Updates to our Terms of Use

We are updating our Terms of Use. Please carefully review the updated Terms before proceeding to our website.

Sunday, July 14, 2024 | Back issues
Courthouse News Service Courthouse News Service

Wary of China, Trump Offers Rosy Take on Virus

President Trump had plenty to talk about during his latest campaign rally, regaling a friendly crowd in New Jersey with his thoughts about impeachment, the economy, the border wall, and much more — but not a word about the deadly new Chinese virus.

WASHINGTON (AP) — President Trump had plenty to talk about during his latest campaign rally, regaling a friendly crowd in New Jersey with his thoughts about impeachment, the economy, the border wall, and much more — but not a word about the deadly new Chinese virus.

A self-described germaphobe, Trump has had little to say in public about the new virus that so far has killed more than 170 people in China, sickened thousands more there and led to a handful of confirmed cases in the United States.

And he speaks in broad terms when he does talk about it.

"We're very much involved with them, right now, on the virus that's going around," Trump said of China before signing a trade deal at the White House on Wednesday. He said he had discussed the situation with Chinese President Xi Jinping and that "we're working very closely with China."

Aides and confidants say Trump's careful approach is part of a strategy to avoid upsetting the stock market or angering China by calling too much attention to the virus or blaming Beijing for not managing the situation better, according to a White House official and a Republican close to the White House.

Later Wednesday, Trump tweeted photos from a briefing on the virus he attended with administration officials in the Situation Room, writing that "we have the best experts anywhere in the world and they are on top of it 24/7!"

In keeping with the low-profile approach, the White House announced by email Wednesday night that the meeting included members of a task force that will lead the U.S. response to the new virus. The 12-person team is chaired by Secretary of Health and Human Services Alex Azar and coordinated through the National Security Council.

Trump's comments contrast sharply with the fierce criticism he lobbed at his predecessor, President Barack Obama, during the 2014-15 Ebola crisis, which left more than 11,000 dead in three West African nations.

At the time, Trump ripped into Obama as a "dope" and "incompetent" and called for a travel ban on visitors from Ebola-infected countries. Trump also advocated preventing infected U.S. health care workers from coming home for treatment.

Obama faced some criticism from public health officials for being slow to address the Ebola crisis initially, but received plaudits for eventually attacking it with vigor. He nudged Congress to make a $5.4 billion emergency appropriation to help in the fight and sent 3,000 U.S. troops to West Africa to help with the international response.

Lawrence Gostin, a professor of global health law at Georgetown University, said he's taken a measure of comfort in the fact that Trump, so far, hasn't overreacted and has resisted "fanning the flames" as he did with his rhetoric during the Ebola crisis. That leaves room, Gostin said, for public health professionals to take the lead.

"As long as that continues and as long as there isn't political interference or mass quarantines in the U.S. or outright travel bans, I will feel comfortable with how the White House is handling it," Gostin said. He said he'd like to see Trump ask Congress for a $1 billion emergency appropriation to help agencies battling the virus.

Trump is aware that the virus outbreak in China could create a wild card for the U.S. economy during an election year. He has long prioritized the U.S. economic relationship with China, especially during trade negotiations, and similarly largely held his tongue during months of widespread protests in Hong Kong. He takes pride in the personal relationship he's developed with Xi and has commended him for demonstrating "transparency" as he deals with the crises.

Trump said "we have it totally under control" when he was asked about the new coronavirus while in Switzerland last week for the Davos economic conference. In a separate Twitter posting, he offered reassurance but scant detail for his confidence.

"China has been working very hard to contain the Coronavirus," Trump tweeted. "The United States greatly appreciates their efforts and transparency. It will all work out well."

But some public health experts say Trump's rosy assessments of the situation don't match the ground truth.

Gostin cited Chinese government bureaucratic delays that led to tens of thousands of people traveling outside of Wuhan province, increasing the likelihood that the virus will travel far beyond China.

"It's not accurate at all," Gostin said of Trump's assessment of China's handling of the outbreak. "China manifestly does not have this under control."

Trump's Democratic presidential rivals have zeroed in on his efforts to reduce financing for public health organizations.

Former Vice President Joe Biden and others have criticized Trump for eliminating a senior director position for global health security and biothreats at the National Security Council. Trump has also repeatedly sought budget cuts to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention and the National Institutes for Health.

Congress resisted that, and the 2020 budget includes $8 billion for the CDC, $1.4 billion more than Trump's budget request. It includes $41.7 billion for the NIH, $7.5 billion more than Trump's budget request.

Biden wrote in an opinion article for USA Today this week that the "possibility of a pandemic is a challenge Donald Trump is unqualified to handle as president." Massachusetts Sen. Elizabeth Warren, another Democratic contender for the 2020 nomination, tweeted that after the Ebola outbreak, Congress "invested to prevent pandemics like coronavirus. Donald Trump tried to cut that funding."

Categories / Health, International

Subscribe to Closing Arguments

Sign up for new weekly newsletter Closing Arguments to get the latest about ongoing trials, major litigation and hot cases and rulings in courthouses around the U.S. and the world.