Updates to our Terms of Use

We are updating our Terms of Use. Please carefully review the updated Terms before proceeding to our website.

Wednesday, April 24, 2024 | Back issues
Courthouse News Service Courthouse News Service

In Political Gamble, Macron Forces French to Get Vaccinated

The move gives French the option of getting vaccinated or getting barred from restaurants, cafes and other public places.

(CN) — Facing a tough reelection next spring and the grim prospect of another winter of coronavirus illness and lockdowns, French President Emmanuel Macron is making headlines across Europe with his decision to force the French to get vaccinated or not be allowed into cafes, cinemas, gyms and restaurants.

On Monday evening, Macron made his fifth televised speech since the coronavirus pandemic started and announced new rules to effectively make vaccination mandatory for people wanting to live normal lives. He also said it will become mandatory for health workers to get inoculated.

“To protect ourselves and for the sake of our unity, we must move toward the vaccination of all French people because that is the only way to return to normal life,” Macron said, speaking with a lit-up Eiffel Tower in the backdrop.

“A summer of mobilization for vaccination: this is what we must aim for. Vaccinate as many people as possible anywhere, at anytime,” the 43-year-old president said.

Other European nations are introducing or discussing adopting similar rules, though these policies are sparking debate and dividing opinions over their legality, fairness and effectiveness. Some countries, such as Germany and Cyprus, already require people eating at restaurants to show they have been vaccinated.

Following Macron's speech, German Chancellor Angela Merkel said she was not ready for force health workers to get vaccinated. But similar measures to those in France are going into effect in Greece.

In France, Macron's top-down vaccination push was decried by his chief opponent, far-right leader Marine Le Pen, as an attack on personal freedoms. Macron and Le Pen are running neck-to-neck in polls and are expected to face off in April. The mainstream conservative party, Les Republicains, is fielding a candidate, Xavier Bertrand, who could be a contender too for the runoff.

Macron is struggling to win over French voters, and his liberal party performed dismally in recent regional elections. His approval rating is stuck at around 57% and his pro-business neoliberal policies have irked many French. His term as president has been marked by protests, disillusionment, poor election results, ridicule and doubts over his handling of the pandemic. France was one of the countries hit the hardest in Europe, in part because of Macron's unwillingness to impose lockdowns and restrictions.

German Chancellor Angela Merkel; Jens Spahn, federal minister of health; and Lothar Wieler, president of the Robert Koch Institute, from right, prepare for a picture in front of the entrance to the RKI in Berlin on Tuesday. (Michael Kappeler/Pool via AP)

On Monday, though, Macron tried to paint a sunny picture of his presidency, describing France as the best place in Europe to live and work, and laying out a future where France will become a technology leader with homegrown high-tech businesses.

His speech was seen as a kind of unofficial launch of his reelection campaign as he talked about creating jobs, investing in green technologies, making France a pioneer in modernization, lowering taxes and raising the retirement age. Overhauling France's complex, and generous, retirement system is a very touchy subject in France, and his previous attempts at reform failed after widespread protests broke out.

Macron is betting on winning a second term in the Elysee Palace through his tough stance on vaccination. France has one of the lowest vaccination rates in Europe with about 52.6% of French having received at least one vaccine dose. Infections are on the rise across Europe due to the spread of the much more contagious delta variant, and European leaders are imposing new restrictions to ward off the need for new crippling lockdowns.

Macron said it will become mandatory for all health workers to get vaccinated by September 15, and that starting in August people will need to show they have been vaccinated or recently tested negative for coronavirus infection before they can enter cafes, restaurants, shopping centers, gyms, hospitals and retirement homes.

ADVERTISEMENT

“Green passes,” as these Covid-19 vaccination certificates or “passports” are being called in Europe, will need to be shown before people are allowed onto long-distance airplanes, trains and buses, he said. This is already the case for most travel on public transportation between countries in Europe.

To compel people to get inoculated, Macron said France this autumn will start charging for coronavirus infection tests. France, unlike many other European countries, is offering the tests for free.

Macron said he will convene a special session of parliament on July 21 to pass the new rules.

