DENVER (CN) - Attorneys for the man accused of the Aurora movie massacre want Colorado's capital punishment laws declared unconstitutional.
In a series of motions Tuesday, attorneys for James Holmes asked that the state's death penalty be declared arbitrary and capricious, cruel and unusual, and in violation of constitutional standards set by the U.S. Supreme Court.
Holmes is accused of murdering 12 people and wounding dozens at the midnight premiere of a Batman movie in an Aurora theater on July 20, 2012.
The three motions submitted to Arapahoe County Judge Carlos Samour constitute an exhaustive legal broadside on Colorado's capital punishment laws.
One motion states : "Mr. Holmes has a fundamental right to not be put to death under a system in which geography, income, race, gender, venue, the status of the victim, and a host of other arbitrary, extra-judicial factors have the most influence on whether a defendant lives or dies."
The deputy state public defenders claim Holmes is more likely to face the death penalty in Arapahoe County than in most other counties in Colorado. In the past decade the state has sought the death penalty against suspected murderers 11 times; of those, 8 were in the 18th Judicial District, where Holmes will be tried.
"Several months ago, when presented with the impending execution of death row inmate Nathan Dunlap, Governor John Hickenlooper granted him a reprieve, relying heavily on the fact that a defendant's likelihood of facing the death penalty in Colorado depends largely on the jurisdiction in which his case arose," the first motion states.
That motion quotes Hickenlooper as saying: "As one former judge said to us, '[the death penalty] is simply the result of happenstance, the district attorney's choice, the jurisdiction in which the case is filed, perhaps the race or economic circumstance of the defendant.'" (Brackets in complaint.)
In a second motion , the defense claims that Colorado's punishment for capital murder is cruel and unusual as defined by state and federal law.
"In measuring and assessing contemporary standards of decency, one important consideration is whether there is a decline in the use of a practice," the second motion states. "Throughout the country and in Colorado, the death penalty is in steep and consistent decline.
"Across the country, states are abandoning the death penalty. In 2004, the courts declared the death penalty to be unconstitutional in New York. In 2007, New Jersey repealed its death penalty law, with New Mexico following suit in 2009, Illinois in 2011, Connecticut in 2012, and Maryland in 2013. In several other states, there has been a de facto moratorium on executions for many years. In 2013, a majority of Nebraska lawmakers voted to repeal the death penalty, but the bill died because of a filibuster by opponents.
"Even the very architects of the modern capital scheme have given up. In 2010, the American Law Institute withdrew its support for the model capital sentencing stature it had drafted, citing 'intractable institutional and structural obstacles to ensuring a minimally adequate system for administering capital punishment.'"
Death sentences have declined by 56 percent nationwide since 1999. Colorado has executed just one inmate since 1967, the second motion states.