NOAA Emails Show Shock at Trump the Weatherman

WASHINGTON (AP) — A flurry of newly released emails from scientists and top officials at the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration illustrates the consternation and outright alarm caused by President Trump's false claim that Hurricane Dorian could hit Alabama. A top NOAA official called Trump’s behavior "crazy."

What the scientists and officials found even more troubling was a statement later issued by an unnamed NOAA spokesman that supported Trump's claim and repudiated the agency's own forecasters.

The emails, released late Friday in response to Freedom of Information Act requests from The Associated Press and others, give an inside picture of the scramble to respond to Trump and the turmoil it caused inside the federal agency.

"What's next? Climate science is a hoax?" Craig McLean, NOAA's acting chief scientist, wrote in an email sent to the agency's top officials. "Flabbergasted to leave our forecasters hanging in the political wind."

In a more formal letter, McLean wrote that what concerned him most was that the Trump administration "is eroding the public trust in NOAA for an apparent political recovery from an ill-timed and imprecise comment from the president."

As Dorian headed for the southeastern United States in early September, Trump tweeted that Alabama was "most likely to be hit (much) harder than anticipated."

The National Weather Service in Birmingham corrected him, tweeting that "Alabama will NOT see any impacts from #Dorian."

But Trump remained adamant, and NOAA came to his defense with the unsigned statement, which claimed that some data provided to the president had indicated that Alabama could be hit by the hurricane and scolded the Birmingham office. The statement was issued after the White House and Commerce Department intervened, the AP and others reported at the time.

The incident was widely covered, as Trump showed a NOAA-prepared weather map of Dorian’s expected path, which someone had altered, apparently with a Sharpie, to show the story could hit Alabama. Trump is a well-known user of Sharpies.

It provoked angry emails from within the agency and from the public.

Gary Shigenaka, a NOAA scientist, wrote to the agency's acting administrator, Neil Jacobs, asking him to "reassure those of us who serve the public ... that we are not mere pawns in an absurd game."

In response, Jacobs defended the forecasters and said: "You have no idea how hard I'm fighting to keep politics out of science."

"Apparently the president is convinced that Alabama was in the path of Dorian and someone altered a NOAA map (with a Sharpie) to convince folks," NOAA official Makeda Okolo wrote in an email to chief operating officer Benjamin Friedman and others.

Friedman replied: "Yep, crazy."

Subscribe to Closing Arguments

Sign up for new weekly newsletter Closing Arguments to get the latest about ongoing trials, major litigation and hot cases and rulings in courthouses around the U.S. and the world.

Email *

Submit