Updates to our Terms of Use

We are updating our Terms of Use. Please carefully review the updated Terms before proceeding to our website.

Monday, May 27, 2024 | Back issues
Courthouse News Service Courthouse News Service

New York Bids Bon Voyage to Marble Statues Looted From Lebanon

New York officials held a ceremony Friday to mark the return to Lebanon of three marble sculptures that predate the dawn of the Roman Empire.

MANHATTAN (CN) - New York officials held a ceremony Friday to mark the return to Lebanon of three marble sculptures that predate the dawn of the Roman Empire.

“We were told the big sculpture was worth $800 million,” said Majdi Ramadan, consul general of Lebanon in New York.

Towering nearly seven feet high from its display on a pedestal, the 6th century B.C. statue to which Ramadan had been referring depicts the marble torso of a calf bearer.

As reported in October by The New York Times, Manhattan prosecutors only got wind of the statue while preparing for a court battle over a marble bull’s head.

Colorado collectors Lynda and William Beierwaltes acquired both pieces in 1996 and then sold them to New York collector Michael Steinhardt.

Lebanon requested the return of the bull’s head when a curator at the Metropolitan Museum of Art, where Steinhardt had loaned the piece, raised concerns about its provenance.

When Steinhardt asked the Beierwalteses for his money back, the couple brought a short-lived federal complaint against Manhattan District Attorney Cyrus Vance.

The Times noted that one of the assistant prosecutors in Vance’s office spotted the calf bearer in a photograph of the Beierwalteses’ home that appeared in a profile of the couple in a June 1998 issue of House & Garden magazine.

After reviewing the evidence of the sculptures’ theft, however, the Beierwalteses dropped their court challenge.

Both pieces and a second, much smaller, torso were on display Friday in an eighth-floor conference room of the Manhattan District Attorney’s Office.

The bull’s head is the oldest of the three, said to have been chiseled in 360 B.C. Like the calf bearer, the bull’s head was originally found at the Temple of Eshmun, excavated in 1967 from this ancient place of worship near Sidon in southwestern Lebanon.

Before its theft in 1981, during the Lebanese Civil War, the bull’s head was transferred to the Byblos Citadel in Jubayl.

Prosecutors say the smaller torso is from the 4th century B.C. and was excavated from the Temple of Eshmun in the 1970s.

They did not offer a valuation of this piece, but said the calf bearer was worth $4.5 million and the bull’s head was worth $1.2 million.

At Friday’s repatriation ceremony, District Attorney Vance emphasized that sticker prices are a poor way to evaluate the sculptures.

“When you put a price tag on these artifacts, however, it is all too easy to forget that these are not just valuable collector’s items — these are rare, celebrated remnants of entire civilizations’ culture and history," Vance said.

Assistant District Attorney Matthew Bogdanos described the route these types of stolen antiquities follow to end up in New York.

“They leave a war-torn area or an area that is undergoing civil war or civil strife,” Bogdanos said. “They get in the hands of dealers who are less than scrupulous in determining its origin. Then they make their way through auction houses and other dealers in New York.”

Ramadan noted that the process of getting these three pieces back to Lebanon was not very heated.

“What’s really wonderful about this repatriation, the whole process took months, which is really unheard of, I understand,” he said. “We’re very happy, and we expect more to happen in the future.”

Prosecutors have their work cut out for them. “These pieces were stolen along with 500 other pieces back in 1981,” Ramadan noted.

But “with the kind of leadership and the cooperation we’re seeing from the Office of the District Attorney,” he continued, “I’m certain that there’s going to be more of these heirlooms, and I hope it’s not going to take long.”

Angel M. Melendez, special agent-in-charge of homeland security investigations in New York, spoke at the press conference as well. “These three pieces have traveled through the underworld of art, being recovered here in New York,” she said. “Now it is time that they are returned to Lebanon, their rightful home.”

Vance put antiquities collectors on notice in an October statement when the Beierwalteses dropped their suit. “The art world must acknowledge that stolen antiquities are not simply collectible commercial property, but evidence of cultural crimes committed around the world,” he said, according to the Times. “These important historical relics must be treated with caution and care, and galleries, auction houses, museums, and individual collectors must be willing to conduct proper due diligence to ensure that an item has not been unlawfully acquired.”

Ramadan said the smaller marble torso might be worth $300,000 and that the bull’s head was worth $2 million. The Lebanese government plans to have the statues appraised by the auction house Christie’s, he noted.

Follow @jruss_jruss
Categories / Arts

Subscribe to Closing Arguments

Sign up for new weekly newsletter Closing Arguments to get the latest about ongoing trials, major litigation and hot cases and rulings in courthouses around the U.S. and the world.