Updates to our Terms of Use

We are updating our Terms of Use. Please carefully review the updated Terms before proceeding to our website.

Sunday, August 25, 2024 | Back issues
Courthouse News Service Courthouse News Service

Shedding light on maritime history

California lighthouses provide photo opportunities, history lessons and plenty of tourism revenue.

AVILA BEACH, Calif. (CN) — Inside the picturesque Point San Luis Lighthouse, docent and author Kathy Mastako leads her group of eight visitors to the seaside Victorian’s kitchen and launches into her familiar spiel.

“I’ll invite you to suspend disbelief for just a couple of moments and time travel back with me to 1890,” she said.

As she described the lighthouse’s first head keeper, Henry Wilson Young, his wife and their four children, it’s easy to picture the family sitting in this cozy room, with wood floors, a coal-burning stove and spectacular views of the Pacific Ocean. And, because fantasy is a big part of the tour’s allure, it’s not difficult to picture yourself sitting at the table, watching whales breach near the Avila Beach shoreline as coffee brews on the stove.

“I think people see it as a very romantic place,” Mastako told Courthouse News. “And I think people do wonder, ‘What would it be like to live here?’”

Built to aid maritime traffic, today, California’s lighthouses represent a significant tourist draw, which explains the state’s $16 million dedication to renovating the photogenic lighthouse at Pigeon Point Light Station State Historic Park.

The lighthouse at Pigeon point provides postcard-worthy photo opportunities. The structure is currently under renovation. (California State Parks)

“We estimate about 200,000 visitors a year stop at the park because we are about 50 miles south of San Francisco and 30 miles north of Santa Cruz, right up along Highway 1,” said Julie Barrow, special projects coordinator with California State Parks. “And many of our visitors are international visitors who make a circuit.”

The history of the lighthouse dates back to 285 B.C., when the Pharos of Alexandria was built on an island at the entrance to the city’s harbor, according to the Lighthouse Preservation Society. As sea travel increased in the 17th century, the number of lighthouses expanded significantly, their powerful beacons warning mariners  of rocks, reefs and currents.

In the United States prior to the mid-19th century, there was a reluctance to spend money on lighthouses, said Jeremy D’Entremont, a historian with the U.S. Lighthouse Society. But as commerce grew in the fledgling nation, so too did a need for safe sea travel.

The creation of the U.S. Lighthouse Board in 1852 launched a new era of lighthouse construction.

“In the early days, it was the merchants that were largely responsible for getting them built,” said D’Entremont, author of several books including the recent “Lighthouses of New Hampshire.”

“They really started building better lighthouses in the second half of the 1800s,” D’Entremont said.

California can’t claim the first lighthouse (Boston, 1716) or the most lighthouses (Michigan, 129). But it does have the largest tourism economy ($150 billion yearly), and its roughly 35 lighthouses inspire photographers, nature lovers, and historians.

“We have a lot of visitors who are lighthouse aficionados, who want to see all the California lighthouses they can,” Barrow, with California State Parks, said.

When lighthouses were first built in the United States, the lights were illuminated sunset to sunrise with wicks, usually burning whale oil or kerosene.

“It had to be lit every night,” Barrow said. “Somebody had to be there to do that, and they had to maintain the flame to keep it burning cleanly and brightly so it was visible.”

Many lighthouses also included fog stations, which created steam whistles that also helped captains navigate.

“Pigeon Point is considered a light station because it had a lighthouse, it had a fog signal building, and it had keepers quarters,” Barrow said.

While some keepers and their families lived solitary lives on rugged and remote locations, several lighthouses, especially those with fog stations, required multiple keepers and their families on site.

ADVERTISEMENT
Docent and author Kathy Mastsko shows visitors the Fresnel lens that used to provide guidance to mariners at Port San Luis (Pat Pemberton/Courthouse News)

“Now you have company, which has its plusses and minuses because you’re living in pretty close quarters,” said Mastako, author of “The Lighthouse at Point San Luis,” published by the United States Lighthouse Society. “If you’re not getting along with your fellow keeper, that’s a problem . . . if the wives weren’t getting along or the kids didn’t get along.”

