Updates to our Terms of Use

We are updating our Terms of Use. Please carefully review the updated Terms before proceeding to our website.

Friday, August 30, 2024 | Back issues
Courthouse News Service Courthouse News Service

Drawn to drama: The life and times of a courtroom sketch artist

Retired courtroom artist Art Lien captured memorable court cases for 45 years, including the trials of Oklahoma City bomber Timothy McVeigh and the Boston Marathon bomber, and the impeachment hearings of then-President Donald Trump.

(CN) — When a county clerk faced a judge in 2015 for failing to issue marriage licenses to same-sex couples, courtroom sketch artist Art Lien traveled from his home in Maryland to Ashland, Kentucky, so he could document the case.

Arriving early for Kim Davis’s contempt hearing, Lien sketched scenes both inside and outside of the courthouse.

“People were praying on the steps outside. I sketched that,” Lien recalled. “She got on the stand, and she testified. They led her out of the courtroom in handcuffs. I got that.”

Lien turned in several detailed sketches from the event. But when the hearing aired as the lead story on NBC Nightly News, not a single Lien sketch appeared.

“That helped move me toward retirement, for sure,” he said, half jokingly.

Lien was one of a handful of artists who made a living sketching court dramas. While Lien’s long career would face increasing competition from still photos and video, when he retired in 2022, the craft was on the cusp of a major comeback with the Donald Trump court hearings.

Art Lien's depiction of Supreme Court justices Ruth Bader Ginsburg and Samuel Alito. Lien captured numerous Supreme Court proceedings during his career as a courtroom sketch artist. (Courtesy Art Lien via Courthouse News)

The former president has been the subject of numerous court filings, both civil and criminal, since leaving office. And since cameras have been largely limited or outright prohibited in those high-profile cases, even longtime courtroom sketch artists have experienced newfound exposure for their work.

“I’ve gotten more comments, both negative and positive, about my pictures than I’ve ever had before,” said Elizabeth Williams, a courtroom artist whose work on the Trump cases came decades after she chronicled the Hillside Stranglers court proceedings in 1980.

While Lien doesn’t regret missing out on the Trump cases, he does admit to having trouble adjusting to retirement after a 45-year career.

Trump attorney William S. Consovoy arguing before judge Amit Mehta in Trump v. House Oversight Committee. (Courtesy Art Lien via Courthouse News)

“I’m a little lost,” he said. “When I first retired, I didn’t want to do anything.”

After graduating from the Maryland Institute College of Art in 1976, Lien worked several manual labor jobs to make money.

“After I graduated, I was worried,” he said. “I was getting crappy jobs: house painting, tarring roofs and lying sod — stuff like that.”

So when a local TV station offered him an opportunity to sketch a racketeering trial of former Maryland Governor Marvin Mandel, Lien seized the opportunity to put his artistic training to work — albeit in an unfamiliar setting.

“The courtroom was a completely new thing to me,” he said. “The first time I went into the courtroom, everything was so far away.”

While that first job didn’t work out — “I got fired the first day” — he eventually was hired by numerous news outlets, including CBS, NBC and SCOTUSblog. Many of the cases he sketched included highly publicized ones, including the trials of Oklahoma City bomber Tim McVeigh, the D.C. sniper killers, and the Boston Marathon bomber. Lien also chronicled the U.S. Supreme Court and the Trump Senate impeachment hearings.

While his medium changed over the years, one thing was constant: His output.

Art Lien captured Oklahoma City bomber Tim McVeigh during his 1997 trial. (Courtesy Art Lien via Courthouse News)

“He draws incredibly fast,” said Williams, co-author of the book “The Illustrated Courtroom: 50 Years of Court Art,” which both explains the craft and offers a look at some of the nation’s most famous court cases. “He’s like lightning on paper.”

That speed allowed him to tell a story with several drawings from a long day of court testimony or to quickly capture the scene of a very brief hearing.

“Sometimes an arraignment might take five minutes,” he said.

