OAKLAND, Calif. (CN) — Dissolving an extended temporary restraining order Friday, a federal judge gave the California Department of Transportation the green light to begin sweeping an Oakland encampment which may have 200 residents.
Oakland's largest known encampment was surveyed by Governor Gavin Newsom this past April after Caltrans cited growing safety concerns. It spans large areas Caltrans owns under the freeway as well as city and railroad property. Caltrans estimates there may be 200 people living on the land, some for several years.
On July 15, the agency notified residents they would be removed, citing safety hazards due to several recent fires at the encampment. In April, a man trapped in his RV died in another fire at the camp.
Some residents filed a federal lawsuit asking for a temporary restraining order, and this month requested a preliminary injunction against Caltrans. The residents also wrote an open letter to Newsom, asking for Caltrans, the city and county to help improve fire safety at the site, such as by providing garbage removal and dumpsters and fire extinguishers.
Their case is similar to others being fought across the state, as homeless residents primarily fight Caltrans and local police departments for the right to stay in one place. Under Martin v. Boise, cities may face legal repercussions if they attempt to move people sleeping in public spaces when there aren't enough shelter beds for the number of homeless residents. But different judges have come to different conclusions to settle requests for relief from encampment sweeps, based on the conditions in each city.
Last month, U.S. District Judge William Orrick extended the temporary restraining order he awarded to Wood Street residents, chastising Oakland, Alameda County and Caltrans for not coming to an agreement to shelter the encampment's residents.
Newsom criticized Orrick’s ruling. “Our roadways and highways are no place for individuals to live, and this encampment is risking public health and safety," he said in a statement.
In a hearing Friday, Orrick reviewed the city’s relocation proposal released late Thursday night to provide shelter beds for people who are being moved. The city has more than 5,000 homeless people according to the latest survey, and needs help from the county to coordinate contacting residents about where they can access shelter.
However, county attorney William Rowell said county personnel at Wood Street only have federal funding to provide health services.
“That is the sticking point right now. The city wants to put this on the county, but the county does not have the funding or the people available,” Rowell said.
But Orrick disagreed.
“When the folks at Wood Street are going to be relocated, they're going to be your responsibility as much as they are the city’s, and they are residents of your county,” he said. “You can't wash your hands of the issue.”
Caltrans attorney Mark Guenzi said the agency wanted to move by Monday to start abating fire safety risks, which is why the agency filed a motion to dismiss on Aug. 11.
“The frequency of fires in that area is very concerning given the potential for catastrophic risk,” he said.
Brigitte Nicoletti, lawyer for the plaintiffs, blamed Caltrans for not providing trash removal at the site despite residents asking for it. She also said the agency has pushed residents further north. closer to flammable materials.
“The shelter options are not accessible for the majority of residents,” she said, noting St. Vincent de Paul's shelter is congregate and only designed for nighttime sleeping with no daytime shelter — which does not work for people with disabilities. Each time people have been moved they have lost personal property, “and there’s no reason to think this will go any differently," she told Orrick.