Updates to our Terms of Use

We are updating our Terms of Use. Please carefully review the updated Terms before proceeding to our website.

Thursday, May 23, 2024 | Back issues
Courthouse News Service Courthouse News Service

Ohio School District Arms Its Teachers

At the entrance to Sidney High School in small-town Ohio, there is a poster that states: “Inside this building, our children are protected by an armed and trained response team.”

SIDNEY, Ohio (AFP) — At the entrance to Sidney High School in small-town Ohio, there is a poster that states: “Inside this building, our children are protected by an armed and trained response team.”

In rural Shelby County in west central Ohio, law enforcement trained some teachers to fight back should an attacker threaten students. They were among the first in the United States to embrace the controversial strategy.

On Halloween, as high school students and staff roam the hallways, John Pence — a gun on his belt — patrols calmly.

He is a full-time resource officer, assigned to Sidney High. That arrangement has become commonplace across the country, as the number of school shootings has multiplied.

But he has backup: the response team of armed teachers, who have volunteered for the job.

So far, about 15 states have approved similar set-ups, but many are not happy about putting weapons in the hands of teachers.

Pence rejects the usual arguments, saying: "In some areas, probably it might not work — maybe in a city. But most of these employees have been exposed to some type of firearms training beforehand."

One Sidney teacher, who cannot be named in order to protect the confidential nature of the armed response team, is one such case. He is an avid hunter.

He says he had "no fears, no hesitations" about carrying a gun in school — even if that means that one day he could face the prospect of shooting at one of his students.

"That's one of those boxes that mentally you can have to check," he said.

"I have a wife and I have kids so if anybody is going to try to do any harm to them, this is what I'm going to do. This is what has to be done if it's a student that is causing the threat.

"The other students being threatened, they have the right to go home to their parents that night too."

Sidney (est. pop. 22,000) is the seat of Shelby County (est. pop. 49,500), about 40 miles east of the Indiana line. Sidney is 86% white and 7% black, according to city-data.com. Its median household income of $48,227 is 8% below the statewide median of $52,334, and the median value of a home or condo there, $116,307, is 17% below the statewide median of $104,000, according to city-data.

The idea of arming teachers — “the program,” as those in Sidney call it —surfaced after the Newtown, Connecticut shooting in 2012, in which 26 people, including 20 children, were killed at Sandy Hook Elementary School.

The shooter also shot his mother to death before taking his own life.

After that horrific attack, Shelby County Sheriff John Lenhart said he realized how vulnerable the schools in his area were.

He pushed for new safety measures as he contemplated a hard truth: "The rule of thumb is after the first shot is fired, every 17 seconds after that, somebody dies. So you need an immediate response."

But he never suggested that teachers should give lessons or patrol the hallways with a gun on their hip.

"I didn't want our schools to look like the Wild, Wild West, like an armed fortress," Lenhart said.

The response team has access to 9mm Glock pistols, which are kept, along with ammunition, in small black safes that open when the digital fingerprint of an authorized user is scanned.

Bob Humble, the superintendent of Sidney's school district, which teaches 3,500 students in six buildings, is proud of being a trailblazer. He thinks the team offers a compelling deterrent to any "crazy people with guns."

"Their goal is to get the highest body count they can in the shortest amount of time," Humble said. "This is why I think the chances of this happening are very low now, simply because they know someone's going to take them down in a hurry."

Humble says having such a security team "is just common sense."

"The kids don't think anything about it. You can't really hear anyone talking about it — it's just embedded into the community now."

At the end of a school day, parents, grandparents and babysitters sit in an orderly line of cars, waiting to retrieve their young charges.

David Bishop, who is picking up his granddaughter, says the armed response team at Sidney High is fine with him.

"My granddaughter, she knows how to handle a gun," he says.

"Her brother and dad have guns, her mother too. She's too young yet, but they have taught her how to respect a gun and how to use it if needed."

High school senior Tom, who is 18 and asked that his last name not be used, said students hardly talk about “the program” in their free time.

"We all know the weapons are there, but it doesn't really concern us. I know they are locked up in a safe; the kids can't get them," he said.

He says he has faith in the teachers to protect him.

"I like the idea. It makes me feel safe because I know they are specially trained if an intruder comes in and they are able to stop him," Tom said.

Before being invited to join the program, teachers are vetted in "serious interviews" and their criminal records are checked, Lenhart said.

After an initial 20 hours of training by police, teachers go through refresher courses once a month.

"I'm very confident that our schools are some of the safest in the nation," Lenhart said.

One teacher who is part of the response team said he believes the vetting process is airtight, so the team can be trusted.

As an example, he said that a few years ago two teachers on staff were going through a divorce.

The male teacher was immediately removed from the program and his access to the safes revoked while his personal life was in turmoil.

Since the Sandy Hook shooting in 2012, there have been at least 239 school shootings in the United States, at which 438 people were shot and at least 138 died — roughly 20 gun murders a year at schools.


© Agence France-Presse

(Courthouse News contributed to this report.)

Categories / Education

Subscribe to Closing Arguments

Sign up for new weekly newsletter Closing Arguments to get the latest about ongoing trials, major litigation and hot cases and rulings in courthouses around the U.S. and the world.