Throughout his career, Lien has used pastels and markers, colored pencils and, more recently, graphite pencils with watercolors. His courtroom sketches were always a blend of art and journalism.

Many more contemporary courtroom artists, particularly on the East Coast, Williams said, create interpretations of scenes, whereas she favors the journalistic approach of drawing the action as it appeared.

ADVERTISEMENT

“If somebody is putting a defendant right up next to a witness or putting a jury jammed up next to a judge, that’s not how courtrooms work,” she said.

Lien’s work, she added, was a more accurate picture of the courtroom environment.

“There’s an authenticity to his work that doesn’t always exist with others,” she said. “It’s really informing the public.”

Getting it right isn’t always easy, Lien said. Sometimes courtroom sketch artists have bad seats with obstructed views. Other times it can be challenging to capture the essence of a subject.

Lien found Supreme Court Justice Sandra Day O’Connor and Senator Orrin Hatch difficult to capture because they lacked distinguishing characteristics.

A view of the Senate chamber on day one of the Trump impeachment trial. (Courtesy Art Lien via Courthouse News)

“Other people had trouble with Justice (Anthony) Kennedy,” he said. “One of my colleagues described him and was quoted in a newspaper article as saying he had a vanilla face.”

“I think the shape of his head was easy for me,” Lien added. “It was kind of football shaped.”

While a prominent feature — say, a large nose or bushy eyebrows — might make a subject easier to capture, Lien said body language can also define a subject’s look.

“In art school, we had an exercise where we had to do portraits without putting in any facial features,” he said. “And that was pretty revealing.”

Many attorneys who argued before the Supreme Court proudly display Lien watercolors on their wall. Occasionally, a subject would have special requests for the artist.

“They’re always coming up to you asking if you can give them a little more hair or do this or that,” said Lien, who drew some commissioned works until he eventually became annoyed with the requests.

Drawing with graphite pencils in court and adding watercolor later allowed him to erase and revise if something visually interesting compelled him to change direction.

Courtroom artists always have to be ready to capture a key moment.

Famously, during Charles Manson’s 1970 murder trial, the defendant leaped over the defense table and lunged toward the judge as a quick-to-react bailiff rushed to restrain Manson mid-air.

Courtroom sketch artist Bill Robles captured that tense scene with an iconic image, which is featured in Williams’ book.

“That happened in an instant,” Wiliams said. “They never expected it.”

While Robles could have easily drawn an interpretation of the dramatic moment, instead he drew what he saw from his seat behind the defense table.

Bruce Rogow delivers opening statement for defense in Roger Stone trial. Rogow later purchased Lien art for his own posterity. (Courtesy Art Lien via Courthouse News)

“You’re not creating a pretty picture,” Williams said. “You’re creating a visual representation of the scene that’s in front of you. If you want to create a pretty picture, go do that in your studio.”

While Williams has always drawn pretty pictures outside of court — including rock concerts and weddings — Lien seldom drew anything else besides legal proceedings during his career.

“I think the work kind of ruined it for me,” he said. “It was a grind. It was not something I particularly wanted to do on my time off.”

When he retired, scores legal and news professionals offered tributes to his work on the SCOTUSblog.

“He was an expert in a demanding and highly specialized art form, and he was liked and respected by his peers and the lawyers and judges he covered,” wrote Pete Williams, a former Supreme Court correspondent for NBC News. “He was, quite simply, the absolute best.”

While longtime courtroom sketchers, including Elizabeth Williams, Bill Robles and Jane Rosenberg continue to chronicle the courts, Lien retired after the pandemic, no longer wanting to commute to Washington. Lien has some fun watercolor projects in mind but acknowledges it’s more difficult to be motivated without the tight deadlines.

“I’m not terribly disciplined,” he said. “I don’t think I’m capable of working on stuff for a long time.”

Categories / Arts, Courts

Subscribe to Closing Arguments

Sign up for new weekly newsletter Closing Arguments to get the latest about ongoing trials, major litigation and hot cases and rulings in courthouses around the U.S. and the world.

Loading...