Updates to our Terms of Use

We are updating our Terms of Use. Please carefully review the updated Terms before proceeding to our website.

Tuesday, April 16, 2024 | Back issues
Courthouse News Service Courthouse News Service

For youth facing stressful justice system, Bay Area judges have an answer: Courtroom dogs

When children face the stress of a courtroom, a courthouse dog can sometimes be their only source of comfort.

SAN FRANCISCO (CN) — Meet Bear, a six-year-old black lab who lives in Northern California. Spot him around his neighborhood in Martinez, a small city in the Bay Area, and he may look like just another friendly pooch ready to run across lawns and make friends.

When at work in the Contra Costa County courthouse, though, Bear is all business. A certified courthouse dog — one of only a handful in the country — Bear has spent years working with children everywhere from family courtrooms to medical facilities.

Even in court, after all, there’s a place for very good dogs: at the side of a child who needs comfort as they testify.

Bear learned his skills at Canine Companions, an organization that breeds and trains service dogs. While often used by individuals with disabilities, government bodies like Contra Costa County also occasionally apply to acquire the dogs to accompany and calm people as they navigate through stressful government systems. 

Bear is specially trained to comfort witnesses and victims, typically children, as they navigate what can be extremely stressful legal proceedings. Like his handler, Janet Wright, he technically works for Contra Costa County.

A day at work for Bear could mean meeting victims, including children, during stressful police interviews and legal depositions. It’s his job to emotionally support each client, whether by handing a child toys and puzzle pieces or simply laying quietly at their feet to calm them. He’s currently the only one at this job — and it can be a busy one. 

When not on call, the black Labrador spends his work days at the Contra Costa District Attorney’s office, where he practices commands or roams through the halls in search of friends. Off duty, he enjoys apples, carrots and playtime. He lives with Wright and her family in Martinez.

It takes years to train a dog like Bear, colloquially known as “court dogs,” and prepare them for the courtroom. While dogs like Bear can provide a huge service to traumatized children, it's usually up to officials at the county level to decide if they have the ability to handle, train and house them. 

Wright, who has been paired with Bear since 2019, said that in the years since, she’s seen the impact his calming presence has had in juvenile court. As children gather strength to answer questions from lawyers and judges, they will often first whisper answers to him in court, she said. 

Bear, she says, is particularly adept at sensing emotions and can soothe panic attacks. “He’s very relaxed [and] very calm — he knows his job at this point,” she added. “I don’t have to direct him when he’s in a courtroom, and when I hand over the leash, he just kind of knows.”

Back at home, it's a different story. Bear is a goofball, she said, full of attitude and always ready to run and play.

“Please don’t be fooled by him,” she laughed, motioning at Bear as he lay calmly at her feet during an interview at the DA’s office. “He’s a complete clown. He has an attitude most of the time.”

Bear regularly receives drawings and letters from children in Contra Costa County. His handler Janet Wright tries to answer them personally. (Natalie Hanson / Courthouse News)

While courthouse dogs are rare nationwide, Bear is not the only one in the Bay Area. In nearby San Francisco, longtime court dog Nemo — also a black lab — just retired this year after seven years working alongside his handler and houser Shelley Gottlieb.

Unlike Bear, who is a government employee, Nemo worked for the nonprofit San Francisco branch of CASA (Court Appointed Special Advocates), a national organization that helps support abused and neglected children in the legal system. Kate Durham, executive director at San Francisco’s local CASA, said dogs like Nemo can help make the process a little less scary for traumatized children.

ADVERTISEMENT

“When kids are in foster care, they are often removed from families [and] removed from communities,” she said. And while such children may meet scores of attorneys and court workers, “none of those people really focus specifically on the young person.” That’s where dogs like Nemo come in, to help get clients through traumatic times. 