“Vaccination is not immediately compulsory for everyone, but we will expand the health pass as much as possible to encourage as many of you as possible to get vaccinated,” he said.

But he held out the possibility that vaccination will become compulsory if the pandemic worsens. He called vaccination a civic duty.

Millions of Europeans are reluctant to get a vaccine shot, though vaccination is now much more accepted than earlier in the pandemic. A YouGov survey shows that only 32% of French were willing to get vaccinated last November but that number has climbed to 77%. French were among the most wary in Europe to get inoculated.

Across Europe, the number of people willing to get vaccinated has risen with roughly 80% or more Danes, Italians, Germans, Spanish and Brits in favor of vaccination. But vaccination drives have slowed. The United States has seen a similar uptick in willingness to get vaccinated, though the YouGov survey found only 70% of Americans ready to get inoculated.

It appears Macron's strategy is paying off for now.

Within 24 hours of his speech, about 1.7 million vaccine appointments were made through Doctolib, France's biggest online website where people can book vaccine appointments. Daily vaccinations hit a new high on Tuesday, too, with 792,339 shots administered, Prime Minister Jean Castex announced.

Still, Macron's stance is giving his critics ammunition.

Le Pen warned of a “serious decline in individual freedoms,” and members of her ultra-nationalist party, the National Rally, ripped into Macron, accusing him of going back on a promise he made last year that vaccines would not become compulsory.

“With the health pass, Emmanuel Macron is sinking more and more into authoritarianism,” said Stephanie Ravier, a senator in the National Assembly and a leader in Le Pen's party. “The French are fed up with this mediocre little leader. Let us breathe! Let us live!"

People wears face masks to curb the spread of coronavirus during the morning rush hour at Waterloo train station in London, Wednesday, July 14, 2021. London Mayor Sadiq Khan has asked Transport for London to enforce the use of mask wearing on buses and trains as a "condition of carriage", even after legal restrictions in England are lifted on July 19. Khan said he was "not prepared" to put tube, tram and other transport users in the capital "at risk" by removing the rules on face coverings. (AP Photo/Matt Dunham)

In Italy, far-right politicians also came out strongly against the Italian government adopting the “French model,” calling it unconstitutional and Orwellian.

“Vaccine, test or 'green pass' to enter bars and restaurants? Are we joking?” said Matteo Salvini, the leader of the League. “It's chilling to think that you will need a 'green pass' to take part in social life.”

Opposition to Covid passes isn't found only on the right of the political spectrum. In Italy, for example, many who lean to the left are against getting vaccinated and are opposed to Covid passes. Civil rights advocates, too, are questioning the expanding use of the European Union's Covid pass system, known as the EU Digital Certificate.

“The EU Digital Certificate is designed to facilitate cross-border travel, not to govern access to socio-economic life,” Alberto Alemanno, a law professor at the HEC Paris Business School, commented on Twitter. “Yet the temptation to extend its use to the latter is growing.”

Andrew Stroehlein, a spokesman for Human Rights Watch in Europe, called the passes “discriminatory.”

“We need to fight the pandemic, of course, and that means protective measures will be needed,” he said on Twitter. “However, some of the new proposals go too far.”

“Clearly, until vaccines are freely available to all — irrespective of country, region, economic or social status or population — the requirement of a 'vaccine passport' is discriminatory,” he said.

He said making people pay for Covid tests was a “terrible idea” because it will discourage people from getting tested and allow the virus to spread.

“Knowing your status, even when vaccinated, is critical for individual health,” he said. “Knowing case positivity rates is necessary to understand if and how vaccines are working, and critical for public health. Testing should remain free, accessible, and prioritized.”

The hospitality industry in France also questioned Macron's plans, arguing that restaurants and hotels should not be made to turn their staff into enforcement officers. Another concern is that the Covid passes will drive people away from their businesses.


Courthouse News reporter Cain Burdeau is based in the European Union.
Follow Cain Burdeau on Twitter

Follow @cainburdeau
Categories / Health, International, Law, Politics

Subscribe to Closing Arguments

Sign up for new weekly newsletter Closing Arguments to get the latest about ongoing trials, major litigation and hot cases and rulings in courthouses around the U.S. and the world.

Loading...