Updates to our Terms of Use

We are updating our Terms of Use. Please carefully review the updated Terms before proceeding to our website.

Friday, April 19, 2024 | Back issues
Courthouse News Service Courthouse News Service

No Crowds on California Beaches as Counties Look to Reopen

Beaches were mostly empty over the warm weekend as Californians heeded stay-at-home orders in anticipation that Gov. Gavin Newsom might ease some restrictions this week, while some rural communities announced plans to reopen on their own timetable.

SAN FRANCISCO (AP) — Beaches were mostly empty over the warm weekend as Californians heeded stay-at-home orders in anticipation that Gov. Gavin Newsom might ease some restrictions this week, while some rural communities announced plans to reopen on their own timetable.

In Orange County, where beaches were singled out for closure by the governor during the coronavirus pandemic, crowds were sparse as lifeguards and police patrolled and issued warnings to people to stay off the sand.

A Huntington Beach police spokeswoman said people were cooperating and no citations had been issued as of Sunday afternoon. In neighboring Newport Beach, police put out barricades and spoke with surfers to advise them of the closure and said people were quick to comply.

Meanwhile Modoc County on the state's far northern end allowed businesses to open in defiance of the governor's shutdown rules amid the coronavirus pandemic, and two counties north of Sacramento said they would follow suit.

There haven't been any confirmed cases of COVID-19 among Modoc's 9,000 residents, which Sheriff Tex Dowdy said was a deciding factor in allowing a "staged, safe" reopening of hair salons, churches, restaurants and the county's only movie theater.

Businesses could only have half the patrons, and customers must stay 6 feet apart. No problems were reported over the weekend, officials said.

In Alturas, Antonio's Cucina Italiana will remain delivery- and takeout-only for the time being, owner Stan Yagi said Sunday.

"We had to scale everything back and we're just not ready to reopen the dining room yet," said Yagi, who has owned the restaurant since 1997. Some of the longtime employees have underlying health problems and he doesn't want to put them at risk, he said.

Yagi said he appreciates the need for widespread shutdowns in more populated communities. But he understands the decision by his fellow business owners to defy the governor's orders.

"They're hurting and they need to open. We're all mom and pop places up here and it's been difficult," he said.

Elsewhere, a variety of businesses from restaurants to hairstylists in rural and more populated areas have opened their doors in individual acts of defiance.

Yuba and Sutter counties plan to allow some businesses to reopen on Monday as long as they follow social distancing protocols. The counties are not only much bigger with a combined population of about 175,000 people, many of whom commute to jobs in the capital region, but have had 50 confirmed cases of the disease and three deaths.

Jesse Villicana, the owner of Cool Hand Luke's steakhouse in Yuba City, said 25 employees who were laid off during the stay-at-home order returned to work Sunday to help prepare for the reopening.

He was anxious to welcome customers back into the bar and dining room but wary of the slow return to business as usual. Customers must sit one booth apart from each other, meaning he can only fill half of the restaurant.

"We were running at 80% capacity before all this. It's going to be tough to pay all the bills," Villicana said.

Newsom acknowledged the building economic anxiety while repeatedly teasing the possibility the state could begin relaxing aspects of the restrictions this week.

"We are all impatient," the governor said during his daily briefing Friday.

But the governor also noted that while hospitalization statistics are heading in a better direction, the state still has a growing number of infections and deaths.

Nearly 2,200 Californians have died from coronavirus and more than 53,000 have been confirmed to have it, according to data compiled by Johns Hopkins University, though the number of infections is thought to be far higher because of a shortage of testing.

Orange County beach cities argue that most of the tens of thousands of people who hit their shores during a heatwave last weekend did practice anti-virus safety measures and fumed that they were being unfairly singled out.

On Friday, a judge refused a request by Huntington Beach and others to block Newsom's order to close the beaches. Judge Nathan Scott said he weighed the harm the closures caused the city and others, but the virus's threat to public safety should take priority. He said he will consider the issue again May 11.

In Northern California, Santa Cruz County began on Saturday to close all beaches between 11 a.m. to 5 p.m. to let residents visit the beach in the early morning or sunset hours and deter day trippers from hanging out there.

Beaches are just the latest focus for frustrations over Newsom's month-and-a-half-old order requiring nearly 40 million residents to remain mostly indoors. Businesses not deemed essential are closed until COVID-19 testing, hospital and death rates indicate the state outbreak is beginning to ease. Millions have been unable to work.

While Newsom has promised a cautious, phased reopening of the state, protesters don't want to wait.

In Huntington Beach, police estimated 2,500 to 3,000 people gathered for May Day on a beachside street. In Sacramento, as police lined steps outside the Capitol, protesters on Friday waved signs that said "Defend Freedom" and broke into "U-S-A" chants. A few rallies took place over the weekend, though attendance was significantly smaller.

For the vast majority of people, coronavirus causes mild or moderate symptoms. For some, especially older adults and people with existing health problems, it can cause more severe illness, including pneumonia, and death.

The fear is that the virus can be spread in close quarters by people who don't known they've contracted it, and allowing too much contact too soon could lead to a second surge of cases.


By DAISY NGUYEN and CHRISTOPHER WEBER

Categories / Entertainment, Government, Health

Subscribe to Closing Arguments

Sign up for new weekly newsletter Closing Arguments to get the latest about ongoing trials, major litigation and hot cases and rulings in courthouses around the U.S. and the world.

Loading...