Updates to our Terms of Use

We are updating our Terms of Use. Please carefully review the updated Terms before proceeding to our website.

Wednesday, July 17, 2024 | Back issues
Courthouse News Service Courthouse News Service

Dysfunctional Israeli Government Faces Third Election in a Year

Israelis grappled Thursday with the reality of unprecedented third national elections in less than a year, after Parliament was dissolved and the date for the next vote was set — extending months of political paralysis.

JERUSALEM (AP) — Israelis grappled Thursday with the reality of unprecedented third national elections in less than a year, after Parliament was dissolved and the date for the next vote was set — extending months of political paralysis.

Legislators passed a motion to hold elections on March 2, hours after the deadline to form a coalition government expired. The motion passed by a 94-0 vote in the house.

That triggers a nearly three-month-long campaign that most polls predict will not produce dramatically different results than those that led to the logjam.

"This nightmare, in which we're heading into elections once again, the third within the space of a single year, is neither a parable nor a dream. It is completely real," wrote Sima Kadmon in the leading Yediot Ahronot daily. "There aren't words left that can express the public's disgust with and mistrust toward its elected representatives.”

As in each previous round, the largest parties, Likud and Blue and White, blamed each other for the impasse and tried to set the narrative for what is likely to be a grueling and caustic campaign.

"The politicians were unable to decide and so it goes back to the people. And it's a shame. There weren't big differences," Foreign Minister Israel Katz, a Likud lawmaker, told Israeli Army Radio.

Israel has been mired in political deadlock for months, after two inconclusive elections and failed attempts by Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and his chief rival, former army chief Benny Gantz, to cobble together coalition governments.

The costly election campaigns, government work on indefinite hold and the obstinacy of both sides has frustrated Israelis, who are used to fractious politics but have never seen repeat elections.

"It's very disappointing. Terrible, in my opinion. It's also a waste of resources and energy. The public is tired of it and I think there's anger at all sides that can't reach any kind of agreement," said Malka Miller, walking along Tel Aviv's beachside boardwalk.

During government negotiations, both sides professed eagerness to reach a power-sharing agreement, but could not agree on its composition nor who would lead it. Netanyahu insisted on serving as prime minister, where he is best positioned to fight his recent indictment on a series of corruption charges. Gantz has refused to serve under a prime minister with such serious legal problems and called on Likud to choose a different leader.

Likud has seen a burgeoning insurrection by lawmaker Gideon Saar, who says the party needs a new leader because Netanyahu has been unable to form a government. Primaries are set for later this month, but fewer than a handful of Likud legislators have fallen behind Saar and Netanyahu is expected to be returned to party leadership, despite the political disarray and his legal woes.

Netanyahu faces charges of bribery, fraud and breach of trust in three corruption cases in which he is accused of trading legislative or regulatory favors in exchange for lavish gifts or favorable media coverage.

Among the charges are that he told mainline newspapers that if they reduced criticism of him in news and opinion pieces, he would limit the distribution of the free, right-wing newspaper owned by U.S. casino magnate Sheldon Adelson, a strong backer of Netanyahu.

Netanyahu denies wrongdoing.

Netanyahu had hoped for a clear victory in April's elections: a majority that would grant him immunity from prosecution. He can now hope that the next election delivers him a more favorable result. Netanyahu's trial is on hold until the immunity issue is resolved, a process that is expected to take months.

After the March election, he could use coalition negotiations as leverage to push potential partners to support his immunity request.

Under Israeli law, a sitting prime minister charged with a crime is not required to step down. But other top ministers under indictment must resign, and Netanyahu, who holds four portfolios, including health, agriculture and welfare, notified Israel's Supreme Court on Thursday that he would give up each ministry by the New Year.

The letter to the court, which was responding to a petition by a good governance group, said that Netanyahu would continue serving as prime minister.

Netanyahu's opponents say he cannot guide the country through its myriad challenges while fighting his legal battles.

"The suicidal tailspin on the political system this past year originated with one person: Benjamin Netanyahu," columnist Yossi Verter wrote in the liberal Haaretz.

"This election campaign, like its two predecessors in April and September, is the result of his ongoing escape from a trial that is likely to end in prison," Verter wrote.

Categories / International, Politics

Subscribe to Closing Arguments

Sign up for new weekly newsletter Closing Arguments to get the latest about ongoing trials, major litigation and hot cases and rulings in courthouses around the U.S. and the world.