Thursday, September 21, 2023
Courthouse News Service
Thursday, September 21, 2023 | Back issues
Courthouse News Service Courthouse News Service

Refugees in Church Sanctuary Hit With Huge Fines

The Trump administration has found a new way to punish refugees and asylum-seekers who come to the United States: Fine them hundreds of thousands of dollars.

CHARLOTTESVILLE, Va. (AP) — Devotional candles to St. Jude, the Holy Trinity and the Virgin of Guadalupe sit on a bookshelf by the door of a classroom in a United Methodist church. A sewing machine is a few feet away between a bed and a set of wicker furniture. In a corner, an electric skillet warming chicken thighs acts as a kitchen.

It is from these makeshift quarters that Maria Chavalan-Sut, an indigenous woman from Guatemala, has spent 10 months staving off a deportation order to a country that she says has scarred her life with violence, trauma and discrimination. Her fight for asylum could cost her at least $214,132.

Chavalan-Sut is among a number of refugees taking sanctuary at houses of worship who have received letters from immigration authorities threatening them with huge fines under the latest move by the Trump administration. It's unclear how many people have been targeted, but Church World Service, an organization that supports refugees, is aware of at least six who've received letters.

"Where am I going to get (money) from? I don't know," said Chavalan-Sut, who worked for a while at a restaurant after arriving in Virginia more than two years ago but hasn't been able to hold a job since seeking sanctuary. "God still has me with my hands to work, and they're the only thing I have. If God thinks that with my hands I can pay that, give me a job."

Chavalan-Sut began living at Wesley Memorial United Methodist Church on Sept. 30, 2018, the day she was told to report to a U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement office for deportation. She crossed the border into and was arrested in November 2016 near Laredo, Texas, after a weeks-long journey that started in Guatemala' City. She said her decision to emigrate and leave her four children behind came after her house was set on fire.

Chavalan-Sut, 44, doesn't know who set the fire while she, her children and their father were asleep inside. But she believes it was linked to a dispute over land rights because she is an indigenous woman, her immigration attorney Alina Kilpatrick said.

Chavalan-Sut said a fire official refused to investigate because there were no fatalities.

Refugees have sought relief from deportation at houses of worship because immigration officials consider them "sensitive locations" in which enforcement action is generally avoided. Forty-five people live in sanctuary at churches across the United States, up from three in 2015, according to Church World Service.

Among them are Honduras native Abbie Arévalo-Herrera and Edith Espinal-Moreno, of Mexico. Arevalo-Herrera took sanctuary at the First Unitarian Universalist Church in Richmond, Virginia, in June 2018, while Espinal-Moreno has been living at the Columbus Mennonite Church in Columbus, Ohio, since October 2017.

Like Chavalan-Sut, both women received notices of fines. The three letters were signed on June 25. Arevalo-Herrera's fine is $295,630, and Espinal-Moreno's was set at $497,777.

Attorneys, activists and faith leaders have decried the fines. Krish O'Mara Vignarajah, president and CEO of Lutheran Immigration and Refugee Service, called them a "scare tactic."

"So long as ICE continues to respect its own policy of avoiding sensitive locations like churches, which may not be a given, the agency will have to continue to resort to psychological games to coerce families out of their legal protections," she said.


Wesley Memorial joined the sanctuary movement after an immigrant rights activist contacted the Rev. Isaac Collins asking for help. The church's 31-year-old pastor said that while he has heard from other pastors who have expressed concern about mixing religion and politics, for him making Wesley Memorial a sanctuary was not a political move: It was a decision based on Christian ethics.

"When you start at, 'Maria is a human being who's in trouble and needs a place of safety,' OK, (that's) very firmly in the realm of ideas in Christianity about hospitality and human rights and loving our neighbors," Collins said.

"The church is a space that can provide that safety and that neutral space while she figures out due process. ... It doesn't get political until your political party is the one saying 'Actually, Maria doesn't deserve all these things.'"

Since seeking sanctuary, Chavalan-Sut has been able to talk to her children, 7, 11, 14 and 21, for an hour a day, making sure the young ones do their homework. The oldest is pursuing a degree in civil engineering. She left them all under the care of a family in Guatemala City. She weeps thinking about them.

The devout Catholic participates in Sunday services at Wesley Memorial with the help of a Spanish translator. She prays daily, and tends to a garden of flowers, herbs and vegetables. She sews headbands and bags using fabric that a son mailed from Guatemala. She can't sell the items, but she accepts donations in exchange. She occasionally cooks tamales and other traditional foods at the church's kitchen.

At least one volunteer guards the church property around the clock. People take turns buying her groceries. Some are helping her learn English. All volunteers have been instructed to ask for a signed warrant should immigration officers show up.

The church also has provided Chavalan-Sut with a mental health therapist. The fire at her home is only one of many traumatic events she says she suffered for being Kaqchikel Maya. As a 7-year-old living in Guatemala's highlands during the country's 1960-1996 civil war, she saw her cousins buried alive.

Indigenous communities disproportionally suffered during the 36-year war. Rachel Nolan, an assistant professor at Boston University whose research includes Central American civil wars, said the Kaqchikel suffered enormous discrimination and violence. While the peace accords signed in 1996 ended large-scale massacres for the most part, she said, indigenous people continue to face violence, including land dispossession.

Carissa Cutrell, a spokeswoman for U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement, said a judge ordered Chavalan-Sut to be deported after she failed to appear for an immigration hearing in July 2017.

Kilpatrick, the immigration attorney, said that was because the notice to appear did not have a date and time, something immigrant rights activists say is common.

Chavalan-Sut's motion to reopen her case was denied in July 2018. An appeal filed in December is pending at the Board of Immigration Appeals.

Cutrell said the Immigration and Nationality Act allows the agency to impose civil fines on people "who have been ordered removed or granted voluntary departure and fail to depart the United States." The fines are calculated at $799 a day, from the date the person took sanctuary to avoid removal.

Refugees like Chavalan-Sut who have received fine notices have 30 days to dispute them in writing or request an interview to respond, which would mean risking leaving their sanctuaries. It's unclear whether any of them, including Chavalan-Sut, have filed paperwork to fight the fines.

For now, Chavalan-Sut has turned to self-help books to try to cope. The Spanish versions of the New York Times best-seller "Rising Strong" by Brene Brown and bilingual evangelist's Jason Frenn's "Power to Persuade" are among the stack of books in her room.

In sanctuary, she said, she has begun to heal.

"I'm just an example of the decisions that governments make," she said. "They do not measure the damage that they are making. They are the ones who plant the seeds, and then many people leave their countries. ... Why do they leave their country? Because they cannot stand it anymore."

Categories / Civil Rights, Government, International, Law, Religion

Read the Top 8

Sign up for the Top 8, a roundup of the day's top stories delivered directly to your inbox Monday through Friday.