(CN) — The United States was founded on the concept of life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness. But have we gotten to a point where those values are putting the greater public at risk and hampering this country’s response to Covid-19?
Dozens of civil rights lawsuits have been filed throughout the country since local and state governments issued stay-at-home orders designed to “flatten the curve.” Armed protestors, some triggered by angry tweets from President Donald Trump, have stormed state capitols demanding a return to normal life despite the advice from medical professionals.
Has this pandemic exposed an economic desperation and cultural rift that threatens democracy entirely?
Distrust of the Government and Experts
The lawsuits and protests are the result of long-simmering political tension.
“For decades, the right has been fueling a hostility to government that has bread real and deep distrust among Americans on the right to what government, not just what government does, but who the people in government are,” said Johann Neem, an author and a history professor at Western Washington University. “In that sense, there is that idea of ‘leave me alone’ that is being expressed from the right.”
Neem is quick to point out that the political right doesn’t have the monopoly on distrust of authority. The left has traditionally sparked counterculture movements, the most recent being The Black Lives Matter campaign.
However, the undercurrent of the current protests from the right has exposed a distrust not only of government, but also of professors, public health officials, environmental experts, journalists and others whom society has traditionally respected.
“There’s a deeper question of who has authority and does the sort of knowledge experts have is authority that should be listened to?” Neem said. “That question is fueling an anti-government sentiment. And the people who are protesting feel that the authority should lie with their interests and somehow the government is opposed to them because it is listening to other people who can't be trusted.”
Inconsistent messages from the Trump administration has fueled this distrust.
Wendy Parmet, who directs the Center for Health Policy and Law at the Northeastern University Law School, believes the country has moved heavily towards the individualistic spectrum. It has led to decades of a thinning of the public sector, especially in the health field, leaving the country vulnerable.
While it is impossible to put exact numbers to it, hyper-partisanship has compromised the United States’ response to Covid-19.
“The president is saying one thing and his own task force is saying another thing and the CDC is saying another thing, and really what is a human being supposed to know or do?” Parmet said. “I don’t think we can discount the importance of the confusion of the messaging and the fact that even what is said on Monday is inconsistent with what is said on Monday night on Twitter.”
She added, “If there was ever a moment we needed to come together and put our individualism aside … roll up our sleeves and do the best that we can with the best information we have, I think this is that moment.”
The Myth of American Individualism
Make America Great Again — it is either an inspirational rally cry or a racist insult, depending on one’s political leanings.
What isn’t in doubt is the phrase’s intent, to harken back to a time when the United States was the standard bearer for freedom. A place ripe with opportunity, where hard work and individual ingenuity was rewarded. A place where a man could pick himself up from his bootstraps and live the American Dream.