Updates to our Terms of Use

We are updating our Terms of Use. Please carefully review the updated Terms before proceeding to our website.

Tuesday, April 16, 2024 | Back issues
Courthouse News Service Courthouse News Service

In Bear Country Romania, Cohabitation Grows Strenuous

When Maria Lacatus' son opened the barn door, it was already too late. "The bear had one of the pigs in its claws," the sobbing 86-year-old says.

CUSMA, Romania (AFP) — When Maria Lacatus' son opened the barn door, it was already too late. "The bear had one of the pigs in its claws," the sobbing 86-year-old says.

After losing a horse too a few days later, Lacatus now agrees with many of her neighbors in the northern Romanian village of Cusma that hunting the protected species is the only answer.

The bear had fled through an opening it had made in some wooden planks, Lacatus says, unable to shake the vision of the animal she "almost bumped into".

She lives with her son, daughter-in-law — both take whatever daily work they can find — and their seven children in a house protected by a wooden fence opening onto a muddy yard.

The pigs are a vital source of income.

Romania has Europe's highest number of brown bears which have always been a common sight in Cusma, population about 600 and lying eight hours by road from the capital Bucharest.

But residents say that the bears didn't use to venture into farms to take animals -- around 15 cows and pigs have been killed by bears in the last two years, says deputy mayor Florin Griga. 

In other parts of the country, humans have been attacked. 

In October alone, a bear killed a 47-year-old who was picking mushrooms and a 61-year-old died due to an attack while fishing.

Thirty-two people were attacked, two of them fatally, in 2017 and 2018, according to government data.

Authorities have suggested that communities erect electric fences and use specialized dogs to keep bears away. 

But with very few exceptions, such as the central town of Baile Tusnad, the measures have not been carried out.

In response to calls from some in rural areas, senators voted in September to allow brown bears to be hunted over the next five years, citing a problem of overpopulation. 

The controversial bill, which still needs approval by deputies, has mobilised several associations into trying to get it blocked.

Some 100,000 people have signed an online petition by the World Wildlife Fund asking MPs to reject the bill.

EU member Romania also risks sanctions as the brown bear is among 1,200 species protected by the bloc's habitats directive.

'Maintain a balance'

"Man has always intervened to maintain a balance. Stopping this intervention results in the bear population getting out of hand," says senator Tanczos Barna, a supporter of the draft law.


Hunting bears in the nation of 20 million people, known for its large swaths of rural countryside with poor infrastructure, as well as forested mountains and hills, has periodically been permitted, including in the 1970s and again in the 1990s. 

Despite Romania joining the EU in 2007, hundreds of bears were killed for almost a decade under a system of waivers that stopped in 2016 due to a public outcry.

Since then, the environment ministry has allowed so-called nuisance bears to be killed — those that bother villagers — and recommends culling only as a last resort.

Some 140 bears were killed in 2017 but the tool is deemed inefficient and bureaucratic by hunters.

Romania is thought to have more than 6,000 brown bears spread across about 30 percent of the country and especially in the Carpathian mountains.

But environmentalists say the government doesn't even come close to knowing the actual number. 

"The methodology used by the authorities has not changed over the last few decades," said Viorel Popescu, assistant professor at Ohio University in the United States who wrote a study on the overestimation of Romania's bear population.

"It consists of counting tracks on snow or mud."

Csaba Domokos, a bear expert and researcher for nature preservation group Milvus, believes any hunting quota should be based on scientific studies.

"You can't do population control through hunting when you don't know the population," he said.

'Trophy hunting'

The encounters with bears in villages are not proof that the population is getting out of hand, insists Silviu Chiriac, of Large Carnivore Initiative for Europe, who has been studying Romania's wildlife for 20 years. 

"What has changed is that now everybody has a mobile phone with a camera and internet. 

"Anyone can take a picture of a bear track or of a specimen and post it on Facebook, giving the impression that Romania is besieged by animals," Chiriac told AFP.

Tourists feeding them, inappropriate refuse management, fields of crops extending near their habitat also affect the bears' behaviour, according to environmentalists.

Until 2016, hunting as a sport flourished, and bears were given "tons of apples, corn, concentrate (a mix of nutrients) and dead cows brought into the forest to habituate them for trophy hunting mostly," Popescu said, a claim disputed by hunters.

"Their space and ecology changed; the whole system changed (in 2016) when we stopped feeding them," he added.


Cusma village is close to Dealu Negru, a fairytale-like hill which used to be the hunting ground of former communist dictator Nicolae Ceausescu.

With their backyards going up into the forest, locals fear they are easy prey. Some say they are afraid to go out at night or let their children go to school in the daytime.

Twice in the last few months authorities used the national alert system to warn residents directly on their phones about a bear's presence near Cusma.

Domokos warns that villagers will ultimately take matters into their own hands and start poisoning the bears if the authorities do nothing.

"Either way, this won't end well for the bears," Domokos said. 


© Agence France-Presse


Categories / International

Subscribe to Closing Arguments

Sign up for new weekly newsletter Closing Arguments to get the latest about ongoing trials, major litigation and hot cases and rulings in courthouses around the U.S. and the world.