Updates to our Terms of Use

We are updating our Terms of Use. Please carefully review the updated Terms before proceeding to our website.

Tuesday, April 23, 2024 | Back issues
Courthouse News Service Courthouse News Service

After Trump, Youngkin Offers Fresh Challenge to Virginia Democrats’ Gubernatorial Hopes

While embracing some of the base's wildest attacks, Virginia’s Republican gubernatorial candidate has avoided Trump despite earning the former president’s praises.

RICHMOND, Va. (CN) — Jim Wilson stood next to his white Chevy Silverado, covered in American flags and signs for Virginia Republican gubernatorial candidate Glenn Youngkin, and tapped out a wooden pipe. 

He pointed to a faded sticker from Mitt Romney’s 2012 presidential campaign and said the Utah Senator gave him the truck after “union goons” burned down his old one as Wilson worked the failed campaign in Pennsylvania, 

“I started [working campaigns] with Eisenhower with my dad in Iowa; there’s an addiction and there’s no cure,” said the 79-year-old Buckingham, Virginia, resident of his love of campaigning. 

And while Wilson smiled when he said he worked on the last three successful Virginia GOP gubernatorial races, he frowned a bit when he admitted to skipping former President Donald Trump’s reelection campaign. 

“Doesn’t matter now cause he’s history,” Wilson snarled when asked why he sat 2020 out. He also notes he never worked for any tea party “loons.”

“If you don’t nominate a loon, you win,” Wilson said as the conversation returned to Youngkin, the first candidate for governor he’s supported in years; his name adorns Wilson’s truck. 

“Glenn’s a breath of fresh air,” he said, taking a drag from his pipe. “He’s not a politician; he’s sincere.” 

Wilson is the kind of voter Youngkin needs to attract. 

It’s been over a decade since a Republican won a state-wide race in Virginia, but supporters like Wilson, who calls himself and his vehicle the campaign’s “mother trucker,” hope Youngkin can break that streak. 

Changing demographics in Virginia’s formerly-conservative suburbs and attacks on immigrants and federal workers who dominate the state’s increasingly diverse Washington, D.C. suburbs led to Trump losing the once-purple state by 10 points in 2020. 

This legacy has former Democratic Governor Terry McAullife, barred from a consecutive term under state law but hoping to reclaim his seat this fall, energized. Youngkin has avoided any discussion of the former president.

He’s gone as far as refusing to respond to questions about the three endorsements Trump has given the candidate since his primary win in May. Instead he’s pushed a folksy businessman’s image, concerned about failing schools and liberal indoctrination, even after spending $12.4 million of his $300 million personal fortune on his own campaign. 

“Everywhere we go, more and more people are standing up and saying ‘No, we’re not going toward that left-liberal, progressive agenda anymore,’” said the former Carlyle Group executive to a packed house Tuesday in Richmond’s Southside.

“No CRT in Virginia schools!” he shouted about a promised fight against Critical Race Theory, the latest conservative boogeyman over a doctorate-level legal philosophy that is not taught in any Virginia public K-12 school.

The crowd offered their most enthusiastic chant of the event back: “No CRT!” 

The speech worked on Randy Walker, a Richmond native and retired security consultant who hopes Youngkin will push back on Virginia Democrats who won complete control over the state’s government for the first time in 20 years just two years ago. 

Walker called the changes, which included mandatory background checks for gun purchases, expanded voting access, legalized marijuana and criminal justice reform, “the abyss we have in the state right now.”

“I’m not against immigration, I’m against illegal immigration,” he said, mistakenly accusing the left of giving “free education to illegals” after they granted in-state tuition for undocumented students. 

“I was born and raised here and I know the monuments on Monument Avenue were all Confederates, but it’s history,” Walker said of Democrats’ successful efforts to remove statutes of Civil War generals, including one who said of Black people “that slavery subordination to the superior race is his natural and normal condition.” 

ADVERTISEMENT

Claims like these may attract the party’s base, but they have pushed those in the middle away.

Matt Walton is a former Virginia GOP nominee for the state’s House of Delegates who left the party after Trump’s presidency and his “big lie” about the 2020 election.

“You’ve got a party that keeps going to the right, expecting to do well, but voters in Virginia are changing,” Walton said in a phone interview, before noting that though he liked Youngkin’s conservative takes on business, he was dumbfounded by the candidate’s inability to swear off Trump.

And then there was a recent video captured by a Democratic party operative which showed Youngkin saying he would make abortion illegal if he won, but he couldn’t speak against the practice during the campaign as it would alienate the state’s moderate base. 

“Any time you hide or make a comment like that, you’re saying there’s something about me you don’t know,” Walton said. “It's a disservice to the electorate, an insult to them.”

But as concerned as Walton is, he thinks recent history has shown Virginia voters will see through Youngkin like he does, and if they don’t, he argues changes to state voting laws will help secure a win for McAuliffe. 

Democrat Schuyler VanValkenburg is a state delegate from a Richmond suburb and one of the architects of those election law changes. He came to power as part of 2017’s “Blue Wave,” which saw the Virginia House of Delegates flip as the state’s voters rebelled against Trump.

“Mail-in voting doesn’t help one party over the other, despite the lies of the last president,” he said in a phone interview. “It encourages people to vote and that makes for a healthy democracy.” 

VanValkenburg also said he expected forthcoming campaign efforts, including his own when he runs this fall, will include encouraging voters to vote by mail.

“You won’t see people collecting ballots, but they’ll call to make sure they’re getting in the mail, similar to if you knock on a door to encourage them to vote in person,” he said, noting state law now mails absentee ballots 45 days before election day with a stamped envelope for easy return. 

And while VanValkenburg “doesn’t buy the narrative that more voters means Democrats win,” the look of disgust on Youngkin fans’ faces during Tuesday’s event after the Republican mentioned early voting might not bode well for his ability to match Democrats’ vote-by-mail efforts.

“It’s easy to cheat on mail-in ballots,” Walker said before he refused to ever vote absentee. 

Still, the standing room-only crowd, and returning Republican voters like Wilson, could spell trouble for McAullife. 

And Youngkin’s tiptoeing around Trump hasn’t stopped the former governor from poking the bear. 

“Since Glenn is too [chicken] to face me, I hereby challenge his inspiration for running, Donald Trump to debate me,” tweeted McAullife after Youngkin broke a 36-year tradition by refusing to debate before the Virginia Bar Association after he discovered the moderator, acclaimed PBS anchor Judy Woodruff, donated $250 to the Clinton Foundation’s Haitian earthquake relief fund.

“It would be a conflict of interest to have former Clinton Foundation board member Terry McAuliffe being ‘questioned’ by a Clinton Foundation donor,” Youngkin said in a statement Monday. 

Meanwhile, McAullife is doing everything he can to bring Trump to Virginia. Walton and Wilson hope Trump won’t take the bait, but Rich Anderson, a former delegate and the current chair of the state’s Republican party, said Tuesday they’d welcome the former president if he decided to come. 

“Of course we’d welcome the former leader of the Republican party, that’s the Virginia way,” he said after Youngkin’s event. “Mr. Trump has a mind of his own. If that takes him on a visit to Virginia, who knows.”

Virginia’s polls close November 2.

Follow Brad Kutner on Twitter

Follow @@BradKutner
Categories / Government, Politics

Subscribe to Closing Arguments

Sign up for new weekly newsletter Closing Arguments to get the latest about ongoing trials, major litigation and hot cases and rulings in courthouses around the U.S. and the world.

Loading...