Updates to our Terms of Use

We are updating our Terms of Use. Please carefully review the updated Terms before proceeding to our website.

Monday, June 17, 2024 | Back issues
Courthouse News Service Courthouse News Service

Trump Defenders Pound Process, not Substance

President Donald Trump is confronting the limits of his main impeachment defense. As the probe hits the one-month mark, Trump and his aides have largely ignored the details of the Ukraine allegations against him, and focused on the process of impeachment, rather than the substance.

WASHINGTON (AP) — President Donald Trump is confronting the limits of his main impeachment defense. As the probe hits the one-month mark, Trump and his aides have largely ignored the details of the Ukraine allegations against him, and focused on the process of impeachment, rather than the substance.

Republicans are loudly objecting to the House Democrats' investigation process, using that as justification for ordering administration officials not to cooperate and complaining about what they deem prejudicial, even unconstitutional, secrecy.

But as a near-daily drip of derogatory evidence emerges from closed-door testimony on Capitol Hill, the White House assertion that the proceedings are unfair is proving to be a less-than-compelling counter to the mounting threat to Trump's presidency.

Some senior officials have complied with congressional subpoenas to assist House Democratic investigators, defying White House orders.

Asked about criticism that the White House lacks a coordinated plan and could do a better job delivering its message, spokeswoman Stephanie Grisham said: "It's hard to message anything that's going on behind closed doors and in secret.

"It's like you're fighting a ghost, you're fighting against the air. So we're doing the best we can," she said on Fox News Channel.

It was a rare public admission from the White House that despite Trump’s belligerent bravado, real risks remain.

White House officials, who have been treating unified Republican support for Trump as a given, have grown increasingly fearful of Republican defections in a House impeachment vote and a potential Senate trial. While they do not believe there will be enough votes to remove the president, as Democrats hope, the West Wing believes more must be done to shore up Republican support to avoid embarrassment and political peril.

Trump has been upset with his own top aides — including Grisham and acting chief of staff Mick Mulvaney — for not changing the story line. Instead he relies on his Twitter account and Q&A sessions with reporters to launch daily attacks on the probe. And while Trump's personal lawyer Rudy Giuliani has added to the smokescreen, as he did during the Russia probe, the former New York City mayor has dramatically scaled back his media appearances since several of his associates were arrested in connection with Ukraine.

Complaining privately and publicly that Democrats "stick together" better than Republicans, Trump has leaned on his congressional allies to do more, according to White House officials and Republicans close to the West Wing. They spoke on condition of anonymity because they were not authorized to publicly discuss private conversations.

Trump is angry that his surrogates failed to defend him effectively. Those included House Minority Leader Kevin McCarthy, who stumbled through a "60 Minutes" interview. Trump urged the Republican Party this week to fight back, a lesson that was taken to heart by a group of right-wing Republicans, including members of the Freedom Caucus, who stormed a Capitol Hill hearing room Wednesday to disrupt testimony in the probe.

Trump allies cheered that maneuver, saying it showed that Republicans throughout Washington were coming to grips with the severity of the situation.

But the Republican complaints still are largely about process and may have limited potency: Trump's defenders complain that the interviews are being conducted in secret, which may soon change, and that Republicans are not involved, though Republican members can ask questions alongside the Democrats.

The contradictions are telling.

On Thursday, Republican Sen. Lindsey Graham of South Carolina, a top ally of Trump, introduced a resolution condemning the Democratic-controlled House for pursuing a "closed door, illegitimate impeachment inquiry." Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell is a co-sponsor of that measure.

But Graham also said he's talked to Mulvaney about what seems to be a lackluster White House pushback.

During President Bill Clinton's impeachment, Graham said, "He had a team that was organized, had legal minds that could understand what was being said versus the legal proceedings in question. And they were on message every day."

Republicans have been complaining for weeks that the Trump White House has no such defense system in place — partly a result of the inability to identify qualified talent, but also Trump's own qualms about projecting concern about the investigation.

"I think they're working on getting a messaging team together," Graham said.

Democrats reject Trump’s claim that the House interview process is unfair, and White House officials privately acknowledge their legal objections may not win the day. But they believe it's a political argument that will hold sway with the public.

However, the White House strategy comes with an expiration date: In coming weeks, the closed-door testimony will give way to public hearings. Democrats are expected to call a small group of witnesses to testify that Trump asked Ukraine to conduct investigations that could benefit him politically in 2020 and to address whether those requests were tied to conditions for giving Ukraine nearly $400 million in military aid and a White House meeting.

Some Trump allies believe the White House can't afford not to directly address what's already been revealed. They note that as more Trump appointees offer disparaging information to Congress, and as it is corroborated by official sources, the president will have increasing difficulty simply complaining he is the target of a "witch hunt."

Trump continues to insist he has done nothing wrong, a contention that can be difficult to square with the testimony coming on a nearly daily basis from the other end of Pennsylvania Avenue.

Tuesday's testimony by the top U.S. envoy to Ukraine, William Taylor, raised the stakes, as he gave House impeachment investigators a detailed roadmap of Trump's efforts to squeeze Ukrainian leaders for damaging information about Trump’s Democratic political rival Joe Biden and his family. Taylor, who read a lengthy opening statement, is expected to be a star witness at the Democrats’ planned public hearings.

Though the White House derided Taylor's testimony as third-hand information, he vividly described, with the help of contemporaneous notes, his concerns about a parallel foreign policy apparatus run by Giuliani that involved U.S. military aid being withheld unless Ukraine's newly elected president announced an investigation into the Bidens.

Wary of any erosion of Republican support, White House aides are stepping up their outreach to Congress, through meetings, conference calls and informal retreats like the one hosted by Mulvaney last weekend at Camp David.

While the White House operation plays catch-up, Trump's outside allies have been bolstering their own anti-impeachment messaging. Former White House strategist Steve Bannon launched a new daily radio show and podcast this week called "War Room: Impeachment."

Categories / Government, National, Politics

Subscribe to Closing Arguments

Sign up for new weekly newsletter Closing Arguments to get the latest about ongoing trials, major litigation and hot cases and rulings in courthouses around the U.S. and the world.