ATLANTA (CN) - The 11th Circuit has held that the News-Journal Corp. should pay the owner of the Atlanta-Journal Constitution and 16 other daily newspapers $129.2 million for its 47.5 percent stake in the company.
Cox Enterprises, an Atlanta-based media partner, sued the News-Journal in May 2004, claiming its executives wasted money on pet projects - including a $29 million "upscale performing arts center" - without telling Cox officials. The News-Journal allegedly forked out $13 million for the right to name the center.
Facing allegations of fraud, waste and mismanagement, the News-Journal opted to buy Cox's shares at "fair value."
But the parties were unable to agree on a fair price, so the district court held a bench trial to determine how much Cox's shares were worth.
Experts on each side argued for starkly contrasting fair-market values: Cox's expert claimed the 47.5 percent share came to $145.35 million, while the defendant's expert said it came to only $29.41 million.
The circuit affirmed an assessment closer to the estimate given by Cox's expert. As partner in a firm specializing in evaluating newspapers, he was "plainly qualified" to testify about the fair value of Cox's shares, the court ruled. The News-Journal's expert was deemed qualified, but "appreciably less so." See ruling.
Subscribe to Closing Arguments
Sign up for new weekly newsletter Closing Arguments to get the latest about ongoing trials, major litigation and hot cases and rulings in courthouses around the U.S. and the world.