Updates to our Terms of Use

We are updating our Terms of Use. Please carefully review the updated Terms before proceeding to our website.

Wednesday, July 24, 2024 | Back issues
Courthouse News Service Courthouse News Service

French Schools Reopen in Mourning After Beheading Of Teacher

French schools held a nationwide minute of silence Monday in tribute to a teacher who was beheaded for opening a class debate on free speech by showing students caricatures of the prophet of Islam.

PARIS (AP) — French schools held a nationwide minute of silence Monday in tribute to a teacher who was beheaded for opening a class debate on free speech by showing students caricatures of the prophet of Islam.

Samuel Paty was killed on Oct. 16 outside his school in suburban Paris by an 18-year-old refugee  of Chechen origin to punish him for showing the caricatures published by the satirical newspaper Charlie Hebdo, which triggered a newsroom massacre by extremists in January 2015.

Since their republication in September at the start of the ongoing Paris trial over the killings, France has endured three attacks blamed on Muslim extremists: one by a Pakistani refugee that injured two people outside the newspaper's old headquarters, the slaying of the schoolteacher, and a deadly knife attack last Thursday in a church in the Mediterranean city of Nice. France's anti-terrorism prosecutor has opened investigations into all three, and France is now at its highest level of alert.

French government officials defend the decision to publish the caricatures, which they say fall squarely into two of France's most cherished rights: freedom of expression and secularism.

"Samuel Paty taught each child of the Republic to become a free citizen. For him, for our country, we will continue. It is our honor and our duty," French Prime Minister Jean Castex wrote in a tweet.

French President Emmanuel Macron has promised to increase protection of schools and churches immediately after the Nice attack, more than doubling the number of soldiers actively deployed in the country. Paty was killed at the beginning of a two-week French school holiday.

On Monday, the middle school where he taught at Conflans-Saint-Honorine reopened for teachers only. Castex spoke with elementary school students in the town, discussing citizenship and rights before leading them in the national anthem. Other schools throughout the country resumed as usual to both students and teachers.

At schools throughout the country, students listened to readings of the letter of Jean Jaurès, a 19th century French thinker and politician, to instructors urging them to teach the country's children to "know France, its geography and its history, its body and its soul."

The cartoons were originally published in Denmark in 2005 and elsewhere later in countries where freedom of expression is considered inviolable. Many Muslims see them as sacrilegious and protests against France have spread in many countries.

"We have the right to believe that these caricatures are in bad taste. There are plenty of people I believe are in bad taste. There are plenty of people who I think say idiotic things," Gerald Darmanin, France's interior minister, told BFM television. "But I'll defend to the death your right to say them, as Voltaire said."

In Germany and the Netherlands, many schools were also paying tribute to Paty.

"We can send a sign of solidarity with those teachers who are committed to democratic coexistence," state Education Minister Sandra Sheeres wrote in a message to Berlin schools asking them to participate.

Scheeres also asked those participating to explain the background to their students to make them aware of "tolerance and solidarity as well as against violence and extremism."

The Dutch education ministers asked schools, colleges and universities to find ways to express their support.

"The Netherlands stands squarely behind teachers and the constitutional freedom of expression," ministers Arie Slob and Ingrid van Engelshoven wrote. "Teachers must be able to do their work in freedom and security so our children and youth can develop into independent citizens who can live together in a country that is characterized by freedom, equality and solidarity."

By LORI HINNANT Associated Press
David Rising in Berlin and Mike Corder in The Hague contributed.

Categories / Civil Rights, Education, International, Media, Politics

Subscribe to Closing Arguments

Sign up for new weekly newsletter Closing Arguments to get the latest about ongoing trials, major litigation and hot cases and rulings in courthouses around the U.S. and the world.