Updates to our Terms of Use

We are updating our Terms of Use. Please carefully review the updated Terms before proceeding to our website.

Wednesday, June 12, 2024 | Back issues
Courthouse News Service Courthouse News Service

Doctor’s Death Unleashes Fury at Chinese Leaders

The death of a doctor who was reprimanded for being the first to warn about China's new virus triggered an outpouring of praise for him Friday and fury that Communist authorities put politics above public safety.

BEIJING (AP) — The death of a doctor who was reprimanded for being the first to warn about China's new virus triggered an outpouring of praise for him Friday and fury that Communist authorities put politics above public safety.

In death, Dr. Li Wenliang became the face of simmering anger at the ruling Communist Party's controls over information, and complaints that officials lie about and hide disease outbreaks, chemical spills, dangerous consumer products and financial frauds.

The 34-year-old ophthalmologist died overnight at Wuhan Central Hospital, where he worked and probably contracted the virus while treating patients in the early days of the outbreak.

"A hero who released information about Wuhan's epidemic in the early stage, Dr. Li Wenliang is immortal," the China Center for Disease Control's chief scientist, Zeng Guang, wrote on the Sina Weibo microblog service.

Police in December reprimanded eight doctors, including Li, for warning friends on social media about the emerging threat. China’s supreme court later criticized the police, but the ruling party has tightened its grip on information about the outbreak.

Weibo users have left hundreds of thousands of messages below Li's last post.

A post by one of Li's coworkers, an emergency room nurse, said the freezing Wuhan weather was "as gloomy as my mood."

"To you, we are angels and so strong. But how strong a heart can watch the people around me fall one by one without being shocked?" wrote Li Mengping on her verified account.

Others placed blame for the deaths on Chinese officials, not an animal species from where the virus might have spread, and said those who made trouble for the doctor should face consequences.

The most pointed online comments were quickly deleted by censors.

The Chinese Communist Party has faced similar accusations of bungling or thuggish behavior after previous disasters. They include the 2003 outbreak of severe acute respiratory syndrome, a 2005 chemical spill that disrupted water supplies to millions of people in China’s northeast, sales of tainted milk that sickened thousands of children, and the failure of private finance companies after the global economic crisis.

In each case, officials were accused of trying to conceal or delay release of information that members of the public said they needed to protect themselves.

The party often responds by allowing the public to vent temporarily, then uses its control of media and the internet to stifle criticism. Critics who persist can be jailed on vague charges of spreading rumors or making trouble — charges to which Dr. Li was forced to “confess.”

On the streets of Beijing, residents expressed sadness and said that China should learn from Li.

"He is such a nice person, but still didn't pull through," said Ning Yanqing. "Those left do not dare to speak out. Alas, I don't know what to say."

Some online comments Friday hinted at broader dissatisfaction with the party and President Xi Jinping, who has tightened controls on society since taking power in 2012.

The most powerful Chinese leader since the 1980s, Xi gave himself the option of remaining president for life by changing the Chinese constitution in 2018 to remove a two-term limit.

Referring to one of Xi's propaganda initiatives, a message that circulated on social media said, "My 'Chinese Dream' is broken."

In Wuhan, local leaders were accused of telling doctors in December not to publicize the spreading virus to avoid casting a shadow over the annual meeting of a local legislative body.

As the virus spread, doctors were ordered to delete posts on social media that appealed for donations of medical supplies. That prompted complaints that authorities were more worried about image than public safety.

Li was detained by police after warning about the virus on a social media group for his former classmates.

The episode is unusually awkward for the ruling party because Li was a physician, part of a group who are regarded as overworked, underpaid heroes who are China's line of defense against a frightening new disease.

"He showed a responsible attitude toward the society," said Cai Lin, a Beijing resident. "He is honest and faithful. So I think the whole society should reflect on this."

The World Health Organization, which has complimented China's response to the outbreak, said in a tweet that "We are deeply saddened by the passing of Dr. Li Wenliang. We all need to celebrate work that he did" on the virus.

The official propaganda apparatus tried to mollify the public on Friday.

"Some of Li Wenliang's experiences during his life reflect shortcomings and deficiencies in epidemic prevention and control," state television said on its website.

The Chinese ambassador to Washington, Cui Tiankai, said on Twitter, which the Chinese government blocks the public from seeing: "Really saddened by the death of Dr. Li Wenliang. He was a very devoted doctor. We are so grateful to him for what he has done in our joint efforts fighting against #2019nCoV."

The government said a team from Beijing will be sent to Wuhan to investigate "issues reported by the masses involving Dr. Li Wenliang."

Categories / Health, International, Science

Subscribe to Closing Arguments

Sign up for new weekly newsletter Closing Arguments to get the latest about ongoing trials, major litigation and hot cases and rulings in courthouses around the U.S. and the world.