Updates to our Terms of Use

We are updating our Terms of Use. Please carefully review the updated Terms before proceeding to our website.

Tuesday, April 16, 2024 | Back issues
Courthouse News Service Courthouse News Service

Host of roving ministries challenges central Colorado city’s broad ban against RVs parking at churches overnight

Rev. Paul Elder sued the city of Pueblo after being cited with a zoning violation for hosting a traveling evangelist’s RV overnight.

PUEBLO, Colo. (CN) — The roving evangelist is an icon of the old west: an inspired man riding his horse between boomtowns, spreading the gospel as he experienced it. The practice still exists today, particularly in Pentecostal Christian circles, but instead of traveling by horseback, travelers have upgraded to RVs.

Though faster, safer and much homier than a horse, RVs are subject to local zoning restrictions.

In the middle of Interstate 25 in Pueblo, Colorado, Rev. Paul Elder has been hosting RV evangelists at the Christian Growth Center for nearly three decades. In 2011, the city signed off on the hookups he had installed to help travelers charge and dump water from their mobile homes.

Then Pueblo passed new restrictions limiting overnight RV parking to the city’s licensed RV parks. People staying the night elsewhere, whether in the Walmart parking lot, on the side of the road or at a church, face a fine of $1,000 per day and up to one year in jail.

The Pentecostal faith of Christianity places importance on individual experiences rather than relying on belief that is directly taught. The traditional revival centers around a believer who channels the "outpoured spirit of God” to the congregation.

Though spoofed on the silver screen in movies like Steve Martin’s “Leap of Faith,” traveling evangelism is as old as the Bible.

“Paul tells Timothy to do the work of an evangelist,” Elder said.

Before settling down at the Christian Growth Center in 1992, Elder had been a traveling evangelist for 15 years, starting while he was in high school.

“When they don't have the truck and the trailer, they have to travel alone,” Elder said. “It becomes a hardship for the family personally and it becomes a hardship, financially, for the church.”.

Elder asked and was denied a variance from the zoning board when first served notice of the violation. While his attorneys explained the biblical tradition of hosting evangelists at the church to the city government, Elder was served with a formal criminal complaint by the municipal court.

The criminal proceedings are stayed pending Elder’s civil lawsuit against the city, first filed in the Pueblo County District Court in January and removed to federal court in February.

Elder’s attorney sees the ban as a direct violation of the Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act of 2000, which protects churches from zoning discrimination.

“It's a really important aspect of the way they worship because they're welcoming these evangelists to preach revivals,” said Andrew Nussbaum, an attorney at Nussbaum Speir Gleason in Colorado Springs.

“It really is a continuation of the churches, historically in the American tradition, that would welcome traveling evangelists on horseback for tent revivals and things like that. It's just now that you have a bit more technology,” Nussbaum added.

Representatives from Pueblo declined to speak with Courthouse News, but the limitations on overnight camping are in line with other efforts nationwide designed to crack down on homeless camps.

The Christian Growth Center is one of hundreds of Christian institutions hosting ministers who call the road home.

“We’ve got a place the mail goes, but we don't have a home there. We literally live full-time in the RV year-round,” said preacher Jeremy Hart who has spent a decade on the road.

As a single man, Hart drove a Honda for several years, couch surfing between church guest quarters and pastors’ homes. Now married, Hart and his wife drive a 37-foot motorhome with a couch and a recliner they picked up in Elkhart, Indiana, home of the RV/MH Hall of Fame.

Today, the Harts average 150 church services every year, stopping only for a spell in March 2020. When Covid-19 shut down the world, the Harts parked in Texas for six weeks. They continued working and recording sermons but said it was a far cry from visiting communities and preaching in person.

ADVERTISEMENT

“It’s wonderful to have the opportunity of technology to be able to livestream or just post something on YouTube,” Hart said. “But however advantageous that may be, it certainly cannot replace the experience that you have by actually gathering together in a building and worshiping God together with others.”

The Harts camp at 95% of the churches they visit, otherwise hosting ministries find a place for them to stay. When they last visited Pueblo in 2019, they parked and preached right at the Christian Growth Center.

“That’s an incredible thing for Pastor Elder to be able to have his evangelists right there on location, and for them to work alongside each other,” Hart said.

In addition to the Pentecostal tradition of traveling revivalists, other Christian groups travel the U.S. performing concerts, seeking shelter during difficult times and even providing volunteer services.

“This is a way to serve God in your retirement years, to use the skills you've acquired over a lifetime to give back,” said Wayne Fieler of the couples RV ministry Servants on Wheels Ever Ready (SOWER). Fieler and his wife travel the country in a class A 40-foot RV, doing maintenance work, plumbing, cooking, electrical, carpentry and other odd jobs for religious camps and organizations.

Volunteers with SOWER only make trips to places that can accommodate RVs. Though it’s rare, Fieler recalled some projects being cut from the lineup because zoning laws prohibited overnight parking.

The Christian Growth Center isn’t rare in hosting mobile ministries, but Pueblo’s parking prohibition is less common, even in Pueblo, where other churches still host RVs.

“The RV hookup has been a great asset to the church. We don't use it 24/7. We don't use it every month, but when we do need it, we're thankful and grateful that it's there,” said Gordon Rogers, a pastor at the Rocky Mountain Baptist Church in Pueblo, 15 minutes south from the Christian Growth Center.

In addition to hosting missionaries and guest preachers in the parking lot, Rogers’ church occasionally shelters snowbirds passing through town.

“I feel personally the city of Pueblo has got their priorities skewed,” Rogers said. “We've got homeless encampments all around the city, and you would think they'd go after that. There’s weeds up around your neck in places, but for them to go after a church and a pastor with a building that’s nice and clean because they got an RV, I think that’s counterproductive.”

In court documents, Elder recalls City Attorney Trevor Gloss failing to list specific concerns about “public health, safety, sanitation or crime” while supporting enforcement of the zoning rule against the church.

Without free church-front parking, traveling ministers can park at one of a dozen local RV parks or campgrounds for $85 a night when there are openings. Since travelers make about $100 a night preaching, they usually expect the hosting church to cover boarding costs.

Even with this small workaround keeping travelers coming through, Elder is willing to fight to protect his parking lot’s religious rights.

“I made it very clear that this is not just people parking here, and we're not charging them money,” Elder said. “They want to tell us that that's not a ministry, to tell us that they have the power to define how we can minister which is a clear violation of the rules.”

Both Elder and the city of Pueblo have requested a jury trial to settle the matter. It is not clear when one will be scheduled or seated.

Follow @bright_lamp
Categories / Courts, Law, Religion

Subscribe to Closing Arguments

Sign up for new weekly newsletter Closing Arguments to get the latest about ongoing trials, major litigation and hot cases and rulings in courthouses around the U.S. and the world.

Loading...