Updates to our Terms of Use

We are updating our Terms of Use. Please carefully review the updated Terms before proceeding to our website.

Wednesday, April 24, 2024 | Back issues
Courthouse News Service Courthouse News Service

Ukraine war sees humanitarian disaster grow, ceasefire talks resume

Hopes for humanitarian relief in Ukraine were revived as Ukrainian and Russian negotiators sat down for a third round of ceasefire talks. More than 1.4 million Ukrainians have fled a conflict that may be poised to enter an even more destructive phase.

(CN) — The war in Ukraine entered its 12th day on Monday with continued fighting and intense shelling in the eastern and southern parts of the country and around the capital Kyiv, which straddles the Dnieper River, a central artery through Ukraine's vast flatlands.   

Over the weekend, efforts to open humanitarian corridors to allow civilians trapped in cities encircled by Russian forces failed with Ukrainian and Russian forces blaming each other for firing on civilians.    

Hopes for a ceasefire and the opening of safe corridors to evacuate suffering populations were renewed on Monday as Ukrainian and Russian delegations sat down for a third round of talks at a site in Belarus. After the talks concluded, negotiators said they had made progress, but announced no breakthroughs. Prospects for a diplomatic end to this conflict remained very uncertain.    

The humanitarian crisis in Ukraine is growing by the day as millions of civilians remain trapped in the war zone, unable to flee or who are seeking a way out amid fighting and explosions. Heart-wrenching images of people – among them the elderly, children, families – suffering in freezing basements, carrying a few possessions in bags on war-torn roads and pleading on video posts for an end to the war have saturated the world. Images from the war zone show destroyed villages, towns, bridges, factories, roads, residential blocks. Gas, electricity, food, water and other basic necessities are lacking in many parts of Ukraine. Making the situation worse, the country is experiencing snow and freezing temperatures.    

On Monday, Ukraine’s infrastructure ministry estimated that the country has suffered $10 billion in damages to its infrastructure. 

After a weekend of relative calm, Russia’s bombing campaign was ramping up on Monday and there were fears it will intensify further over the next day or more as its troops try to seize key cities. On Monday, Ukraine accused Russia of shelling a bread factory in Makariv near Kyiv, killing 13 civilians, and firing cluster bombs in Mykolaiv, a city close to the historic port city of Odessa, Ukraine’s third-largest city with 1 million people. Russia has been accused of using cluster munitions in previous attacks against Kharkiv and Okhtyrka, something the Kremlin denies.    

The use of cluster munitions is considered a war crime, but Russia, like other major powers such as the United States and China, has not signed onto a United Nations convention banning them. Cluster munitions do not distinguish between civilians and combatants and can leave behind unexploded ordnance which can harm civilians,  according to the Arms Control Association.   

The Pentagon estimates Russia has fired about 625 missiles on Ukraine since Russian President Vladimir Putin ordered his troops to invade on Feb. 24. Dozens of civilians and hundreds, if not thousands, of soldiers on each side have been killed. The United Nations estimates that about 1.7 million people have fled Ukraine and that the number of refugees could grow to as many as 5 million if the fighting continues. Civilian deaths have been reported in towns and cities targeted by Ukrainian forces in eastern Ukraine too.     

The dead bodies of people killed by Russian shelling lie covered in the street in the town of Irpin, Ukraine, on Sunday, March 6, 2022. (AP Photo/Diego Herrera Carcedo)

Russian forces advancing on Kyiv were accused of killing a fleeing family on Sunday with a mortar strike and killing the mayor of the town Hostomel and his aides as they handed out bread and water.   

These civilian killings, and others elsewhere in Ukraine, were reported by Ukrainian and foreign news outlets and social media sources, including those used by Ukrainian officials. Russian media and officials, meanwhile, accuse Ukrainian forces of positioning themselves among the civilian population and carrying out attacks on civilians in order to blame Russia. It is nearly impossible for reporters to independently verify most accounts from the frontlines.     

ADVERTISEMENT

On Sunday night, an angry and impassioned Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy said he will never forgive Russia. He noted that Sunday was “Forgiveness Day” in Ukraine when people traditionally say, “God forgives, and I forgive.”   

“These words seem to have lost their meaning today,” he said. “We will not forgive the destroyed houses…. We will not forgive the shooting of unarmed people. Destruction of our infrastructure. We will not forgive.”    

He said Russian troops are determined “to kill even more” and that the invasion was poised to get much worse as the attackers try to seize Kyiv and other cities.     

The slaughter of a family fleeing with others along a road from Irpin was akin to being killed in a “shooting club,” the president said.    

“We will punish everyone who committed atrocities in this war. On our land. We will find every bastard who shot at our cities, our people, who bombed our land, who launched rockets, who gave the order and pressed ‘start,’” Zelenskyy said, obviously referring to Putin and his troops. “There will be no quiet place on this earth for you except for the grave.”    

Ukraine’s tone has grown ever fiercer since the invasion started and Zelenskyy’s government has vowed to fight until Russian troops withdraw in defeat.    

On Sunday night, Zelenskyy accused Western leaders of not caring about the plight of Ukraine and in a speech on Monday he called on the West to enter the fight by shooting down Russian airplanes in a no-fly zone.    