The Coast Guard assumed control of the nation's lighthouses in 1939.

“They wanted to automate,” Mastako said. “They didn’t want to staff them with people and families, like the old lighthouse keepers.”

Bill Owens, the last lighthouse keeper in California, retired in 1963 after a final stint at Point Cabrillo in Mendocino County. The last staffed lighthouse, at Point Bonita near Sausalito, was abandoned when keeper Mark Van Buskirk, then living in Coast Guard housing, left in 1981.

While most ships now use navigation technology, several lighthouses still offer a guiding light — old-school technology that is resistant to threats like the recent CrowdStrike global IT outage.

“Aside from a major meltdown, electronics can fail, computers can fail,” said D’Entremont, who noted that roughly half the  850 U.S. lighthouses still aid navigation. “It’s a backup, basically, but they’re nowhere near as important as they used to be.”

In California, the state operates five lighthouses. Most others are run by local governments or nonprofits.

“If no governmental or nonprofit organization wants to take it, then the federal government will put the property out to private bid,” Barrow said. “And so there are a number of smaller lights where private individuals have bid on them at auction and become the proud owners of a lighthouse.”

Many lighthouses combine tourist draws.

Located on an Island in San Francisco, the East Brother Light Station, owned by a nonprofit, currently operates as a bed and breakfast. Pigeon Point includes a hostel. The Mark Abbott Memorial Lighthouse in Santa Cruz is home to the Santa Cruz Surfing Museum. And visitors to the very first lighthouse built in California (1854) can see it up close during a tour of the former federal prison at Alcatraz Island.

Kenny Lee Lewis, a member of the Steve Miller Band, performs at the Port San Luis Lighthouse in 2022. Concerts at the lighthouse raise money that helps pay for maintenance. (Pat Pemberton/Courthouse News)

Tours are popular at public lighthouses, as are special events. The nonprofit Point San Luis Lighthouse Keepers hosts a summer concert series where patrons can listen to live music and get guided tours at the same time.

“When we have concerts, it’s open,” Mastako said. “We have docents in the lens room, we have a couple of docents in the house.”

Concerts help support ongoing maintenance. Because old houses do need upkeep.

The tallest lighthouse on the West Coast at 115 feet, Pigeon Point was deemed unsafe in 2001 when large pieces of brick and iron fell from the top of the building and compromised the structural stability, Barrow said.

While other buildings on site are open to the public, a two-year restoration launched this year will allow visitors to also view the lighthouse.

“The contractor has begun work,” Barrow said. “They’ve got scaffolding all the way up.”

Renovating lighthouses preserves the picture-perfect architecture while allowing docents to continue their history lessons, like that of Henry Young, who was the keeper on the rugged, isolated Southeast Farallon Island before he transferred to Point San Luis, where he and his family lived for 15 years until Young transferred to his final stop, Alcatraz.

It was there that Young witnessed the devastating fires caused by the 1906 San Francisco earthquake, writing in his Alcatraz logbook, “San Francisco on fire . . . is this the end of the world? Terrible seeing S.F. from here.”

While Young felt despair from his lighthouse view, for D’Entremont, lighthouses symbolize hope, guidance and strength.

“It’s an example of something built for nothing but good reasons,” said D’Entremont, who hosts the podcast “Light Hearted.”

Mastako shares Young’s Alcatraz story during her tours, but she gets inspired thinking about him in Avila Beach.

“I think the kitchen is my favorite spot, but there’s one other place I like,” she said. “When everybody’s gone, and I’m sitting on the steps in front of the keeper’s house, I look around, and I don’t know what year I’m in. I could be in 1890.”

Categories / Uncategorized

Subscribe to Closing Arguments

Sign up for new weekly newsletter Closing Arguments to get the latest about ongoing trials, major litigation and hot cases and rulings in courthouses around the U.S. and the world.

Loading...