Court asked to enforce $3M deal in police shooting lawsuit

VIRGINIA BEACH, Va. (AP) — Several parties to a wrongful death lawsuit over the fatal police shooting of a Black man on the Virginia Beach oceanfront last year have asked a judge to enforce the $3 million settlement agreement announced earlier this month.

The city of Virginia Beach and the family of Donovon Lynch — a cousin of musician and Virginia Beach native Pharrell Williams — announced the settlement agreement on Dec. 13. But Lynch's father, Wayne Lynch, has since told local news outlets that he's parted ways with his attorneys and that the settlement isn't finalized.

Last week, several parties to the matter filed a joint motion asking a judge to enforce the announced deal.

The joint motion was filed by Thomas Martin and Justin Fairfax, who have served as attorneys for Wayne Lynch, as well as attorneys for the city and the officer who shot Donovon Lynch.

The motion says that an outside party advised Wayne Lynch not to sign the agreement, “which is against the interests of the Estate and contrary to Plaintiff’s prior agreement."

Court records show that the motion was referred to a judge on Tuesday.

Efforts by The Associated Press to reach Wayne Lynch weren't immediately successful. But Lynch wrote in an emailed statement on Tuesday that the settlement had not been finalized, TV station WVEC-TV reported.

“I regret that it was publicly disclosed before all non-monetary terms were finalized,” Lynch’s statement said.

He also wrote that Fairfax, a former lieutenant governor, and Martin were no longer representing him.

Lauren Burke, a spokesperson for Fairfax, disputed that, saying in a statement provided to the AP Wednesday that Fairfax and Martin remain “the attorneys of record in this case.”

“Justin E. Fairfax and Thomas B. Martin have been honored to secure a $3M settlement in the death of Wayne Lynch's son Donovon Lynch,” the statement said. “This historic settlement for the Lynch family will soon be completely settled in Virginia federal court.”

A spokesperson for the city declined to comment.

Wayne Lynch filed the $50 million wrongful death lawsuit in June 2021 against the city and Solomon D. Simmons, the police officer who shot his son. Simmons is also Black.

Lynch’s shooting occurred on a warm March night near the city’s crowded boardwalk, which is lined with restaurants and hotels. The evening dissolved into chaos after separate outbreaks of gunfire. At least eight people were wounded and one woman, who was believed to be a bystander, was killed.

In November 2021, a special grand jury found that Simmons was justified in shooting Lynch. Authorities said Lynch had a gun and racked a round into the chamber before pointing his weapon toward a parking lot filled with people and police.

Subscribe to Closing Arguments

Sign up for new weekly newsletter Closing Arguments to get the latest about ongoing trials, major litigation and hot cases and rulings in courthouses around the U.S. and the world.

Email *

Submit