(CN) - T-Mobile USA successfully petitioned the 11th Circuit to decertify a class action filed by former employees who say the company owes them commission for the sale of prepaid cell-phone plans.
Lead plaintiff Henry Vega described the nationwide class as: "All employees of T-Mobile who received, or were entitled to receive, commissions for the sale of T-Mobile prepaid cellular telephone plans who did not receive their commissions or were charged back by T-Mobile for their commissions."
The Atlanta-based federal appeals court backed T-Mobile's claim that there are too many individual differences among the proposed plaintiffs' cases to warrant class certification.
"[T]he claims Vega has asserted on behalf of the class depend on the terms, conditions, and mutual understandings regarding compensation that each class member had with T-Mobile," Judge Tjoflat wrote. "Without a common contract, it is impossible for Vega to bring a case typical of all other class members."
Subscribe to Closing Arguments
Sign up for new weekly newsletter Closing Arguments to get the latest about ongoing trials, major litigation and hot cases and rulings in courthouses around the U.S. and the world.