(CN) — Europe, home to many of world's richest and most technologically advanced nations, has become a crucial battleground in the race between China and the United States and among tech giants to develop the internet of the future — a world where technology becomes even more supreme and potentially more dangerous.
This is a world of driverless cars, where robots harvest crops and doctors conduct remote-controlled surgeries. It's also a world where hackers may sow even more chaos, intelligence agencies and companies may collect even greater oceans of data on people and militaries might unleash crippling cyberattacks.
It’s the “internet of things,” or as some call it, the “fourth industrial revolution.” At its core is the rollout of tens of thousands of new antennae, transmitters and technology kits needed to create a faster, more granular and more complex internet known as 5G — an industry name for a fifth generation, or evolution, in wireless telecommunications.
The big question for Europe is Huawei, a Chinese tech giant that is a leader in 5G technology, and linked to the Chinese Communist Party and allegedly China's intelligence agencies.
By using Huawei's 5G technology, some experts warn, a country is at risk of allowing the Chinese government to have access to — and potentially even control over — its internet network and leave it exposed to crippling cyberattacks, industrial espionage and massive surveillance.
The debate over 5G is a conundrum forcing the European Union to face many of its most pressing domestic and foreign policy and business problems all at once: How to balance the EU between China and the United States, encourage free trade but also stand up to China's practice of subsidizing companies like Huawei, figure out how to build up its own independence and sovereignty while not enraging far-superior superpowers, and needing 5G technology to bolster their economies while protecting themselves from cyberwarfare and ensure its citizens’ human rights and data are protected.
“There are so many dimensions to this debate,” said Jan-Peter Kleinhans, an expert on 5G at Stiftung Neue Verantwortung, a German think tank, in a telephone interview.
It's a risky, high-wire balancing act for Europe.
Last year the United States told Europeans to ban Huawei from their 5G networks to safeguard intelligence sharing and national security. President Trump has shut Huawei largely out of the U.S. market, alleging the company is an extension of the Chinese government. The company is privately run by its founder, Ren Zhengfei, but he has ties to the Chinese military and Communist party. Also, about 99% of Huawei is owned by its workers through a trade union subordinate to the Communist Party. Still, the United States has provided little or no evidence to back up its claims that Huawei is in cahoots with Chinese spy networks.
Banning Huawei would bring with it technical and geopolitical risks for Europe.
On the technical side, Europe is already committed to Huawei, a company that's become ever more involved in Europe since it arrived in 2000 and set up a research laboratory in Stockholm. Eliminating it from the burgeoning 5G network would be difficult and expensive.
Huawei's footprint is easy to see in Europe. Walk into a cellphone store in Italy, Spain or Germany and you are greeted with a range of Huawei smartphones for sale. They've got top-of-the-line processors, high-quality cameras and lots of internal memory.