Judge orders ICE to improve conditions at Adelanto detention center

(CN) — A federal judge ordered U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement Thursday to drastically improve conditions at a privately owned detention center in the desert town of Adelanto, California.

U.S. District Judge Sunshine Sykes gave little in the way of reasoning behind the ruling in the eight-page order, except to say the detainees suing the government demonstrated their Fifth Amendment rights had likely been violated and that, without an injunction, “they will suffer irreparable harm.” The judge also cited “the public interest” as another reason for the ruling.

The injunction includes a veritable laundry list of immediate improvements needed at the Adelanto facility: Detainees must be provided with 24-hour access to clean potable drinking water, as well as “nutritious and sanitary meals” and “adequate sanitation.” The facility must now be cleaned daily; detainees must be given “clean, sanitary, and temperature-appropriate clothing … mattresses, pillows, and blankets.”

The government must also come up with a plan within 14 days to make further changes to the facility, including improved medical care and accommodations for those with disabilities. The court will appoint two independent monitors to make sure the changes are implemented at Adelanto.

“Today’s ruling affirms a fundamental principle: people do not lose their constitutional rights because they are detained,” said plaintiffs’ attorney Belinda Escobosa, the director of litigation at Public Counsel, in a written statement. “The court recognized that the conditions at Adelanto require immediate relief and this injunction is about ensuring that more than 1,500 people are treated with the dignity and humanity our Constitution requires.”

A Justice Department spokesperson declined to comment on the ruling.

Plaintiffs in the class action say in their complaint that the roughly 1,500 detainees at Adelanto face “dangerous conditions and pervasive abuses — disease and illness are rampant, mold grows on the walls, and detained individuals are denied sufficient food, clean drinking water, proper medical care, and disability accommodations.”

Sykes denied an earlier request for a preliminary injunction in April, largely on procedural grounds. At the hearing last week, Escobosa said the second motion was more modest and easier to enforce.

The government has argued the detention center’s failings are the fault of its operator, GEO Group, a publicly traded private prison company that operates the facility. On Thursday, Sykes appeared skeptical of that argument, asking a Justice Department attorney, “Once the government brings in a third party, then they can just wash their hands of constitutional violations?”

Pushkal Mishra, the government’s lawyer, insisted improvements had been made.

“The government has done far more to make sure that it has met its constitutional obligations,” he told the judge, but insisted, “the focus of redressability has to be GEO, the operator.”

Despite the injunction, the case remains active.

Follow @hillelaron