Updates to our Terms of Use

We are updating our Terms of Use. Please carefully review the updated Terms before proceeding to our website.

Tuesday, June 25, 2024 | Back issues
Courthouse News Service Courthouse News Service

Russians Flee Virus Quarantine in Dismay at Hospitals

One patient jumped out of a hospital window to escape her quarantine and another managed to break out by disabling an electronic lock.

MOSCOW (AP) — One patient jumped out of a hospital window to escape her quarantine and another managed to break out by disabling an electronic lock.

Two Russian women who were kept in isolation for fear of possible inflection by the new coronavirus say they fled from their hospitals this month because of uncooperative doctors, poor conditions and fear they would become infected. Russian health authorities haven't commented on their complaints.

The incidents occurred amid the outbreak of the virus in China that has infected more than 40,000 people worldwide and killed more than 1,100. In Russia, only two cases of COVID-19 have been reported. Nevertheless, authorities took vast measures to prevent the disease from spreading and hospitalized hundreds of people who returned from China as a precaution.

Many of those quarantined in Russian hospitals complained about dire conditions of isolation rooms and lack of cooperation from doctors, uncertain about quarantine protocols.

Both women said their hospital ordeals began after returning from Hainan, a tropical region of China popular with Russian tourists.

In a lengthy account on Instagram published Friday, a woman with the screen name of GuzelNeder said her son came down with a cough and a fever of 99.2 F four days after the family returned to their home in the city of Samara. She called emergency services, who diagnosed the boy as having a viral respiratory infection and said the mother and son must go to a hospital for coronavirus tests.

The hospital promised test results within three days, then extended it to five, she said, while the boy responded to treatment with medication and an inhaler. When she tried to press for results, hospital personnel obstructed her, she said.

Meanwhile, she had become concerned about lax procedures in the hospital, saying that some medical personnel came to the isolation area without masks or threw their protective clothing on the floor.

Her anxiety soared on the fifth day, when she began to feel bad. She asked her husband to bring her a home pregnancy test, and "after two minutes of wringing my hands in anticipation, it came on the screen — PREGNANT," she wrote.

Her husband argued with the doctor that she and their son should be released because of her condition and concern of infection. The doctor said they had to be held for 14 days even if the virus test came back negative.

"My son was hysterical," she wrote. "There was no exit for us other than to leave the hospital without authorization, through the window."

Police later questioned her at home, but no charges have been reported. "Everyone in my family is alive and healthy, thank god," she wrote.

The other woman, Alla Ilyina, said in an Instagram post that she came down with a sore throat several days after returning from Hainan to St. Petersburg, Russia's second-largest city.

Ilyina called emergency services, and medics brought her to a hospital for coronavirus testing, promising to let her go after 24 hours. The next day she was told she tested negative for the virus, but had to remain quarantined for two weeks.

"Wild," Ilyina wrote. "All three tests showed I was completely healthy, so why the hell the quarantine?"

Her isolation room was dire, she told the Fontanka newspaper — no books, no shampoo, no Wi-Fi, a wastebasket that was never emptied, the door secured by an electronic lock.

Frustrated, she figured out how to short-circuit the electronic lock and escaped from the hospital on Friday.

Neither the hospital nor police have followed up on her escape, which leads her to believe her health is OK.

"If I were sick, they would have swamped me with phone calls," Fontanka quoted her as saying.

On Tuesday evening, Russian media reported that the hospital reported Ilyina's escape to the police, and that a criminal investigation could be launched.

Both women offered no immediate comment to The Associated Press.

Quarantine protocols in the outbreak vary throughout Russia. In some regions, health officials isolate Chinese nationals who have recently returned from China, and in others everyone who reports symptoms resembling those of the new virus are subject to a 14-day quarantine.

Rospotrebnadzor, Russia's public health watchdog, has not responded to a request for comment on whether the women were allowed to leave the hospitals.

On Wednesday, Fontanka published a video recorded by other patients quarantined in the same hospital Ilyina fled from. The footage shows two young women in what appears to be a patient room singing, "I want to be like Alla (Ilyina)," and a handwritten note saying, "Let us out of here, please."

Categories / Health, International

Subscribe to Closing Arguments

Sign up for new weekly newsletter Closing Arguments to get the latest about ongoing trials, major litigation and hot cases and rulings in courthouses around the U.S. and the world.