No Halt to US Culture Wars During Pandemic

WASHINGTON (AP) — A partisan fight over voting in Wisconsin was the first issue linked to the coronavirus to make it to the Supreme Court. Efforts to limit abortion during the pandemic could eventually land in the justices’ hands. Disputes over guns and religious freedom also are popping up around the country.

The virus outbreak has put much of American life on hold, but the combatants in the nation's culture wars aren't taking a ceasefire.

In a country deeply divided over politics, Republicans are increasingly being accused of using the crisis to advance partisan held goals, especially access to abortion and the ballot box. Conservatives have complained about restrictions on church services and gun shops.

"We see the right as being very opportunistic to advance their agenda," said Marge Baker, executive vice president of the liberal People for the American Way.

Tim Schmidt, founder and president of the U.S. Concealed Carry Association, called restrictions on gun sales "a knee-jerk response to something we don't quite understand. I hope and pray it doesn't happen but that's what I fear."

The clash over this Tuesday's election in Wisconsin was just one fight sparked by the coronavirus. Right-wing majorities on both the U.S. Supreme Court and Wisconsin Supreme Court rejected efforts to delay the vote and extend absentee balloting. The rulings signal an approaching season of bitter election-related litigation, said University of California at Irvine law professor Richard Hasen.

"It is a very bad sign for November that the court could not come together and find some form of compromise here in the midst of a global pandemic unlike anything we have seen in our lifetimes," Hasen wrote about the U.S. Supreme Court justices on his Election Law blog.

"And it does not look like the courts are going to be able to do any better than the politicians in finding common ground on election principles."

Presumptive Democratic presidential nominee Joe Biden has said the country should be looking "to all-mail ballots across the board" because of the pandemic. But President Trump has weighed in strongly against voting by mail, though he himself casts absentee ballots and Republicans have often favored mail-in ballots especially for older people.

More fights over elections may be ahead, but the pandemic has already led to clashes in multiple states over abortion access. In Republican-led Alabama, Iowa, Ohio, Oklahoma and Texas, governors sought to prohibit almost all abortions by classifying them as elective procedures that should be put off during the pandemic.

Those efforts have, so far, been mostly blocked. In Iowa, the American Civil Liberties Union and the state reached an agreement that allows women to obtain "essential" surgical abortions. Federal court rulings have allowed abortions to continue in Alabama, Ohio and Oklahoma.

But not in Texas, where the Fifth U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in New Orleans held 2-1 Tuesday that the state's restrictions on abortions could remain in place during the pandemic. Fifth Circuit Judge Kyle Duncan, a Trump appointee, wrote for the court that the epidemic justified "emergency measures that curtail constitutional rights so long as the measures have at least some 'real or substantial relation' to the public health crisis."

The ruling drew a blistering dissent from Judge James Dennis, a Bill Clinton appointee, who said that results in cases involving abortion at the conservative Fifth Circuit don't stem from "the law or facts, but because of the subject matter."

Abortion rights groups on Wednesday went back to a lower court in an effort to resume abortions, and the case could reach the Supreme Court. Nancy Northup, president of the Center for Reproductive Rights, said Texas "has been trying to end abortion for decades and they are exploiting this pandemic to achieve that goal."

Abortion clinics aren't the only places that states have sought to close during the pandemic. Gun stores, too, have been targeted. Most states have deemed gun-sellers essential businesses allowed to remain open during the emergency. But three states — Massachusetts, New Mexico and Washington — forced those businesses to close.

Gun rights groups have gone to court to pressure New Jersey's Democratic governor, Phil Murphy, and local officials in North Carolina to reverse course on gun restrictions. Other lawsuits are pending in California.

Joe Bartozzi, president and CEO of the National Sports Shooting Foundation, said closing the stores is the wrong answer. "You don't want to, in a time of crisis, be suspending civil liberties," Bartozzi said, despite the widespread stay-at-home orders that most Americans have accepted.

Gun-control advocates said the National Rifle Association and allied groups are using the pandemic to advance their cause. "This is part of their playbook for many years, which is to foment fear during a time of crisis," said Shannon Watts, founder of the gun-control group Moms Demand Action.

Some churches have become embroiled in fights about whether they can stay open. Some states’ stay-at-home orders have specifically exempted some level of religious activity, but that hasn't prevented clashes.

In Kansas, leaders of the Republican-controlled Legislature overturned Democratic Gov. Laura Kelly's executive order limiting the size of religious gatherings during the pandemic.

"It appears to be out of line and extreme and clearly in violation, a blatant violation, of our fundamental rights," said state Senate President Susan Wagle of Wichita, an abortion opponent. Wagle questioned why abortion clinics remained open, while churches faced restrictions.

Three Houston-area pastors sued over potential fines for holding religious services during the pandemic.

"We believe the government's power stops at the church doors," said Jared Woodfill, a lawyer who represents the pastors and said he's working on three other pandemic-related church lawsuits in Texas, even though Texas Gov. Greg Abbott's executive order deems religious services essential.

He said it's ironic that Wisconsin held elections. "You had elections but you can't have church?" he asked.

Chase Strangio, an American Civil Liberties Union lawyer, took to Twitter to offer a different take on the same set of facts.

"Covid-19: just dangerous enough to block abortion but not dangerous enough to hold elections by mail," Strangio wrote.

Subscribe to Closing Arguments

Sign up for new weekly newsletter Closing Arguments to get the latest about ongoing trials, major litigation and hot cases and rulings in courthouses around the U.S. and the world.

Email *

Submit