Monday, June 5, 2023 | Back issues
Courthouse News Service Courthouse News Service

New York Reforms Law on Police Discipline Records

New York state lawmakers repealed a decades-old law Tuesday that has kept law enforcement officers’ disciplinary records secret, spurred by the national uproar over the death of George Floyd.

ALBANY, N.Y. (AP) — New York state lawmakers repealed a decades-old law Tuesday that has kept law enforcement officers’ disciplinary records secret, spurred by the national uproar over the death of George Floyd.

The measure to make officers’ records and misconduct complaints public is among several police accountability bills racing through the New York Legislature. Lawmakers passed other bills that would provide all state troopers with body cameras and require police officers to provide medical and mental health attention to people in custody.

Many of those bills were proposed years ago, but got momentum after huge protests nationwide condemned police brutality.

The passage came as criminal charges were brought Tuesday against an NYPD officer for his rough treatment of a protester during demonstrations after the death of Floyd, who died as a white Minneapolis police officer pressed a knee on his neck for nearly 9 minutes on May 25.

Eliminating the law, known as Section 50-a, would make complaints against officers, transcripts and final dispositions of disciplinary proceedings, public for the first time in decades.

Governor Andrew Cuomo, who has recently supported reforming the law, said he will sign the repeal. Only Delaware has a similar law.

Momentum for ending the secrecy law reached a crescendo in recent days as marchers filled streets in Brooklyn, Manhattan, Buffalo and elsewhere to rally against police abuses — amplifying the calls of reform advocates who spent years pushing for change in the wake of other high-profile police killings, including that of Eric Garner in 2014.

"This is no time for rejoicing," said state Sen. Kevin Parker, a Democrat representing parts of Brooklyn. "This bill has been around for over a decade … and the only reason why we're bringing it to the floor now because the nation is burning."

Several family members of New Yorkers killed by police officers gathered at New York City Hall Tuesday to call for police reforms and repealing 50-a, which state courts have cited in decisions to withhold officers’ personnel records.

"We are tearing down the wall of secrecy that has been shielding officers across the state," said Constance Malcolm, mother of the late Ramarley Graham, who was unarmed when he was shot to death by a white NYPD officer in the bathroom of his apartment in 2012.

The state Senate and Assembly passed the 50-a repeal largely along party lines, as Republicans said the law would allow release of unsubstantiated or false complaints against officers.

But one of the bill's sponsors, state Sen. Jamaal Bailey, a Bronx Democrat, said the public has a right to view complaints: "Sometimes unsubstantiated complaints happen because people don't want to follow up."

The Legislature on Monday passed other police accountability measures, banning police from using chokeholds, guaranteeing the right to record police activity and making it easier to file lawsuits against people making race-based 911 calls.

As lawmakers acted on accountability legislation, NYPD Officer Vincent D’Andraia was being arraigned on assault and other charges days after a bystander recorded him pushing protester Dounya Zayer, causing her to hit her head on the pavement.

D'Andraia was released after his attorney entered a not guilty plea on his behalf. The officer was ordered to stay away from Zayer, who was hospitalized after the May 29 altercation with what she said were a concussion and a seizure.

"Dounya was assaulted for the very reason she was protesting, and that's police brutality," said Zayer's attorney, Tahanie Aboushi, adding that D'Andraia's supervisor should face punishment beyond an announced reassignment.

"If not for this being on video it would have been business as usual for the NYPD," Aboushi said.

Brooklyn District Attorney Eric Gonzalez said he was "deeply troubled by this unnecessary assault." Zayer, 20, called D'Andraia a coward and said the assault would deepen mistrust of law enforcement.

"I was protesting for a reason," Zayer said in a video tweeted from her hospital bed. The officer, she said, "should have had the self-restraint to not hurt the people he's supposed to be protecting."

The police department suspended D'Andraia, 28, last week without pay. His attorney, Stephen Worth, did not immediately respond to a request for comment. If convicted, D'Andraia could face a year behind bars, but first-time offenders rarely see any jail time.

D'Andraia is the first New York City police officer to face criminal charges for alleged misconduct during days of unrest that roiled the city in the wake of Floyd's death in Minneapolis. Two Buffalo officers were charged with assault last week after they were seen on video shoving a 75-year-old protester to the ground.

D'Andraia's union said de Blasio and police leaders were "sacrificing cops to save their own skin" by sending officers out to protests with "no support and no clear plan."

"They should be the ones facing this mob-rule justice," Police Benevolent Association president Pat Lynch said. "We will say it again: New York City police officers have been abandoned by our leadership. We are utterly alone in our efforts to protect our city."


Categories: Civil Rights Government Law

Read the Top 8

Sign up for the Top 8, a roundup of the day's top stories delivered directly to your inbox Monday through Friday.