Updates to our Terms of Use

We are updating our Terms of Use. Please carefully review the updated Terms before proceeding to our website.

Tuesday, June 25, 2024 | Back issues
Courthouse News Service Courthouse News Service

French PM Fails to Appease Strikers With Pension Reform Plan

France's prime minister sought to strike a conciliatory note Wednesday as he unveiled a controversial plan to overhaul the country's pension system, but failed to appease striking unions which vowed to expand a crippling week-old transport freeze.

PARIS (AFP) — France's prime minister sought to strike a conciliatory note Wednesday as he unveiled a controversial plan to overhaul the country's pension system, but failed to appease striking unions which vowed to expand a crippling week-old transport freeze.

Public transport networks in Paris and other cities have been paralyzed by the walkout, which began last Thursday and left shops, hotels and restaurants fearing for their bottom line.

Edouard Philippe insisted the government would pursue its objective of creating a new points-based pension system that fuses the country's 42 existing plans into one, but said the reform was "not a battle.”

He declared the new-look scheme would be fairer and guarantee better basic coverage for the most vulnerable workers, insisting "there will be no winners and no losers.”

In a televised address, Philippe sought to assuage unions' fears by saying the changes would be implemented gradually, "without brutality", and would not affect workers born before 1975.

But he angered many with his announcement that although the legal retirement age would remain 62, the government would introduce a "bonus/penalty" system aimed at trying to get people to remain in work until 64.

Also unwelcome was Philippe's insistence that special pension provisions for certain sectors — including railway workers, sailors and Paris Opera workers who retire earlier than most — would be scrapped, albeit in a staggered manner.

Unions at state rail operator SNCF called for the transport strike to be "reinforced" in response, while the biggest union at Paris's public transport operator, UNSA, said efforts to get people to work longer crossed "a red line.”

The three biggest trade union federations, the FO, CFDT and CGT, all criticized the proposals which Philippe believed would "justify" the end of the labour action.


The head of the CGT union, Philippe Martinez, said the government had made a "mockery" of workers, adding: "Everyone will work longer, this is unacceptable."

Teachers, who have walked off the job twice in the past week, also declared themselves displeased with the outcome.

Philippe had announced a guaranteed minimum pension of 1,000 euros ($1,100) for minimum-wage workers, higher than some groups, including farmers, currently receive, but well under the average pension of just over 1,600 euros in 2017.

The premier said the new system offered better protection for freelancers, people with gaps in their careers, and women who took time off work to have children. 

"The time has come to construct a universal retirement system," insisted Philippe, adding the government had "no hidden agenda.”

"To guarantee our pension, to finance a higher level of solidarity, to benefit from a higher life expectancy without increasing taxes, the only solution is to work a bit longer, and progressively a bit longer, as is the case everywhere in Europe and everywhere in the world," said Philippe.

Hundreds of thousands of people have taken to the streets in two mass protests over the reforms since the strikes began on December 5.

It has been the biggest show of union force since President Emmanuel Macron came to power in 2017 vowing to cut public spending and make the economy more competitive.

Unifying 42 pension systems

The proposed reform would replace the current pension calculations — based on a private sector worker's 25 best-earning years, or six months for public servants — with a universal scheme of pension points awarded for hours worked.

Philippe said unions themselves would fix the euro value of a point in consultation with parliament, and a "golden rule" would be written into the new pension law to guarantee that the value of a point "cannot go down.”

Public transport in the capital remained at a near standstill as the strike ground on Wednesday, causing much frustration for commuters and tourists alike.

The head of national rail traffic operator SNCF, Alain Krakovitch, warned the chaos that has also hobbled high-speed and international trains would likely continue "until the end of the week.” 

Some labour leaders had vowed to fight through until Christmas.

Those opposing the reform accuse former investment banker Macron of trying to roll back France's costly but highly cherished welfare state.

Their labour action has revived memories of three-week-long strikes over pension reform that crippled France in 1995, forcing the center-right government of the day to reverse course.


© Agence France-Presse

by Mariëtte Le Roux

Categories / Employment, Government, International

Subscribe to Closing Arguments

Sign up for new weekly newsletter Closing Arguments to get the latest about ongoing trials, major litigation and hot cases and rulings in courthouses around the U.S. and the world.