Updates to our Terms of Use

We are updating our Terms of Use. Please carefully review the updated Terms before proceeding to our website.

Monday, April 15, 2024 | Back issues
Courthouse News Service Courthouse News Service

R. Kelly trial opens with focus on marriage to underage Aaliyah

A former R. Kelly "superfan" — 14 years old when she met the R&B crooner and 16 allegedly when they started having sex — will be first on the stand after opening arguments in the sweeping abuse trial Wednesday.

BROOKLYN (CN) — Prosecutors outlined decades of sordid sexual allegations against R. Kelly at the start of the singer’s federal trial Wednesday, focusing on the inner ring of associates and employees said to have facilitated the abuse of women and minors while helping Kelly control his victims’ every move. 

U.S. District Attorney Maria Cruz Melendez described a pattern starting in the early 1990s: Kelly would identify a fan eager to meet the rising, and later chart-topping, R&B singer, contact her through an associate and pay for her to travel to come see him. 

“He had his pick of young fans in cities around the country,” Melendez said. 

Four of the six victims in the nine-count indictment were minors when Kelly, now 54, began alleged sexual relationships with them. The singer groomed victims “using every trick in the predator handbook,” Melendez said, instructing them to call him “Daddy,” wear baggy clothing, and keep their heads down when other people — especially other men — were present. 

“He began collecting girls and women as if they were things — hoarding them like objects that he could use however he liked,” Melendez said. 

To ensure “absolute obedience,” including having sex with others at Kelly’s direction, Melendez said the “Trapped in the Closet” singer kept a stash of sensitive or degrading nude and sexual photos and videos, as well as letters falsely admitting to stealing from Kelly. 

Walking through each of the victims in the indictment, Melendez began with the singer Aaliyah, who turned 13 in 1992 when she met R. Kelly, then 25. 

What began with Kelly writing music for the child soon turned into a sexual relationship and then a plan to marry the then-15-year-old Aaliyah in 1994 following a pregnancy scare. “If she is his wife, then she can’t testify against him, or so he thought,” Melendez said. 

This combination photo shows singer R. Kelly at the Cook County Criminal Courthouse in Chicago on May 9, 2008, left, the late R&B singer and actress Aaliyah during a 2001 photo shoot in New York. (AP Photo/File)

As charged in the first count of Kelly’s indictment, Kelly and his associates bribed a public official to create a fake ID for Aaliyah, who died in a plane crash in 2001. The ceremony, Melendez said, was officiated by a minister in a hotel suite. The marriage was later annulled once Aaliyah’s parents learned about it. 

Stephanie, the second alleged victim, met Kelly at a Nike store when she was 16 years old and Kelly was 32, beginning a sexual relationship that lasted for six to eight months. 

Jerhonda Pace, another victim listed in the indictment, was the first to take the stand on Wednesday afternoon. She has spoken publicly in the past about abuse by Kelly, and appeared in the Lifetime docu-series “Surviving R. Kelly," describing first meeting the singer as a 14-year-old “superfan” who skipped school to attend his 2008 child pornography trial in Chicago.

Pace described going to a party at Kelly’s home in Olympia Fields, Illinois, the month after she turned 16 years old. First claiming to be 19, Pace said she exchanged phone numbers with Kelly and later returned to the house, where she undressed for Kelly, who was 42 at the time, and allowed him to perform oral sex on her.

Feeling uncomfortable, Pace told the singer her true age and showed him her ID, she testified.

“He asked me, ‘What is that supposed to mean?’” Pace said, and then instructed her to continue telling others she was 19, and to “act 21.”

Then, she said, “he bent me over the back of a sofa and he took my virginity.”

Over the course of a sexual relationship that lasted six to eight months, Pace said she contracted herpes from Kelly, who is charged with transmitting the disease to several other victims without their consent. She also said she got a tattoo of Kelly’s name on her left breast, at his suggestion, and has since covered it up with a black heart.

ADVERTISEMENT

Pace described having to follow “the rules” imposed by Kelly, under threat of being punished or physically abused. The last time Pace visited the Olympia Fields home, he got angry with her for not acknowledging him when he entered the room.

“That’s when he slapped me and he choked me til I passed out,” she said. “When I got up, I was on the floor.” 

Pace said Kelly spit in her face, and then forced her to perform oral sex on him. She cleaned herself off with a blue Aeropostale t-shirt that she later gave to attorneys while contemplating a civil lawsuit against Kelly; the shirt was admitted into evidence by U.S. Attorney Elizabeth Geddes on Wednesday after Pace identified the garment as hers.

While prosecutors described most illicit relationships as indicating a pattern of manipulation, one victim whom Melendez described on Wednesday believes she was drugged and sexually abused at Kelly’s Chicago recording studio. 

Sonia, a 22-year-old radio intern at the time, traveled to the studio to try to secure an interview with Kelly, Melendez said. When she arrived, an associate of Kelly’s asked if she needed condoms. Her phone and luggage were then searched, and she was brought into a room, finding that the door was locked. 

“Sonia spent approximately three days in that room,” Melendez said, pleading for food and asking to go home. Eventually, someone brought her some Chinese food and a Coke. 

Then, Sonia’s eyes grew heavy and she passed out, awaking to find that her underwear had been removed and Kelly was in the room doing up his pants. She felt a “wetness between her legs that made it clear to her she had been sexually abused while she was not conscious,” Melendez said. 

Responding to the government’s opening remarks was attorney Nicole Blank Becker, whose contact with two of Kelly’s alleged victims was the subject of a conflict-of-interest hearing leading up to trial. 

Becker said that racketeering charges accusing Kelly of heading up an enterprise to kidnap and coerce victims are inappropriate in this case. 

“The government wants you to believe that our client, an internationally known singer, is the leader of some large enterprise, similar to John Gotti, the head of a mob family,” Becker said. “The evidence will show that this is uncharted territory.” 

During remarks that were often rambling, Becker was reminded several times by U.S. District Judge Ann M. Donnelly not to focus on Kelly’s musical accolades or instruct the jury on the law. 

Becker argued that those alleging abuse by Kelly had actually entered “consensual” relationships, some of which were “beautiful.”

“They knew exactly what they were getting into,” she said. “It was no secret that Mr. Kelly had multiple girlfriends.” 

In the first part of her remarks, which will finish after a midday break, Becker did not address the fact that some alleged victims were minors at the time. 

Some alleged victims are outright lying about their experiences, Becker said.

“They will not hold up to scrutiny,” Becker said. “In fact, we believe that their testimony will crumble when it comes to cross-examination. ... Even the government won’t be able to untable the mess of lies.” 

Becker also warned jurors that, “just because someone has 5, 15, 20 witnesses that take the stand,” does not mean Kelly is guilty. 

In addition to victim witnesses, prosecutors plan to call former members of Kelly’s inner circle who arranged travel for alleged victims; clinical and forensic psychologists to discuss grooming methods, trauma, and why victims stay with abusers and delay reporting abuse; and a DNA expert to testify about Kelly’s semen found on a T-shirt of a 16-year-old victim. 

“We are going to ask you to hold the defendant accountable,” Melendez told the jury, for years of abuse, and come to a guilty verdict. 

Follow Nina Pullano on Twitter.

Follow @NinaPullano
Categories / Criminal, Entertainment, Trials

Subscribe to Closing Arguments

Sign up for new weekly newsletter Closing Arguments to get the latest about ongoing trials, major litigation and hot cases and rulings in courthouses around the U.S. and the world.

Loading...