MANHATTAN (CN) - A former Metro-North rail worker can keep the $118,000 awarded by a jury for hearing loss he sustained working for 29 years as a flagman on rail construction sites, a federal judge ruled.
At his trial, Ronald Folmsbee estimated that he heard a train horn being blown for around 15 seconds as trains passed close by, at least 200 times per day during portions of his seven years at a Stamford, Ct., station.
He told a jury that the noise caused him a temporary tingling sensation.
"If you [were] right next to the train and he blew the horn in your ear and that went on 200 times a day, five and six days a week, quite a few hours [were spent with tingling]," he testified, according to court documents.
Besides the train horns, Folmsbee said other assignments assaulted his eardrums in different ways.
For five years, he said he worked within 10 feet of a screeching, tunnel-digging, rock-cutting, giant saw, and then spent another five years working near booming diesel engines in a tunnel.
For up to three months, he stood less than 12 feet from a large, hydraulic drilling machine and 2 to 3 feet from jackhammers.
At this site, he said that he and his co-workers needed to use air horns to speak to each other.
Trying to dodge the award, Metro-North argued that it could not have foreseen how Folmsbee's job could have harmed his hearing.
U.S. Magistrate Judge George Yanthis shot down that appeal on Wednesday.
Subscribe to Closing Arguments
Sign up for new weekly newsletter Closing Arguments to get the latest about ongoing trials, major litigation and hot cases and rulings in courthouses around the U.S. and the world.