ON BOARD THE SAM SIMON, France (AFP) — Three knocks on the cabin door: "Half past midnight!"
It's time for the team from Sea Shepherd, a group dedicated to protecting the world's marine life, to start their nightly patrol.
Six volunteers set out in a semi-rigid boat to monitor and film the operations of a nearby fishing fleet.
They already know that increasing numbers of dead dolphins are washing up on France's Atlantic beaches.
Their mission is to document the damage these vessels are doing to the local dolphin population.
Since December 22, Sea Shepherd's Sam Simon, a converted meteorological observation vessel, has been the base for these nightly patrols in the Bay of Biscay off the southwest coast of France.
The volunteers can spend hours waiting as the trawlers winch up their enormous nets.
But their presence is not welcome.
"Bunch of scavengers!" shouts one crew member from a trawler just a few yards away.
Although the trawlers are fishing for sea bass, Sea Shepherd wants to record whether dolphins — or other cetaceans — have also been caught in their nets.
Earlier in their campaign, they posted a video of two dolphins being hauled aboard a fishing trawler: one had apparently already drowned, but the other, still alive, was struggling to escape the netting.
Dying in record numbers
Operation Dolphin By-Catch aims to warn the public about the issue — and pressure the authorities to take action.
They argue that industrial trawling is devastating the local dolphin population, with hundreds washing up dead on the west coast of France every year.
"The problem has been going on for 30 years, but there is a kind of omerta," says Lamya Essemlali, President of Sea Shepherd France.
And according to the experts, the numbers are rising.
"2019 was the year of all the records," says marine biologist Helene Peltier of the University of La Rochelle on France's west coast.
Between January and April, when the toll is highest, 1,200 small cetaceans washed up dead on the beaches of France's west coast -- 880 of them common dolphins.
Of those they autopsied, 80% showed signs of collisions with fishing boats: cuts, broken teeth, battered heads, asphyxia.
And because most dead dolphins sink or are carried off to sea, they estimate that in all, 11,300 dolphins died in 2019.
"The fishermen go to the zones where there are fish — the dolphins too," says Yves Le Gall, head of the acoustic service at Ifremer, the French oceanographic research institute.
The threat from trawling
A 2016 report by University of La Rochelle's Pelagic Institute warned that fishing threatens the dolphin population in the Bay of Biscay, estimated at 200,000.
Peltier says that human activity is already killing more than 1.75 of the population — the endangerment threshold.
"The animals that are killed accidentally are in good health," she noted.
In the first decade of the century, scientists and fishermen collaborated to develop acoustic devices known as "pingers" to warn off dolphins.
Although they succeeded in reducing the accidental captures, the pingers were not widely adopted.
The 2016 Pelagic Institute report appears to have prompted a greater sense of urgency.
"A real dynamic developed, with concrete actions" that galvanized fishermen, says Thomas Rimaud of Pecheurs de Bretagne (Brittany Fishermen).
"It's no fun for fishermen, capturing dolphins," says Hubert Carre, head of the National Committee for Maritime Fishing (CNPMEM).
Most recently, the fishing ministry has been pushing to have all trawlers in the Bay of Biscay fitted with the pinger devices. France is in talks with the European Union to ensure that all boats, not just French ones, must comply.
And the main trawler fleet, responsible for four percent of accidental captures of dolphins, has agreed to accept observers on board.
Ifremer meanwhile is working on more effective pinger devices and reflective equipment to make the massive nets more visible to dolphins.
But for Sea Shepherd, technological fixes only go so far.
They want a complete ban on all indiscriminate methods of fishing, such as trawling — they have already called for a consumer boycott.
"Impossible," given the economic importance of the French fishing industry, says Carre at CNPMEM.
Dominique Chevillon of the less radical group France Nature Environment suggests a middle way: periodic suspensions on fishing certain kinds of fish in certain waters.
The authorities have banned the more damaging methods of trawling off some parts of the coast. But there are other boats fishing these waters, and it is difficult to tell how much damage they are doing, Peltier says.
© Agence France-Presse
by Laure FILLON
Subscribe to Closing Arguments
Sign up for new weekly newsletter Closing Arguments to get the latest about ongoing trials, major litigation and hot cases and rulings in courthouses around the U.S. and the world.