New Yorkers’ Anxieties Ramped Up on the Subways

NEW YORK (AP) — They let trains that look too crowded pass by. If they decide to board, they search for emptier cars to ride in. They size up fellow passengers before picking a spot to sit or stand for commutes sometimes lasting an hour or more.

This quiet calculus is performed daily by people who must keep working during the coronavirus pandemic and say the social distancing required is nearly impossible in the enclosed spaces of New York City's public transit system.

The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention says that people should stay 6 feet apart. But even though ridership has plummeted in the city, making jampacked trains and buses the exception rather than the rule, passengers aren't always guaranteed even 6 inches.

"Everybody is very scared," Shaderra Armstead, a health care clinic receptionist who rides the subway to work, said this week. "They're trying to keep their distance from each other, but it's impossible.

"It makes me not want to go on the train at all," she said. "I'm nervous every day, but I still have to go."

Riders on some trains in Brooklyn and Queens this week sat or stood in some cars within a few feet of one another, some with their faces uncovered, while keeping their distance from homeless people camped out. At the same time, there are images showing subway platforms mostly empty at times they'd typically be crowded.

Transit officials say they're working harder than ever to protect passengers and their own workers amid a pandemic that has killed more than 7,000 New Yorkers in a few weeks, mostly in the city and its suburbs. Several suburban counties in New Jersey and Connecticut also have registered significant numbers of deaths.

The virus has taken the lives of 41 employees of the Metropolitan Transportation Authority, which runs the city's buses and subway and many commuter trains.

"We want as little social density and as much social distance as we can get," MTA Chairman Patrick Foye said in a radio interview Tuesday.

Foye, who contracted the virus but is doing fine, called scenes of crowding on trains "episodic" and said that safety measures are working well enough that complaints by riders about overcrowding have dried up in recent days.

The challenges aren't unique to New York. In Philadelphia, where at least three transit workers have died from Covid-19, the Southeastern Pennsylvania Transit Authority said it will move to a "lifeline" service Thursday, closing some stations and limiting rail and bus service to core routes.

London, Paris and South Korea have also struggled to keep public transport running.

In London, where ridership is down as much as 93% from the same point last year, images posted on social media have shown some trains crowded at rush hour, as fewer are running because of staff illnesses. Fourteen London transport workers have died from the virus, including eight bus drivers.

In New York, too, use of all forms of mass transit has plummeted.

Ridership on the subways Monday was down 92% compared to a normal weekday. The commuter rail lines serving Long Island had 97% fewer passengers. On Metro-North, which serves the city's northern suburbs, including those in Connecticut, ridership was down by 95%. On MTA buses, it is down more than 60%.

The agency has cut back bus service by about 25%, reduced the number of trains running on weekdays on the Long Island Rail Road from around 740 to around 500 and on Metro-North from 713 to 424.

While subways and buses are far less crowded than normal, there are still moments too close for comfort in the age of coronavirus.

Waiting for a Manhattan-bound train on the Queens platform, Ebrahima Sumareh said he searches for the least crowded subway car he can find before boarding.

"I'm scared for people to touch me, to get close to me," said Sumareh, a railroad quality control clerk. "I'm scared for other people too."

He's worried some of his fellow riders might not be following the distancing protocols in their lives, not just on the trains, he said. "New Yorkers, we don't listen."

To keep trains from getting too crowded, New York's MTA says it has sought to keep up normal service on the most-used routes. Police direct people on subway platforms to less crowded sections of trains. Riders are urged to cover their faces and to report situations where social distancing isn't being observed.

The agency has posted signs on some trains that state: "Essential Worker, yes, OK to ride. … No — Why are you even reading this? Go home."

The MTA has sought to help protect employees by distributing 300,000 medical grade masks, 160,000 surgical masks, and 2.5 million pairs of gloves to its employees since March 1, Foye said.

Queens subway rider Bhargav Munagala said Tuesday that during his commute to his job as a project manager for a food packing and delivery service, he tries "to give respect to the very important people" like nurses.

"Most of the people I look at now are tired," while others act "crazy," he said. "That's New York."

Subscribe to Closing Arguments

Sign up for new weekly newsletter Closing Arguments to get the latest about ongoing trials, major litigation and hot cases and rulings in courthouses around the U.S. and the world.

Email *

Submit