our grievances,” said farmer Matteo Legrand, as reported by France 24.

Farmers drive their tractors on their way to a blockade on a highway, Friday, Jan. 26, 2024 near Saint-Arnoult, south of Paris. Protesting farmers shut down long stretches of some of France's major motorways on Friday, using their tractors to block and slow traffic and squeeze the government ever more tightly to cede to their demands that growing and rearing food should be made easier and more lucrative. (AP Photo/Christophe Ena)

Since they started, the protests have been marked by aggressive acts too. Farmers have dumped and sprayed manure at supermarkets, public buildings and at least one McDonald's restaurant; they've unloaded vegetables, car tires and bales of hay on public roadways; torn up the parking lot of a supermarket with a tractor; and doused a politician visiting a roadblock in flour.

“This is a serious time for the government because if it is not up to the task, I don’t know how the rest of the movement will go,” said Arnaud Gaillot, the president of Young Farmers, a national farmers' group, speaking on Sud Radio.

ADVERTISEMENT

“We have been warning people for 10 years, warning the government and saying that we risk ending up against a wall. We are there today.”

Unlike other protest movements, the French government has not taken a confrontational approach with the farmers even as they dump piles of manure outside prefectures and set fire to mounds of tires on highways.

Recently, French Interior Minister Gérald Darmanin said he would not send riot police against people “who are suffering.” By contrast, under Macron's watch police have used heavy handed tactics against environmentalists, demonstrators against pension reforms and the “yellow vest” movement.

In France, the list of grievances include low prices for their products, onerous EU environmental rules, inflation and high taxes.

Rushing to quell the unrest, Attal, the new prime minister, went to a farm in Haute-Garonne near Toulouse and announced measures to help farmers. He made a U-turn on a plan to reduce tax breaks on diesel fuel for agricultural use, a chief gripe among French farmers, and said the government would encourage French citizens to buy French products.

“We decided to put agriculture above everything else,” Attal said. “We have received your message loud and clear.”

It remained uncertain whether Attal's concessions would quiet the unrest, but the farmers clearly scored a win.

“These are really traditional farmers' protests,” Warlouzet said. “If you want to be helped, basically you have to block roads or make a lot of noise.”

Despite there only being about 500,000 farmers in France, he said they are quite influential as a bloc, in no small part because agriculture is still a major economic sector.

“Farmers are more influential than other categories because they are better organized and they have also the means to block roads — they have tractors and they have the willingness to do this,” Warlouzet said.

On Thursday, European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen also promised to do more to help Europe's farmers.

“I think we all sense that there is an increasing division and polarization when it comes to topics related to agriculture,” von der Leyen said as she met with farmers.

Her comments came at the kickoff of a “strategic dialogue” the commission will oversee with farmers, agribusiness, academia, financial institutions and civic society on the future of agriculture in the EU.

Warlouzet said the farmers' complaints need to be taken seriously because many of them are legitimate. “The problem is that agricultural prices are too low,” he said.

He said farmers are getting hurt by “excess competition from countries that do not respect the same environmental regulations” and by low prices offered by supermarkets.

But Warlouzet said farmers are wrong to blame their problems on the EU's rigorous set of environmental rules.

“In my opinion, the target is false,” he said. “The problem is not environmental regulations but rather the price paid to farmers.”

He worried the farmers' protests could prompt EU officials to weaken ambitions to fight climate change and move away from harmful farming practices, such as the widespread use of pesticides.

“If you look at the debate at the European Parliament you see that there has been more and more backlash against environmental regulation over the past year,” he said. “There is a more general environmental backlash, not only in France but also in Europe.”

Warlouzet pointed to how new pesticide restrictions were blocked last year by the center-right European People's Party, the largest group in the Parliament. In a bid to retain the support of farmers, the group upset many in the EU by adopting an anti-green agenda at a party conference last May.

Courthouse News reporter Cain Burdeau is based in the European Union.

Follow @cainburdeau
Categories / Economy, Environment, Government, International, Politics

Subscribe to Closing Arguments

Sign up for new weekly newsletter Closing Arguments to get the latest about ongoing trials, major litigation and hot cases and rulings in courthouses around the U.S. and the world.

Loading...