San Francisco’s CASA program has a high volume of cases, seeing about 400 children per year. Nemo started working with these children in 2016, after local judge Nancy Davis learned about court dogs working elsewhere in California and helped kick start the process. CASA volunteer Gottlieb, who had worked with an SPCA therapy dog before, volunteered to become his handler. 

In an interview, Renee Espinoza, San Francisco CASA’s former executive director, credited Davis with helping bring courtroom dogs to the city. She said it was Davis’s idea to put the court dog program under CASA’s purview.

“She specifically said this will be a game changer for kids coming to court,” Espinoza said.

Davis, who worked as a judge in San Francisco Superior Court until 2021, said she first learned about support dogs like these through a presentation from a courthouse dog foundation in 2014. The presentation focused heavily on using dogs in criminal courts, but Davis had a different idea. 

“At the time, I was sitting in the dependency court,’’ Davis said, referring to the branch of the court system that handles child abuse and neglect cases. She thought dogs like Nemo could help kids brave testimony and provide a safe space.

By 2016, that vision became reality when Nemo began sitting in on family reunification efforts. “It seemed to me they were perfect for that purpose," Davis said.

It took several years of planning and red tape to get Nemo paired with his handlers: Gottlieb and her assistant volunteer, Cynthia Dragon. Training, provided through Canine Companions, was “extremely intensive,” and Nemo ultimately cost around $50,000, Espinoza said.

Despite some initial pushback, the program went on to see seven years of success. Nemo accompanied children in court at least three days a week, Gottlieb said. He also visited them in other facilities, such as hospitals. But that program came to an abrupt end during Covid, as many court proceedings went remote. “Even now in San Francisco, our courts are operating in a hybrid way,” said Durham, the CASA executive director. 

Going forward, Durham would like to see CASA hire another dog like Nemo but isn’t sure if and when that would happen. “It doesn't make sense to launch the program with a new dog, even though we saw the amazing impact of it.”

Gottlieb was sad to see the program — and with it, Nemo’s employment — come to an abrupt end. Over her years working with Nemo, Gottlieb said she saw the trust children and families placed in him, as well as Nemo’s remarkable ability to create an affectionate and calm atmosphere.

She recalled one recent incident where a child hid under the table when it came time for him to give testimony. The judge encouraged him to come out, ‘’and the kid said, ‘I want to sit here with Nemo.’” 

San Francisco court dog Nemo is seen with his handlers Shelley Gottlieb, right, and Cynthia Dragon, left. (Photo courtesy of Shelley Gottlieb)

“We had families ask for Nemo to come to court,” Gottlieb added. “He de-stresses a situation.” 

Attorneys who got to know Nemo over the years agreed. 

“He was such a welcome and calming presence,” San Francisco-based child welfare attorney Julia Ten Eyck said in a phone interview. “For our children and youth, but also for many parents and attorneys.’’

San Francisco attorney Andrea Goodman, who often works with children in need of court-appointed lawyers, praised Nemo and his handlers for their experience and work in child welfare. Calling him a “very sweet, jovial boy,” she said that Nemo made a difference in the lives of children facing the frightening prospect of testifying in court. 

Having Nemo in court, she said, “interrupts the panic or the anxiety or tension. You would see that with attorneys, with parents and children. It was to remind them to stop and breathe and look at this sweet creature.” 

Back in Contra Costa County, Bear may soon have another companion dog as a co-worker. Wright said the county is discussing the matter. It depends on whether another county employee can take on the intensive job she has had with Bear, and if the county can afford it. 

Bear has at least four years until retirement. Until then, he will keep spending his workdays comforting clients and learning new skills with his handler Wright. 

“Our judges love him and everybody is so used to him,” Wright said. “The feedback is always, ‘I would have not have done this if Bear wasn’t present.’”

Follow @nhanson_reports
Categories / Courts, Law

Subscribe to Closing Arguments

Sign up for new weekly newsletter Closing Arguments to get the latest about ongoing trials, major litigation and hot cases and rulings in courthouses around the U.S. and the world.

Loading...