Updates to our Terms of Use

We are updating our Terms of Use. Please carefully review the updated Terms before proceeding to our website.

Monday, April 22, 2024 | Back issues
Courthouse News Service Courthouse News Service

Michigan shooter sentenced to life in prison without parole

Victims of the Oxford High School shooting confronted the shooter at the sentencing hearing where they called him a coward and detailed the personal traumas they would deal with for the rest of their lives.

DETROIT (CN) — The Michigan high school student behind the worst school shooting in state history will spend the rest of his life in prison without the hope for parole.

Oakland County Circuit Court Judge Kwame’ L. Rowe ruled Ethan Crumbley’s obsession with violence drove his actions, not his claimed mental illness.

“He could have changed his mind, but he didn’t,” the judge said.

He added: “He asked for the weapon he could do the most damage with, he chose not to die that day because he wanted to see the misery.”

The shooter, sporting a shorter new haircut, spoke at length at the hearing for the first time.

“Um, we are all here because of me,” he began. “I’m a really bad person. I’ve lied. I’ve hurt many people. I do plan to be better. I will change. I really am sorry.”

More than two dozen people testified over the course of the day. Nicole Baldwin, mother of Madisyn Baldwin who was killed by the shooter, worked to stay composed as she discussed the joy of raising her daughter.

“She made me the mom I am today,” she said. “She is a light when you need it most.”

All that was destroyed by the shooter.

“She became a statistic,” Baldwin lamented.

Baldwin recounted how she paced through the Meijer that was used as a meeting area, looking for her daughter, before being pulled into a room at the grocery store and informed of her death.

“I don’t have good news about these children, they are deceased,” Baldwin said she was told.

“All I was offered was a table at the medical examiner, where I had to identify her,” she continued.

Baldwin said Madisyn was laying on a gurney with bluish-colored hand laying out from underneath the sheet.

“I was dragged away from her like a toddler, screaming,” she told the judge.

Baldwin saved her ire for the shooter who she addressed as “waste.”

“The regret will consume you,” she predicted. “Might not happen tomorrow, but it will happen.”

She concluded: “No one will love you. No one will forgive you.”

The father of Tate Myre, Buck Myer, was emotional, with a quivering voice as soon as he walked to the podium.

He spoke in an off-the-cuff manner, recalling his experiences of how he learned of the shooting.

“Got a call from my wife,” he said.

“I had a feeling something didn’t feel right,” he said as he described being called into the manager’s office at the Meijer, where he was told Tate was gone.

“Not my baby boy,” Mire said his wife exclaimed.

Mire said love was currently absent from his family because there is no joy. He confessed his marriage is struggling because of the shooting.

“And we didn’t even do anything to each other,” he sighed.

Mire offered his suggestion for the shooter’s sentence and spoke to him directly even though the shooter would not look back.

“We want you to spend the rest of your life rotting in your cell.”

Craig Schilling, the father of Justin Schilling, struggled to control his anger as he made his statements.

“These events have rocked three generations of my family,” he said, and talked about how his future dreams of hanging out with his son and golfing were shattered by the shooting.

“Father’s Day foursome out on the links is something I will never have,” he said.

Schilling saved his heaviest remarks for the shooter, who refused to look up.

“Lock this son of a bitch up for the rest of his life,” he said. “I’d really like to show how much pain I felt. Those bird screams are nothing compared to what I would do with you. You piece of shit.”

ADVERTISEMENT

Justin’s mother also took time to speak at the hearing and pleaded with the judge to sentence the shooter to life without parole.

“You will face your demons in the afterlife,” she told the shooter. “It didn’t go down the way you had hoped. You are not famous.”

She concluded by saying that Justin would have been the shooter’s friend if he just asked him.

Reina St. Juliana, sister of Hana St. Juliana, saud she still had not fully processed her death.

“Instead of speaking at her wedding, I spoke at her funeral,” she told the judge.

Reina did not mince words about what should happen to the shooter.

“If I could, the shooter would be dead,” she said.

Steve St. Juliana, also there to speak, agreed with his daughter.

“There can be no forgiveness. There can be no rehab. His potential is irrelevant,” he said.

Molly Darnell, an adviser who was shot during the incident but recovered, had anger in her voice as she addressed the shooter.

“It is easier to see you as a monster,” she said. “You intended to kill me, someone you didn’t even know. You intended to make my husband a widow.”

Student Kylie Ossage struggled to keep her composure when she approached the podium and shared her experience being shot.

“All of a sudden, it sounded like a balloon pop,” she recalled. “I fell to the ground. I was shot. I thought I was going to die.”

Ossage said she tried to do push-up to drag herself to safety but could not. She described her blood soaking into the carpet and making a squishing sound as she laid there next to a groaning Hana St. Juliana.

“Fifteen minutes laying in my own blood, listening to Hana die,” she told the court.

Ossage described a painful journey of rehab where she required multiple spinal surgeries to repair her damaged bones.

“I’m so tired of relying on my medications to take me out of my misery,” she said. “Seven hundred thirty-eight days of constant pain, living with PTSD, living with survivor’s guilt.”

Aidan Watson, a student at Oxford, described how he walked into the hallway to see Tate Myer lying on the floor in a pool of blood. Watson was shot in the leg but did not realize it at first.

Watson talked about his painful recovery that includes permanent nerve damage. He told the court he cannot run without being in pain and that the shooter deserved life without parole.

“He is a horrible human being,” he said.

Oakland County Prosecutor Karen D. McDonald implored Judge Rowe to deny parole in her closing statements. She noted that the children involved in the shooting are forever changed and their trust is shattered.

“We have pored over this evidence for two years. Give [the victims] the justice they deserve,” she said.

The shooter’s attorney Paulette Lofton tried to convince the judge that the shooter was a changed person. She said when she first met him in prison, he looked hopeless, and she wondered if he would even make it to a court hearing.

However, with medication and therapy, Lofton said the shooter has matured.

“He is remorseful. He tries to be better every day.”

Lofton dismissed the evidence of the shooter's journal in which he wrote about the shooting as an exaggeration of his thoughts and suggested he struggled with the plan up until he left the school bathroom and started firing.

The judge noted a recent independent investigation that revealed Oxford School officials could have done more to prevent the shooting but was not convinced it had a place at this hearing and said the shortcomings of the school staff were not on trial.

The shooter pleaded guilty in October 2022 to 24 charges against him, including the first terrorism charges brought against a U.S. school shooting suspect.

He was subject to a so-called Miller hearing this past summer to determine his prison sentence since he was a minor at the time of the incident.

Following the hearing, Judge Rowe decided he could face life in prison without parole.

The shooter’s parents are scheduled to go to trial on manslaughter charges in January since the Michigan Supreme Court refused to hear their appeal. They recently requested to be tried separately and not as a couple as they had previously presented themselves.

Categories / Courts, Criminal, National

Subscribe to Closing Arguments

Sign up for new weekly newsletter Closing Arguments to get the latest about ongoing trials, major litigation and hot cases and rulings in courthouses around the U.S. and the world.

Loading...