“How many more deaths and losses are needed to close the skies over Ukraine? How do civilians in Kharkiv or Mykolaiv differ from those in Hamburg or Vienna?” Zelenskyy said. “We are waiting for a decision on closing the skies or providing the forces you have, or you can send to us combat aircraft and air defense systems which will give us the strength we need.”   

U.S. President Joe Biden and NATO leaders have so far said they do not want to enforce a no-fly zone because that would put the West at war with Russia and, as Biden put it, kick off World War III, a war between nuclear powers. But pressure is building in the West for its troops to enter on the side of Ukraine as a growing number of Democrats and Republicans in Washington voice support for going to war with Russia. The public in the United States is becoming much more supportive of enforcing a no-fly zone over Ukraine and not buying oil and gas from Russia, according to a recent poll by Reuters/Ipsos. It found about 74% of Americans in support of a no-fly zone.   

Anti-Russian sentiment is being reported in many countries. In Ireland and elsewhere, Russian embassies and foreign offices have been the scene of protests and they have been vandalized and even attacked. On Monday, a man in Dublin backed a large truck into the gates of the Russian embassy in protest and spoke out against the Russian invasion and the killing of the family in Irpin before he was calmly arrested by Irish police.  

Russia’s wealthiest individuals, known as oligarchs, are seeing their properties and wealth targeted by Western governments accusing them of having ties to the Kremlin. Russian cultural icons, too, are coming under attack. Last Tuesday, the Munich Philharmonic fired star conductor Valery Gergiev because he would not condemn the Russian invasion. Russian athletes were banned from performing at the Winter Paralympics in Beijing and Roman Abramovitch, a Russian billionaire, sold Chelsea, a top Premiere League soccer club in the United Kingdom.  

ADVERTISEMENT
A Ukrainian police officer helps people while fleeing Irpin in the outskirts of Kyiv, Ukraine, on Monday, March 7, 2022. (AP Photo/Emilio Morenatti)

This week pressure will build in Europe and among Western allies to punish Russia further by not buying its oil and gas exports. So far, the unprecedented economic clobbering of Russia exempted its oil and gas because Europe relies so heavily on them. Germany, though, was pushing back against sanctions on oil and gas because it is so dependent on it.       

On the military front, compared to previous days the weekend saw less fighting and shelling, though civilian and military deaths continued to be reported. Russia's military advance has continued on Kyiv with fresh troops being sent there.  

Russia’s advances, though, have been slowed by stiff resistance from Ukrainian forces, logistical problems and the alleged placement of mines in the path of Russian troops by retreating Ukrainian troops, according to military experts. Ukraine has a large army with about 200,000 soldiers and some 800,000 reservists. Russia massed more than 150,000 troops on Ukraine’s borders prior to the invasion and it is believed that almost all those troops are now inside Ukraine.    

In his pleas for more Western help and for NATO's entry into the war, Zelenskyy is warning that the West must stop Russia as it prepares for a new wave of bombing on Kyiv and other cities where fighting has been intense, such as Kharkiv, the country's second-largest city.   

Russia appears to be preparing for an attack on Odessa, a key port on the Black Sea through which flows many of Ukraine's exports, such as wheat and other grains. The war has brought those exports to a standstill, dangerously driving up food costs around the globe and sparking anxiety and unrest in other countries. Oil prices too are surging upward and adding to existing inflation problems.     

Meanwhile, NATO continues to ship arms to Ukraine and it is working on a deal by which Soviet-era fighter jets now being used by Poland would be transferred to Ukraine. In exchange, Poland would get new American F-16 fighter jets.   

Although NATO troops haven’t been sent to fight, Ukraine is getting help from hundreds of foreign fighters who are signing up for a so-called International Brigade. Veterans from the United States, the United Kingdom and elsewhere are purportedly joining the brigade. On the other side, pro-Russian Chechen militia fighters have been in Ukraine for several days and the Pentagon warned that Russia was seeking to get Syrians into the conflict as well.    

Still, the possibility for diplomatic breakthroughs is growing with Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov and Ukrainian Foreign Minister Dmytro Kuleba were scheduled to meet on Thursday in Turkey, a NATO member with close ties to both Ukraine and Russia. Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan is trying to establish himself as a potential mediator, as is Israeli Prime Minister Naftali Bennett, who flew to Moscow on the weekend to talk with Putin. Israel has not joined the West in its massive sanctions campaign. There are large Jewish populations in both Ukraine and Russia.   

Should the meeting between Lavrov and Kuleba take place, it would be the first time top-level officials in the conflict will have sat down since the invasion started on Feb. 24.    

China, too, is coming under pressure from the West to do more to mediate talks and get Putin to stop the invasion. So far, Chinas has not condemned Russia, though it has called for an end to the conflict. China is seen as a superpower that is deeply against invasions such as Putin’s, but its ties to the Kremlin are becoming much stronger in the wake of efforts by the U.S. to constrain its global ambitions, a dynamic that many political experts warn has created a new Cold War.     

Courthouse News reporter Cain Burdeau is based in the European Union.

Follow @cainburdeau
Categories / Government, International, Politics

Subscribe to Closing Arguments

Sign up for new weekly newsletter Closing Arguments to get the latest about ongoing trials, major litigation and hot cases and rulings in courthouses around the U.S. and the world.

Loading...