Updates to our Terms of Use

We are updating our Terms of Use. Please carefully review the updated Terms before proceeding to our website.

Sunday, April 28, 2024 | Back issues
Courthouse News Service Courthouse News Service

Chaos in Kabul as NATO evacuates thousands from Afghanistan

The NATO alliance is in the midst of a major crisis as it evacuates thousands of Westerners and Afghan allies from Taliban-controlled Kabul.

(CN) — With the crisis in Afghanistan deepening, the NATO military alliance came under increasing strain on Friday as it evacuated thousands of people from Kabul and assessed what many are calling its catastrophic failure to keep Afghanistan from falling into the hands of the Taliban.

NATO held emergency talks on Friday in Brussels as the situation worsened in Afghanistan after the Taliban seized control of the capital Kabul and established itself once again as the rulers of a Central Asian nation racked by four decades of conflict.

The United States and its European allies vowed to step up evacuations of Westerners and Afghan nationals who helped the NATO mission. An Aug. 31 deadline has been set for a complete withdrawal by U.S. and NATO forces and allies. NATO is racing to remove thousands of people who fear for their lives in a Taliban-run Afghanistan.

In Europe, the Afghanistan debacle has become an all-consuming mess with top politicians in the United Kingdom and Germany coming under pressure to resign as reports of Taliban violence emerge.

In London, British Foreign Secretary Dominic Raab was slammed for remaining on vacation on the Greek island of Crete even as Afghanistan fell into the hands of Taliban fighters with very little resistance from the NATO-trained and financed Afghan National Defense and Security Forces. Raab was accused of delegating the crisis to junior ministers. But he resisted calls from the opposition Labour Party and members of his own Tory party to step down.

In Berlin, German Foreign Minister Heiko Maas also held firm as demands for his resignation grew. Maas was accused of mishandling the crisis and misleading the German public by insisting only two months ago that there was no reason to fear a quick Taliban takeover. Like so many others, including U.S. President Joe Biden, Maas said he misread the situation.

“In the past few days I have only thought of one thing, namely drawing conclusions from the mistakes we have all made and making sure to get as many people out of Afghanistan as possible,” Maas told Der Spiegel, a German news magazine.

The evacuation of thousands of people continued on Friday. A hub has been set up in Spain to receive evacuees from Afghanistan.

The urgency to evacuate people became even more poignant as reports emerged of Taliban fighters targeting people who assisted NATO forces and the fallen NATO-supported Afghan government.

Amnesty International reported that Taliban fighters killed nine ethnic Hazara men in Afghanistan's Ghazni province last month. The humanitarian group said it spoke with eyewitnesses who said six men were shot dead and three were tortured to death. The Hazara are a minority group who practice Shia Islam and are one of the most persecuted minorities in Sunni-majority Afghanistan and Pakistan.

“The brutal killings likely represent a tiny fraction of the total death toll inflicted by the Taliban to date, as the group have cut mobile phone service in many of the areas they have recently captured, controlling which photographs and videos are then shared from these regions,” Amnesty said.

The Amnesty report and others warning that Taliban fighters were going door-to-door in Kabul to punish people who worked with NATO forces added to a sense that the Taliban will rule Afghanistan with ruthlessness. Taliban fighters are also accused of firing shots at protesters in Afghan cities who marched against the Taliban takeover.

In recent messages, Taliban leaders pledged to not use violence against collaborators and vowed that they were seeking to build peace in Afghanistan. But the reports of Taliban violence indicate the Islamist group has not moderated its violent creed since it was ousted by NATO forces in 2001 following the Sept. 11, 2001, terrorist attacks.

ADVERTISEMENT

“The cold-blooded brutality of these killings is a reminder of the Taliban’s past record, and a horrifying indicator of what Taliban rule may bring,” said Agnes Callamard, Amnesty's secretary general.

