Plea Deal Reached in Ghost Ship Warehouse Fire

OAKLAND, Calif. (CN) – Two men pleaded no contest Tuesday to involuntary manslaughter charges over the deaths of 36 people who perished in the Ghost Ship warehouse fire in Oakland and accepted county jail sentences of nine and six years.

Derick Almena, 48, and Max Harris, 28, entered their pleas in Alameda County Superior Court in downtown Oakland and were pronounced guilty on 36 charges of involuntary manslaughter, avoiding a July 16 jury trial that was slated to last up to six months and which could have put them in prison for the rest of their lives.

Harris, dressed in a red and white striped jail suit, cried as Judge Morris Jacobson read the names of the victims, some of whom were close friends, according to Harris’ lawyer. His voice and Almena’s were barely audible as they entered their pleas for each of the 36 counts, one for each person who died while attending a dance party at the Fruitvale-area warehouse when it burned down on Dec. 2, 2016.

“Max has been and will always be paying for what happened,” Tyler Smith, one of Harris’ attorneys, said outside court. “He’s going to be feeling remorse and sorrow and pain for all of these lives for the rest of his life.”

Both men were found to have negligently run the Ghost Ship, leading to the fire. According to prosecutors, Almena, the building’s master tenant, and Harris, its creative director, illegally rented the warehouse to concert promoters and as many as 25 residents, even though it was only zoned for industrial use; failed to ensure it complied with fire and safety codes; installed a rickety, handmade staircase; and crammed it with flammable materials.

Ghost Ship warehouse after the fire.
[photo credit: Jim Heaphy]
A civil lawsuit also claims the Ghost Ship got its power from an adjacent building via a cable snaked through a hole in the wall.

Almena and Harris both accepted split sentences of 12 and 10 years, respectively. Almena will serve three of those years under supervised release, which is similar to probation. Harris will serve four years under supervised release.

However, with time served and the legal requirement that California inmates serve just half of their sentences, Almena will serve about 3.5 years in custody and Harris 23 months, according to their lawyers.

“It’s not what I would call devastating,” Almena’s attorney, Tony Serra, told reporters.

“This was not a plea he entered into because of legal necessity,” he added of Almena. “We had, from my perspective and many lawyers’ perspectives, viable defenses. This is a plea that has been entered into as a moral imperative to eliminate all of the trauma and pain and suffering that everyone who touches this case endures.”

But the victims’ family members, some of whom were at the hearing, said the sentences weren’t long enough.

“We just wanted some fair justice, not three or four or two years with time served,” said David Gregory, the father of one of the victims. “We don’t feel that in our opinion that was fair justice.”

“Thirty-six lives,” he added.

Gregory is one of a slew of loved ones suing Almena and Harris on civil charges, along with the city of Oakland.

The plaintiffs in the civil case also blame Oakland for the fire, claiming it neglected to inspect and shut down the Ghost Ship for not being up to code, though police and fire personnel visited repeatedly before the fire and knew it was unsafe, and the city planning and building department had received multiple reports of dangerous conditions there.

Harris’ lawyer, Curtis Briggs, also blamed city officials Tuesday, who he accused of “botch[ing] this entire situation.”

In May, it emerged that the scene of the fire was never tested for arson, and an investigator destroyed evidence by removing and destroying debris left behind by the fire. Almena’s and Harris’ lawyers had argued that the evidence could have exonerated their clients.

“What they did and didn’t do leading up to the Ghost Ship tragedy and what they did in investigating it is completely unacceptable,” Briggs said outside court. “And today, when the focus may be on Mr. Harris and Mr. Almena, it should be on the city of Oakland and what it is doing to prevent this in the future.”

Briggs said reaching a plea agreement had been difficult, in part because Harris’ defense team pushed back on the idea that he should serve jail time for his role in the fire.

Harris, who also collected rent from tenants, was accused of blocking off one of only two stairwells in preparation for the night’s festivities.

Most of the victims died of smoke inhalation, trapped on the second floor.

Mary Alexander, who represents 11 of the victim’s families in the civil case, said having Almena and Harris pronounced guilty by the judge had given the families a “small sense” of justice.

“Each name was read,” she said. “Each name was a life.”

Sentencing is scheduled for Aug. 9 and 10.

The civil trial is scheduled to begin Oct. 7, 2019.

 

%d bloggers like this: