Updates to our Terms of Use

We are updating our Terms of Use. Please carefully review the updated Terms before proceeding to our website.

Monday, April 15, 2024 | Back issues
Courthouse News Service Courthouse News Service

Burning olive trees becomes new reality in southern Italy

For miles and miles, the olive groves of Italy's Salento region are eerily void of any green or life – they are inert places where the olive harvest has been killed by a dangerous plant illness. Now arsonists are setting fire to the region's dead trees.

TREPUZZI, Italy (CN) — The catastrophic Xylella fastidiosa olive tree epidemic just keeps getting worse for the ancient olive oil makers of Italy's Salento region.

A new chapter in this tragedy has struck: Fires, many of them likely set by arsonists, are destroying what remains of thousands of olive trees mortally infected by an olive tree strain of the Xylella fastidiosa, a dangerous bacterium native to Central America and threatening hundreds of species of plants around the world.

This is the second summer in a row where Xylella-infected olive trees are going up in flames in Salento, adding a dramatic and even hellish twist to a disaster that was already nearly incomprehensible for the people here.

Salvatore Mongiò, an olive mill owner and grower in Trepuzzi, is nearly the only person left in his town who makes olive oil. With a shake of his head, he said the fires are awful.

“We've moved on to the phase of destruction," he said.

The mass death of olives is deeply emotional and complicated for this part of Italy because the southern Apulia region historically was Italy's most productive olive oil region. Olive oil is central to life, as it was for the Greeks, Phoenicians and Byzantines who planted olives centuries ago in Salento, an Apulia sub-peninsula of the Italian peninsula and often referred to as the “heel” of the “boot.”

Mongiò drove slowly through the charred olive groves in the vicinity of Trepuzzi.

“Look here, this burned a couple of days ago,” he said, nodding at blackened carcasses of olive trees on the edge of town.

Ghostly groves extended for as far as the eye could see. He drove on ponderously.

“These trees were beautiful three years ago,” he said, passing a grove of leafless centuries-old trees, all of them dead or dying though spared still from fires. “They were vigorous, green, with foliage.”

An olive tree burns near Trepuzzi, a town in the Italian region of Apulia devastated by a lethal olive tree disease. (Photo by Salvatore Mongiò via Courthouse News)

This “phase of destruction,” as Mongiò calls the pyromania taking place all around him, is painful.

“Not almost, every day there have been fires,” he said. “It's vandalism, let's be clear. This should not be happening to the countryside.”

Systematic fires became a feature of the Xylella disaster last summer, but this year the pace of fires has picked up and local newspapers seem to be unable to keep up with all the reports of burning olives.

Few if any people have been arrested, according to news reports. Officials with Apulia's regional government did not immediately return messages seeking comment about the fires.

Donato Boscia, a plant and Xylella researcher with the National Research Council of Italy, said most of the fires are lit by people.

“There are only a few cases of so-called 'auto-combustion,'” Boscia said in a telephone interview. “A fire erupts because someone has lit a match somewhere.”

It's a cruel sight to see the blackened groves around Trepuzzi, one of several areas in the provinces of Lecce and Brindisi hit hard by arsonists. Burnt trunks are toppled over on ground, split in two, three and four pieces.  

Mongiò said people evidently see burning trees as an effective way to clear the land of Xylella-infected trees.

“When an olive tree catches on fire, it burns from the inside for days,” he said. “I saw some old trees catch on fire and the firemen doused the trees from morning to evening. The next day, the tree was still burning.”

Removing the millions of dead olive trees in Salento has proven problematic and costly. Most farmers have left their Xylella-hit trees standing right where they are, some waiting for the state to pay for their removal, others hoping their trees will miraculously come back to life. Trees are also extirpated by companies that use the wood in biomass-burning energy plants. Other firms remove trees to sell as firewood.

ADVERTISEMENT

The spread of fires may be tied to a longer-term plan that allows farmers to replant their dead groves with Xylella-resistant olive trees and other crops, such as oranges. In recent months, tens of millions of dollars have begun flowing as relief for farmers struck down by Xylella.

Xylella fastidiosa is a bacterium native to Central America and it has dangerously spread in many parts of the world. Different Xylella strains are attacking grapes and almond trees in California, citrus in Brazil and olive and almond trees in Europe. It's believed the bacterium has spread through the global trade in exotic plants.

A dead olive grove near Trepuzzi, Italy, where a farmer has left the trunks of Xylella-killed trees and removed the upper branches for firewood. (Courthouse News photo/Cain Burdeau)

Boscia said more than 500 different types of plants may be susceptible to infection from Xylella. For example, he said in Apulia the bacterium has destroyed nearly all the polygala myrtifolia, an evergreen ornamental shrub found in many vacation villas.

In 2013, scientists first pinpointed a Xylella subspecies as the cause of a new sickness turning olive trees around the town of Gallipolli brown. Gallipolli is a former port town on the Ionian Sea where huge amounts of olive oil were shipped to northern Europe for use as lamp oil and in the kitchen.

Today, Gallipolli and its picturesque rocky bays are one of Europe's most cherished holiday destinations and its countryside is dotted with lush villas. The town's modern transformation into a tourist hub likely led to the introduction of Xylella in Salento. Scientists believe the bacterium got to Gallipolli with the widespread planting of exotic species to embellish vacation homes.

By the time Boscia and other scientists figured out that olive trees were infected with Xylella, some 8,000 hectares around Gallipolli were sick. Today, nearly eight years later, he said about 800,000 hectares are afflicted.

“It's multiplied almost 100 times,” Boscia said.

Indeed, the countryside of Salento, once the land of olives, is today a ghostly place littered with gnarled dead olive trees, haunting skeletons of their former selves. The daily fires only make this spectral landscape that much more unreal and spooky.

Back in town, Mongiò made his way to a now-shuttered modern olive mill, or “frantoio” in Italian, that his family ran for many years in Trepuzzi's industrial zone. But with all the olive trees dead, the family simply had no other option: Hardly anyone makes olive oil anymore in Trepuzzi and they closed the mill.

“Look how huge our frantoio was,” he said, standing outside the closed mill.

In September, his family sold off the big machines inside the mill used for making oil. The big frantoio building was bought by a neighboring firm that does work for ILVA, a massive state-run steel mill in the city of Taranto. Mongiò and his wife now live in what was the office building for the frantoio.

Mongiò and his brother then moved their olive business back into an old smaller mill their father built in Trepuzzi.

He is in the midst of radical changes to his native land.

Outside a large Italian olive oil mill he and his family were forced to close due to the Xylella fastidiosa disaster, Salvatore Mongiò points in the direction where the big modern mill was housed, processing about 100,000 quintals of olives a year. (Courthouse News photo/Cain Burdeau)

Already, some farmers have removed their dead groves and planted new trees. In other places, big agricultural interests are trying to buy up smaller plots and plant large-scale super-intensive groves with Xylella-resistant stocks, similar to the mechanized and lucrative olive harvest in Spain.

But Salento is prized land for other activities too and many groves may simply disappear. Investors are looking at Salento as ideal for big solar panel and wind mill parks. The tourism industry too is eyeing abandoned farmland for golf courses and resorts.

The fires make Mongiò suspicious about what's going on.

“There are higher interests behind these fires,” he said. “These interests want the countryside to be deserted to then be able to acquire gli appezzamenti [smaller land lots] at, let's just say, moderate prices.”

Despite all the tragedy, Mongiò isn't leaving the olive oil business. He said he's even feeling upbeat.

His family is among those more fortunate because about 60% of their 10,000 olive trees were of local varieties that have been able to hold out against Xylella and continue to produce fruit. With that harvest in hand, they can still sell oil.

Still, he plans to extirpate all 10,000 trees they have and replant them with varieties known to be completely resistant to Xylella, including one that is a lab-invented hybrid called “la favolosa.”

“In three years, these new trees will be producing,” he said. “But you know what the problem with these new trees is? In 20, 30 years you have to remove them.”

A newly planted Xylella-resistant grove of olives in Trepuzzi, Italy, lies next to an old grove of killed by Xylella. (Courthouse News photo/Cain Burdeau)

It's the start of a long process of renewal for him and one that may be repeated across the Mediterranean in the decades to come as Xylella continues its slow march north in Italy. The bacterium has reached the province of Bari, about 70 miles north of Gallipolli.

Its progress, though, appears to have slowed, giving rise to hope that it may not spread as fast as first feared.

“The diffusion continues; it's slow, but continues,” Boscia said. He credited better land management, improved monitoring for the bacterium and quicker responses to outbreaks as reasons for the slower pace of infection.

There is no known cure for Xylella, but biologists have shown success at treating infected trees. Boscia, though, called these treatments “palliatives.” Treatments are costly and only slow a tree's decline.

“The fact that it is spreading slowly should not let anyone feel safe,” Boscia said.

Mongiò is pessimistic that Xylella can be stopped. His plight, he fears, will become the plight of olive farmers around the Mediterranean.

“It's not only going toward northern Italy, Xylella will go beyond, around the Adriatic, it will hit Albania, Greece. It will hit the entire Mediterranean basin. You can't stop it.”

When he speaks with farmers from elsewhere, they can't believe they will ever get hit. But he heard the same thing from farmers in Salento.

“Until it hits you personally,” he said, “even if you have a neighbor with it, you say: 'Well, he has it, but I don't.'”

“It's slowly climbing,” he added, “and it will eventually change the countryside. Everything will change.”

Courthouse News reporter Cain Burdeau is based in the European Union.

Follow Cain Burdeau on Twitter

Follow @cainburdeau
Categories / Environment, International

Subscribe to Closing Arguments

Sign up for new weekly newsletter Closing Arguments to get the latest about ongoing trials, major litigation and hot cases and rulings in courthouses around the U.S. and the world.

Loading...