In Kabul, there were reports that Taliban fighters were preventing thousands of people from reaching the international airport, where NATO forces were evacuating people caught in the Afghan capital. Media outlets described chaotic scenes outside the airport. NATO and Taliban officials reported that 12 people have been killed since Sunday around the airport.

The German broadcaster Deutsche Welle said a family member of one of its reporters was killed by the Taliban when they came looking for the journalist, who had already fled the country.

German media also reported that a German national was shot and wounded while traveling to the airport. The civilian was reportedly flown out of Afghanistan. A German nonprofit that runs safehouses for Afghans who assisted NATO forces said it closed down its centers out of fear they would be raided by the Taliban.

European officials said airplanes were leaving Kabul partly empty because Taliban fighters were stopping people from reaching the airport.

Civilians prepare to board a plane during an evacuation at Hamid Karzai International Airport in Kabul, Afghanistan, on Aug. 18, 2021. (Staff Sgt. Victor Mancilla/U.S. Marine Corps via AP)

Spanish Defense Minister Margarita Robles said one Afghan family flown to Spain left behind a daughter after she lost in the chaos surrounding the airport.

By Friday, NATO said more than 18,000 people had been flown out of Kabul since the Taliban seized the capital on Sunday.

The collapse of Afghanistan has been a massive humiliation for NATO and Western foreign policymakers who pushed the idea of nation building in an impoverished and mountainous nation in Central Asia that has a long history of resisting foreign invaders. In Europe, many also criticized the American-dominated agenda for the alliance. European leaders reportedly were opposed to a quick withdrawal from Afghanistan and are blaming Biden and his predecessor in the White House, Donald Trump, for the disaster that is now taking place. Trump pushed for a withdrawal from Afghanistan, arguing that the two-decade conflict was against American interests. Biden, under pressure at home, followed through with Trump’s withdrawal plans.  

Questions also swirled about the worth of military intelligence that suggested the NATO-trained Afghan army would be able to hold out against the Taliban for several months after a troop withdrawal. Allegations were leveled against NATO and Afghan leaders over reports of widespread corruption, waste and incompetence in connection with the training of an Afghan army that hardly put up a fight against the Taliban.  

Additionally, many, especially those on the left, used the debacle as further evidence of the failure of American foreign policy and global leadership. In Afghanistan, the NATO mission faces accusations of conducting a bloody and ruthless war against Afghan resistance.  

Throughout the 20 years of NATO involvement in Afghanistan, the Taliban continued to fight against the NATO presence. More than 164,000 Afghans were killed in the fighting and hundreds of thousands were wounded. Many Afghan civilians were among those killed and injured. The U.S.-led operation in Afghanistan was marked by bombings, drone strikes and other acts that killed and maimed many civilians.       

Casualties were high among NATO troops too. About 2,448 U.S. soldiers, 1,144 soldiers from other NATO countries and 3,846 U.S. contractors were killed. Tens of thousands of NATO personnel were wounded. The cost of the Afghan war to the U.S. is estimated at about $2 trillion. 

On Friday, following the NATO meeting, NATO Secretary General Jens Stoltenberg said he would conduct “a thorough assessment of NATO’s engagement in Afghanistan.”    

“There are hard questions that we need to ask ourselves over our engagement in Afghanistan,” he said at a news conference. “We were clear-eyed about the risks of withdrawing our troops. But the speed of the collapse of the Afghan political and military leadership, and armed forces was not anticipated.”  

Stoltenberg said the alliance must not begin to doubt its importance, especially at a time when Russia and China are challenging the West and its democratic values.     

“North America and Europe must continue to stand together in NATO,” he said. “The unfolding events in Afghanistan do not change this.”  

Courthouse News reporter Cain Burdeau is based in the European Union.

Follow Cain Burdeau on Twitter

Follow @cainburdeau
Categories / Government, International, Politics

Subscribe to Closing Arguments

Sign up for new weekly newsletter Closing Arguments to get the latest about ongoing trials, major litigation and hot cases and rulings in courthouses around the U.S. and the world.

Loading...