Spain Court Refuses to Recognize Catalan Separatist as MEP

MADRID (AFP) — Spain's Supreme Court on Thursday refused to recognize jailed Catalan separatist Oriol Junqueras as a European MP because of his October conviction over a failed 2017 independence bid. 

In a long-awaited ruling, the court said it would not authorize his temporary release from prison to collect his parliamentary credentials — in effect rejecting a December ruling by the European Court of Justice (ECJ).

The court said its ruling "implies the suspension of his status as a European parliamentarian.”

Junqueras won a seat in the European Parliament in May elections despite being in pretrial detention in Spain on charges linked to his role in a banned Catalan referendum and a short-lived declaration of independence. 

But he was prevented from leaving prison in June to attend a Spanish swearing-in ceremony and from traveling to Brussels to take up his post, prompting him to file an appeal.

Last month, the ECJ ruled that Spain should have let him out to receive his credentials after the May elections, saying that even jailed MEPs benefitted from parliamentary immunity — a ruling hailed by Catalan separatists.

But in its response to the ECJ, the Supreme Court decided against allowing him out to collect his accreditation.

It said that the traveling privileges recognized by the ECJ were "not a protective shield against the sentence" and rejected any grounds for the invalidation of the Catalan separatists' trial, which finished a day before Junqueras was declared an MEP-elect, nor of the resulting sentence. 

The court said it had communicated its decision to the European Parliament as well as to Spain's Central Election Committee.

Separatist outrage

The ruling provoked an angry reaction from Junqueras' ERC party, which helped to get Prime Minister Pedro Sanchez through a tight investiture vote two days ago by abstaining. 

"Shame on the Spanish justice system, it is a scandal!" top party official Pere Aragones wrote on Twitter. 

"You cannot ignore the ECJ ruling. Once again, this violates the rights of Junqueras and thousands of citizens who voted for him. We will fight to the end. #FreeMEPJunqueras"

The party's 13 lawmakers agreed on January 2 to abstain during Tuesday's confidence vote in a move that allowed Sanchez to be narrowly confirmed as premier with a margin of just two votes. 

But holding only 155 of the parliament's 350 seats, Sanchez's new coalition government comprising his Socialists and the radical leftwing Podemos will struggle to push through legislation — its first order of business to pass the long-overdue budget. 

It was a dispute over the budget in February last year that ended the fragile alliance backing Sanchez's first government, with Catalan separatists issuing a resounding no in a move that ultimately triggered a general election. 

Thursday's ruling by the Supreme Court also disregarded an advisory opinion issued late last month by the state prosecutor's office, which said Junqueras should be allowed to travel to carry out the necessary formalities. 

But it also said the court should approach the European Parliament "as soon as possible" to suspend his parliamentary immunity. 

© Agence France-Presse

Subscribe to Closing Arguments

Sign up for new weekly newsletter Closing Arguments to get the latest about ongoing trials, major litigation and hot cases and rulings in courthouses around the U.S. and the world.

Email *

Submit