Monday, August 8, 2022 | Back issues
Courthouse News Service Courthouse News Service

US Delays Oil Pipeline Approvals After Court Ruling

The Army Corps of Engineers has suspended a nationwide program to approve oil and gas pipelines, power lines and other utility work, spurred by a court ruling that industry representatives say could slow or halt numerous infrastructure projects due to environmental concerns.

BILLINGS, Mont. (AP) — The Army Corps of Engineers has suspended a nationwide program to approve oil and gas pipelines, power lines and other utility work, spurred by a court ruling that industry representatives say could slow or halt numerous infrastructure projects due to environmental concerns.

The directive from the Corps of Engineers’ headquarters, detailed in emails obtained by The Associated Press, comes after a federal court last week threw out a blanket permit that companies and public utilities have used for decades to build projects across streams and wetlands.

The Trump administration is expected to challenge the ruling. For now, officials have put on hold about 360 pending notifications to entities approving their use of the permit, Corps of Engineers spokesman Doug Garman said Thursday.

The agency did not provide details on types of projects or their locations.

Pipeline and electric utility industry representatives said the effects could be widespread if the suspension lasts, affecting construction and maintenance on potentially thousands of projects. That includes major pipelines like TC Energy's Keystone XL crude oil line from Canada to the U.S. Midwest, the Mountain Valley natural gas pipeline in Virginia and power lines from wind turbines and generating stations in many parts of the United States.

"The economic consequences to individual projects are hard to overstate," said Ben Cowan, a Houston-based attorney with Locke Lord LLP who represents pipeline and wind energy companies. "It could be fatal to a number of projects under construction if they are forced to stop work for an extended period in order to obtain individual permits."

The Corps of Engineers has broad jurisdiction over U.S. waterways. It uses the blanket permit to approve pipelines and other utility projects after minimal environmental review. That's a longstanding sore point for environmentalists, who say it amounts to a loophole in water protection laws and ignores the cumulative harm caused by thousands of stream and wetlands crossings

Industry supporters describe the program as crucial for timely decisions on projects that can stretch across multiple states and cross hundreds of water bodies. They say analyzing each of those crossings would be costly and is unnecessary because most involve little disturbance of land or water.

Since the blanket permit in question, Nationwide Permit 12, was last renewed in March 2017, it has been used more than 37,000 times, Corps of Engineers spokesman Garman said. To qualify, projects must not cause the loss of more than a half acre of water or wetlands.

Last week's court ruling in Montana was in a lawsuit before U.S. District Judge Brian Morris, involving the disputed Keystone XL oil pipeline from Canada. Work began this month on the 1,200-mile (line stretching from Alberta to Nebraska that has been championed by President Trump.

Morris said using the blanket permit for water crossings was illegal because the Corps of Engineers did not adequately consider potential harm to imperiled wildlife species when it reauthorized the permit in 2017. The judge cited concerns among scientists that construction could stir up sediment and bury the food source of an endangered, dinosaur-like fish, the pallid sturgeon.

The judge did not limit his findings to Keystone, so the ruling is being interpreted for now to apply to any project using Nationwide Permit 12. The Montana case was cited last week in a lawsuit over a 430-mile natural gas pipeline in central Texas. Plaintiffs, including the city of Austin, said last week's ruling invalidated the Corps of Engineers’ work on the Permian Highway Pipeline.

Because there are no streams or other water bodies near the northern Montana border crossing where Keystone XL is under construction, that work was not immediately halted. Yet it's an obstacle to future work given the many water crossings along the line's path.

Corps of Engineers regulatory program Chief Jennifer Moyer said in an April 17 email obtained by AP that "out of an abundance of caution" she was ordering agency personnel across the nation to stop verifying companies as compliant with the blanket permit.

Questions about the directive were referred to Department of Justice spokesman Wyn Hornbuckle, who declined comment because the case is still in litigation.

An attorney for one of the environmental groups that brought the Keystone lawsuit said critics of the permit program sought changes when last it was renewed but were rebuffed. To prevent the problem it now faces, the Corps of Engineers should have consulted more closely with wildlife agencies to craft a program that would better avoid impacts, said Jared Margolis with the Center for Biological Diversity.

"They knew what they had to do and they were avoiding it and they got caught," Margolis said.

Labor and industry groups led by the American Petroleum Institute and Interstate Natural Gas Association of America said in a statement that the nationwide permit was "critical to the responsible and efficient development and maintenance of energy and other vital infrastructure." The groups said the permit had been applied to pipelines, broadband cable, water mains and other utilities.

For electricity providers, the court ruling could jeopardize efforts to maintain the energy grid by calling into question the status of projects that use the permit, said Emily Sanford Fisher, general counsel for the Edison Electric Institute, which represents investor-owned electric companies.

Cowan, the industry attorney, said he anticipates government attorneys will move quickly to file an appeal or a request with Morris to clarify his ruling.

"The fact that this case involves the Keystone pipeline will almost certainly elevate its profile within the administration," he said.

Read the Top 8

Sign up for the Top 8, a roundup of the day's top stories delivered directly to your inbox Monday through Friday.